Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Wobbly Table Inserts

Posts

Wobbly Table Inserts

#1

Wobbly Table Inserts

Bob S

Wobbly table insert - Please help

I made two 16" leaf(s) for a Pine Trestle Table that my Father made years ago. The inserts are 40" by 16" by 1.5" thickness. So, I had to plane the 8/4 rough-cut lumber down to 1.5". In my haste (and extreme cold), I was more concerned with aligning the top of the table than the underside. And the boards were not as flat as I had hoped. Needless to say, they do not sit flat now, and are basically un-useable. Rather than start over, I want to try to repair what I have. I have ample width (they are 16" wide, but 14-15" will suffice). I have very minimal height to shave off, but I could shim the underside.

So.... My big question is, how to slice up the table tops and try to best orient them so the flatness is improved. Is this even possible? I figured if I cut them into 4 or 5 e" pieces , I may be able to re-glue them up and get by. A few passes in the planer (10" max) may help out.

Any help will be appreciated. If I can't make them do, I will rebuy lumber. I bought cheap furniture grade pine to match what my Dad made the table out of. I hate working with pine!

Bob S.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#2

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Make a router jig and cut dados parallel to the top surface on the underside where they will rest on the table slides. Then make a filler piece out of similar wood such that the grain aligns with the grain in your leaf. Make this filler thick enough that you can trim it to be parallel to the top surface and get rid of the wobble. Glue the filler piece in place and finish it.


Lee

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#3

I need clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What exactly is the problem? I could interpret that the 16" boards are twisted and hence do not lie flat. But then you mentioned something about the "underside". Are these single boards or something you glued up?

I could have told you how to get the pieces flat to begin with but if the lumber is already at the final thickness there is no way to remove twist without loosing thickness.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#4

Re: I need clarification

Bob S

Bill / All,

Sorry for less than thorough depiction of problem.

I bought rough sawn 8/4 x 6" boards, and glued them up into 16" wide panels.

Finished height is 1.5".

I can cut them length wise and re-glue. Losing width not a problem, will just need skinnier people to sit in those positions!

Height is at finished height now. (1.5"). But if need be, I can plane some height off, and restore it or make up for it underneath (it won't be noticed since there is a lower lip on the outer perimeter of the table).

Thanks, and I appreciate the help immensely.

Bob

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#5

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

Bob S

Lee - Great idea. Maybe more than I'm up for now, but I love the idea. The table is not located near me, so the back and forth to try to get the right adjustment maybe too difficult.

Thanks!

Bob

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#6

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

Barry Irby

As Lee and Bill have indicated, there are lots of ways to do this, depending on your skill and the tools available. A router sled and hand planes will both work. Perhaps looking on Youtube will help, but keep in mind that not everyone posting on Youtube actually has a good Idea or knows what they are doing.

Here is a totally different thought. There is a good chance you don't have to worry about the final thickness. Let's say you want the leaf to be 1 1/2" thick, but you end up with 1 1/4" Take some scrap stock and reduce it to 1/4" and apply it to the ends under the bottom. Keep the grain running parallel to the original, so that you will see all end grain from the end. This avoids the cross grain problem and if you fiddle with the alignment on the end can be nearly invisible. The added laminations could run back to and rest on the table frame or just far enough not to be noticeable to someone sitting there who happens to touch the underside. If additional support is necessary you could add little "feet" to rest on the frame or make the classic dowels to insert into the surrounding top. This could also have the benefit of making the leaf lighter.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#7

Shims and hand plane.

Virgil Johnson

Shim the underside on diagonals until the insert does not rock and the high points on the insert are balanced between the sections. Plane off the material on top side that does not align with the original top. Minimal tools needed.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

Ellis Walentine

I'd get the top surfaces as flat as possible, preferably on a wide jointer, but, failing that, properly shimmed up on a planer sled. Of course, if you're skilled with a long handplane (say a #6 or 7), you can flatten them with that. Forget about the underside, unless you are prepared to plane it to thickness and add back whatever you lost in the flattening.

Next, get some alignment pins. I haven't bought any in a while, but they are available as male/female sets that you install in drilled holes in the edges of the tabletops and leaves. Make a drilling template that you can use to drill the holes at the correct spacing and distance from the reference (top) surface. Typically, this would be a long strip of 2x2 with tabs or an overhanging cleat on the top to clamp to the reference surfaces when drilling.

Once installed, the leaves should be usable as is, with or without reestablishing the thickness. You'll probably want to install a couple suitcase latches or Dzus fasteners under the table to keep all the parts tightly joined and aligned.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#9

Hand plane and winding sticks

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The hand plane is used to traverse the underside of the table top - that is, plane across the grain. You only need to plane a wide enough strip for each trestle top.

The winding sticks are to ensure that the levels are coplanar. You sight across them to determine this is so.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#10

Easily flatening twist

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I still am still not sure what the problem is but presuming it is twist as others are speculating..........

I routinely and easily flatten twisted boards wider than my 8" jointer. It was required when we built the book shelf and the picture shows the critical step.

1. Lay board on flat surface and mark the high corners (they will be diagonal) the piece is teetering on.

2. Secure board to bench with these marked corners up.



3. With a scrub plane or any other plane mow off some to all of the high corners. On a 10" wide board I might mow off a strip 8" long and 2" wide tapering to 0 over the 10" length. My scrub plane is simply an old Stanely #5 with a blade severely ground convex (probably 3/32" at edges. ) The result does not have to be anything close to perfect.

4. Place on flat surface and see how much it teeters. If it doesn't, with this side down plane it. ***The key here is that you just need to get the tips of the high corners in the same plane as the low corners. *** the whole surface does not need to be made flat with the plane!

5. If it still teeters some run it across the jointer, flattened side down. You might have to remove the guard(scary) so be very careful. Then hand plane off the ridge the jointer left. Proceed to Step 4.

Every piece of the book shelf was severely twisted but we were able to flatten each piece as described above. The key here is that the planer will flatten some so the previous steps just need to get it close.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#11

Another idea

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I had another thought, not quite as complex, but it should work since the table is at a remote location. Since your top is 1-1/2 thick take some 3/4" flat head screws and screw them up into the leaf from the bottom over the table slides where you need to fill a gap. Use the screw as a miniature jack to support the leaf on the table slide rails. You should be able to go from completely flush to add 1/4" or more where you need it to eliminate the wobble.

Lee

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#12

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

In my haste (and extreme cold), I was more concerned with aligning the top of the table than the underside. And the boards were not as flat as I had hoped. Needless to say, they do not sit flat now, and are basically un-useable.

Bob, I will repeat something that I consider vitally important, as no one else has mentioned this, and no one commented when I did earlier on.

The two strips where the trestle table will join must be coplanar otherwise the table will wobble.

It is not enough for these sections to be flat.

Usually, when flattening boards for a panel, the entire length is coplanar. You have to find a way to make this happen where the legs join the underside of the table top. The the legs are attached to a trestle, there are strips across the panel that must be flattened coplanar to one another.

The way to do this is with winding sticks. These are common tools for hand tools users. See my other post.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#13

Unclear

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bob has yet to confirm that the problem is twist, or some other combination of problems.

But if it is twist your solution to the bottom is quick and easy, and will leave the top not in a plane of the rest of the table. If the problem is twist the top side is going to have to be untwisted to be coplanar with the rest of the table top. And if one side gets untwisted, he might as well run the resultr through the planer to make both sides flat and parallel, and thinner.

If these leaves are to be used occasionally I would rip the glue joint, flatten each piece on the jointer (take the twist out if the problem is twist), run through planer to get both sides parallel and reglue. The result will be thinner but so what for an occasionally used leaf. Just add a filler strip, or blocks to bring the top of these leaves to table top height, located wherever the leaf is supported below.

Re: Wobbly Table Inserts

#14

Re: Unclear

George Koch

I'm wondering if Bob S is trying to keep these leafs aligned with each other and the existing table top without the commonly used dowel pins and corresponding holes in the edges of leafs and table. If so, I think, with changes in climate and humidity when stored, this will be a problem each time the leafs are used and in what order they are place. What method is now used to keep the leafs in place?