Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

question for you heating experts

Posts

question for you heating experts

#1

question for you heating experts

john lucas

I'm trying to save heating costs in my shop. It's heated with natural gas. So here's my question. Which saves the most heat. I used to lower the heat to 50 at night and then warm it back up to 62 in the morning. Lately I have been shutting the heater off so the shop gets down to about 40 buy morning. I remember one time a friend who was in heating said that if you leave the heat on it uses fewer BTU's to maintain that heat than it does to bring everything back up to temp by turning the heat down at night. Anybody out there who really knows this stuff have an opinion. I notice that my heater thermostat has a minimum setting of 50 if you leave it on. My shop is well insulated. It was 10 when got up this morning and had been very windy all night so the wind chill was much lower I'm sure. The shop was 38 when I walked in to turn the heat on.

Re: question for you heating experts

#2

Re: question for you heating experts

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have never seen a legitimate study of which method uses the less fuel. However, I leave the thermostat on about 65 Deg. all winter. My shop is 30' X 30' with an 8' high X 9' wide insulated door and a standard entrance door. My shop is super insulated with 6" walls. I installed HVAC equipment for many years as a side job, so installed a high efficiency furnace and central air upstairs in the shop. My gas bill includes the furnace and water heater in my old (1800's) 4 bedroom home as well as the shop, so I can only estimate the additional cost incurred after starting to heat my shop. As a rough estimate the heating costs for an average month (natural gas) runs about $40 - $60 in added cost.

One issue more important to me than trying to save $10 or $20 a month is trying to eliminate moisture condensation on all the cast Iron surfaces in the shop. I have seen people spend more money and time trying to eliminate rust then the cost of my heating.

Re: question for you heating experts

#3

Re: question for you heating experts

Mark Nowicki

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/heatloss.html#c1

http://www.calculator.net/btu-calculator.html?roomwidth=20&roomwidthunit=feet&roomlength=20&roomlengthunit=feet&ceilingheight=8&ceilingheightunit=feet&insulation=good&temperature=40&temperatureunit=f&calctype=heat&x=117&y=18

It is a zero sum game.

There is no "cheaper BTU" or "better BTU". The amount of heat lost has to replaced by the same amount.

Re: question for you heating experts

#4

Re: question for you heating experts

Bill Howatt

You can have a look at this Cdn Gov't Publication:

https://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/en/co/grho/grho_002.cfm

They say there is a benefit and just about everybody I know has a setback thermostat for lower temperatures at night.

Bill

Re: question for you heating experts

#5

Re: question for you heating experts

John K Jordan

It might be different if you heated with a heat pump rather than gas if it is one that uses electric aux/emergency strip heaters to bring up the temperature. I can't see that there would be an extra cost with gas bringing the temperature up from 40 rather than 50. I expect you will save money by turning off the gas all night - the longer it is off the lower the heat differential and the amount of heat leaking through the insulation. You might contact the Oak Ridge National Lab with this question - they have a building sciences division with a mandate to assist the public and industry with such issues.

Or can you monitor the gas consumption for a couple of weeks of similar temperatures, one with the thermostat lowered and one with it off?

Adding more insulation to the ceiling can help a lot, if there is room for it.

JKJ

Re: question for you heating experts

#6

that is half the story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The amount of heat lost has to replaced by the same amount. "

That is only half the consideration. The other half is how much heat does it take to maintain some lower "rest" temperature when the shop in not in use, as well as the rate of heat loss vs shop temperature.

Heat loss depends on the difference between inside and outside temperature. Therefore, the amount of heat loss is clearly less over the time between when the heat is turned down or off and when it is turned back on vs leaving it on. The heat to get back up to temperature is the sum of the heat loss while heating back up and the heat capacity of the building and its stuff times the temperature difference.

Consider the extreme case. Turn heat off for 1, 2, 3 4, etc days, vs not turning it off, followed by heating back up. It is easy to see in this case that the total heat for a day in the shop heated is much less if the heat is turned off for some number of days. Additionally, the sum of all the mass of the shop may never get heated back to equilibrium at working temperature if the work session in the shop is only a few hours.

If using a heat pump there are complications involving efficiency vs operating temperature. But for your case the system works at identical efficiency whether you are heating in the AM or mid day.

Another consideration is YOUR efficiency. If you turn the heat off and it takes 2 hours to get warm enough that you can work efficiently this loss of working time enters the heat cost equation.

It would good to know what your shop heating cost is per year. Saving 10% of $200 isn't worth worrying about, especially given that this heat situation must affect how you work in the shop. If it takes 2 hours to get warm enough to work, the shop will be used less than if it can be made useable in 15 minutes or 0 minutes.

I keep the shop in my basement because it remains available for work at all times. I can utilize it in 15 minute increments when convenient.

Re: question for you heating experts

#7

Re: question for you heating experts

Tony-Memphis

I've had the same question. Also abut AC. When my wife was working, we let the temp go up (or down, whichever) and then return to our comfort setting abut the time we got home from work. When she retired, I was sure that the utility bill would go up because she was at home and we changed the program. But, it really didn't change best i can tell. There are so many variables there that it is hard to know, but there has been no noticeable trend. I also noticed that the house is more comfortable. In the summer, the unit would run and run and run to cool the house down, but it seems to run much less now. So, I wondered if maintaining a temperature used less energy that trying to make up the delta.

My shop has a unique issue. If I let the temp stay high in the summer, the humidity goes way up. So, I run a dehumidifier. So, I've wondered if it would be better to keep the temp lower and let the ac remove the humidity instead.

I'm a mechanical engineer and my focus was energy systems, but I have not done much related to that stuff in many years (stuck in IT at a large corp. - yes, very Dilbert like!). Interesting stuff. I think it is kind of like the chicken and egg or the chicken crossing the road...we'll probably never know! One thing I can say for sure though - my shop is 16x20 and insulated very well - it holds the heat in (or out) very well. Glad for that. I keep it comfortable 24x7 and our utility bills are very reasonable. Of course, we live in Memphis and we have very good rates here. I've been tempted to add some more insulation to the house attic. We had the walls skim sprayed with foam and batting installed, but the windows are cheap. Wish I had a FLIR so I could find all the leaks.

Another thing I've wondered about is the value of storm windows. Now, that's a relative thing with lots of variables too. Our house is ~20 years old with aluminum dual pane windows. No air movement, but the heat does travel through that aluminum quite well!

Tony

Re: question for you heating experts

#8

Re: question for you heating experts

Barry Irby

In the case of gas, a BTU is a BTU, not so for heat pump's.

If you turn the heat down at night and back up in the morning you have to replace the heat that escaped in the night dollar for dollar. But, as you turn the temp lower less and less heat escapes in proportion to the temperature differential.

This is much more complicated than that. In a reasonably well insulated building most of the heat loss is from air leakage. Warm air escapes and is replaced by cold air. this is reduced by doing an excellent job of sealing. In a shop there is probably not much moisture vapor being generated. (no cooking or bathing, no hanging plants.) But, you transpire a pound or two of moisture vapor every "day" you are in there. If you let it cool down at night you may get condensation on iron and steel surfaces leading to rust. There may be plenty of moisture rising through the slab.

I would turn it down to maybe 60 degrees at night and watch closely for condensation. I really don't think there will be much savings going lower.

Re: question for you heating experts

#9

Re: question for you heating experts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"In a reasonably well insulated building most of the heat loss is from air leakage."

It takes 10 cubic feet of natural gas to heat all the air in a 2000 sqft house from freezing to typical room temperature. 1000 cuft of gas is about $4. Translating to the shop, unless the door is open it is not costing much to keep the shop warm if air leakage is the main heating need..

Re: question for you heating experts

#10

Windows

GolfSteve in Calgary

Tony, my house had aluminum slider windows which were replaced with triple pane PVC frame casement windows about 10 years ago. The new windows are also coated with magic that reduces heat transmission etc etc etc according to the sales documents.

Anyway, the new PVC windows are wonderful compared to my old aluminium sliders. The benefit in the winter is that the frames and windows no longer frost up. Even at -30 deg C I only get minor condensation at the bottom of the window panes.

However the major improvement is in the summer. With the old windows the house would turn into an oven on a hot summer day. When it cooled off at night, the sliders were useless at pulling a breeze into the house.

With the new PVC framed triple pane windows, heat input to the house has been greatly reduced in the summer. Very noticeable improvement! When it cools off the casement windows are much better at pulling a breeze into the house.

Additionally the new windows noticeably reduce noise transmission into the house. I live on a busy and noisy street so this was very welcome.

Finally, the PVC windows are maintenance free. No more scraping and painting the old wood that framed the aluminum windows.

In short, replacing my aluminum sliders with top-of-the-line mid-price-range PVC casement windows was one of the best things I've done to my house.

Re: question for you heating experts

#11

Thermal mass

Dick Coers

I didn't read all the replies, but was the thermal mass of all the cast iron considered? If any studies were done, I doubt if they considered the warming of the mass of cast iron in your shop. I personally wouldn't drop it too far at night. It's pretty tough to raise the the temperature of 1000 pounds of cast iron. It will radiate the cold for a long time after the air temperature has been raised. The humidity is really low right now, but latter you could also risk some condensation issues.

Re: question for you heating experts

#12

Re: Thermal mass

john lucas

Very interesting reading. The reason I ask is the gas bill for my shop was $127 last month. This month the weather is colder. If i turn the heater down to 50 at night you can feel the difference in the machines in the morning after I warm up the shop. they are definitely warmer than when I leave the heat off all night and the shop cools down to 38 to 42 or so. Takes about 20 minutes or so to heat the shop thermometer which is all the way across the room from the heater and it's thermostat. That's from 50. From 38 it took maybe 35 or 40 minutes this morning. It seems like it cycles more for the first few hours when the shop is left cold. I assume that's from the machines being so cold but maybe not.

Re: question for you heating experts

#13

Re: question for you heating experts

Barry Irby

I may be wrong, but I think 3 Air Changes per Hour (ACH) is a fairly common rate for many houses that were not extensively sealed. If a 1000 CF of Gas costs $4 then 10 CF would cost $.04, Or about 12 cents an hour/ $2.88 a day or $86 a month.

This assumes a constant 32 degrees outside and steady wind and whatever. Running vent fans, hood fans, dryers, etc has an effect. As does occupancy, opening doors, etc. Very hard to make firm calculations. But even half that is a pretty serious bite on your gas bill.

Newer well sealed houses have about 1 ACH. If they're sealed much better than that they may need an Air to Air heat exchanger to introduce fresh air. Too many variables. How many people live in the house? How much laundry do they do? Do they use the dryer, vented out side, or hang things out to dry inside. What kind of cooking? Simmer things for long hours? Is the crawl space wet? (A big one) It goes on and on.

Re: question for you heating experts

#14

Re: Thermal mass

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Are you heating with propane or natural gas? That seems an astonishing amount. We don't spend $100/month to heat our 2500 sq ft home.

Of course you get cycling when the shop stats cold. It is not just the machines warming up, which are a piddly mass compared to the walls, floor, ceiling or the building, basically the entire weight of the shop and its floor.

Re: question for you heating experts

#15

Re: Thermal mass

john lucas

Natural gas.

Re: question for you heating experts

#16

Re: question for you heating experts

Pete in Holland MI

Yup, there is the recovery time to heat up all the stuff in the room. Setting the temperature back in an insulated shop does save money, but how far you set it back depends on how long you'll be gone. If you're a weekend warrior, then set it back a lot. If just over night, don't go much. A lot also depends on how tight the building is. A tight building will hold the heat better, but a loose building will lose all the heat to cracks & crevices anyway.

In our house, I set the temp back from 70 to 62 at night for better sleeping. It is up for an hour or so as we get ready for work, then back down to 65 during the day. Used to set the day time temp back to 62, but was not comfortable when we got home.

The lower overall base temperature you can keep it, the better. Nothing wrong with a sweatshirt.

Also, how much of your shop is really needed to be heated? Can you "wall off" storage areas with plastic sheeting........heating a "smaller" room ?

Pete

Re: question for you heating experts

#17

Good info!

Tony-Memphis

Our house was built in '98. What they did 'round here was use an all aluminum window (lowest bidder) - there is no trim on the outside. These are typical "cookie cutter" suburb houses. On the other hand, I had a buddy at work that bought in a 'fancy' neighborhood - he had to replce every window in the house because of rot. At least my aluminum will not rot. They are 0 maintenance. Can't complain about that. And we've only had one lose its seal and that is in my shop, so I don't care.

We were watching This Old House last night where they were replacing windows. I don't know how we/they would go about replacing these windows - the flanges are behind the brick. Not a good way to do things, but that was the thing (still the same here). Despite some shortcomings like that, the place was a good value.

Still wondering if adding storm windows would help much. When my folks bought a house in this area back in '83 or so, there was a special deal from the power company. I guess it was like a very low interest loan. Wish we could get a deal like that. I've looked around and haven't even had much luck finding a company that sells/installs storm windows. Thought about installing the internal kind even. Thing is, given the market, we can't afford to sink much more in this place. Hate that. I want to save energy and be comfortable. Next time....

Tony (at least we are on the way out of our recent permafrost experience!)

Re: question for you heating experts

#18

Re: Good info! (replacement windows)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As I recall, if you ever feel the need to replace your windows, the replacement type fits inside the existing casing. In other words the existing flange can be cut, the old windows removed and the replacement fitted to the opening that is left, fastened to the casing (screws parallel to the glass, then trimmed out.