Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT - Electrical Question

Posts

OT - Electrical Question

#1

OT - Electrical Question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

Is this considered acceptable?

In my basement there is an outlet installed (20+ years ago before I bought the house) on the wall. You can see in the pictures it is a metal box with a short run up to the sill plate. Where the conduit ends, you can see where romex (is that the right word?) exits the conduit. That romex, attached to the floor joists, then heads over to the panel box.

Is this acceptable practice?

Thanks in advance!

#1


#2


Re: OT - Electrical Question

#2

Re: OT - Electrical Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That's the way it's done. The wire runs in conduit "until it enters the structure's framing", even though the framing is open and accessible.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#3

Re: OT - Electrical Question

JohnV

The purpose of the "hard" casing is to protect the wire from abrasion / damage where it is more vulnerable.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#5

Depends on your local code

Dick Coers

Our son lives in Chicago. All wiring needs to be in conduit from the outlet to the breaker box.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#6

Re: Depends on your local code

Dave Bair

Code does not allow NMS cable to run in conduit; it's a potential over-heating issue.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#7

Chapter and verse?

Henry Higginbotham

So far, I've been unable to find in either in my 2002 NEC or by an internet search. But that doesn't mean it's not there, of course.

In any case, we're talking about a very short run (although maybe more than the magic 600mm), and the conduit is open at the top, so I doubt any electrical inspector would say anything unless you were already on his bad side. In this specific case, the abrasion protection probably outranks any slight heat considerations.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#8

Re: Chapter and verse?

Chuck Kettler

Amen

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#9

Re: Depends on your local code

ken combs

I have always understood that it can be run in conduit But, the conduit fill calculations must be done using the widest dimension of the cable. So, only 1 12/2 in a 1/2" conduit!

If you have a NEC citation that contradicts that, I'd appreciate the reference.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#10

Re: OT - Electrical Question

T.M. Stock

As mentioned, physical protection (EMT, RMC, etc.) is required in some circumstances for NMC (e.g., passing between floors) and permitted unless prohibited by some further local authority. Our local code guys don't like to see it because the conductors are not labeled once the sheathing is removed, but they allow NMC in interior conduit provided there is sheathing to the first box...which sounds silly, but they claim it's the only way they can verify conductor size and temp rating. THHN is more expensive, but less hassle if you have to keep the permitting folks happy.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#11

Re: Depends on your local code

Dave Bair

It was brought to my attention by the local electrical inspector about 2002 when I was building my shop. I don't have a code citation. I do recall, now, that there was a calculation involved which required larger conduit than I was contemplating.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#12

Conduit fill

John in NM

Sounds to me like the inspector mis-applied a conduit fill table or calculation.

There is a limit to the number of current conducting wires you can jam into a conduit, because inside a conduit heat from each of those conductors dissipates more slowly than in open air. On the other hand, since the bulk of the fill from using romex is inert as far as current carrying goes, I can't imagine that the application was correct. Basically, you had two current conductors in a 1/2" conduit.

For my own convenience, I strip the outside insulation back to just a few inches into the conduit. Pulling romex through conduit sucks, might as well make it easy to work with.

FWIW, I'm not an electrician, I've just pulled a lot of wire.

Re: OT - Electrical Question

#13

Re: OT - Electrical Question

Jay Lombardo

Being a Chicago electrician myself, that's not the way we would do it here, but as someone mentioned Chicago requires everything in conduit. What you have there is perfectly acceptable for areas that allow Romex. I can tell you from 45 years experience any inspector can knock over any installation if he wants to and you have given him a case of the red arse but this should be fine.