Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Christmas project book shelf, and question

Posts

Christmas project book shelf, and question

#1

Christmas project book shelf, and question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

PIC 1



By design I prepared nothing for this learning exercise with granddaughter(10). We began with the need-book shelf. We measured books to see how far apart to make the shelves. Then we sketched a possible design. Next added up dimensions to see how high the sides needed to be(good exercise in dealing with fractions). (The piece of cherry lumber had been selected before she arrived). It was from a blow down tree her uncle and I logged last year. It was a "sow's ear" to be made into a "silk purse". It was warped, twisted, bowed, sappy and with bark edges.

PIC2



Step 1 was to mow off the high corners to begin the process of flattening the pieces.

PIC 3



It is held together with dovetails and tenons.



I think I should round off the front corner of the side? Why do you all think?

It remains to be stained(she wanted it stained) and finish. Will do that step when it is warmer than single digits.

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#2

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

William Duffield

I think I should round off the front corner of the side? Why do you all think?

I think a cyma reversa (opposite of the pair of cyma rectas on the back) would look better than a quarter round. Turn this one over:


Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#3

my vote, no round overs

Dick Coers

That design has the look of more vintage design. In my opinion, a simple sandpaper break on the edge would be more appropriate. Great project!

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#4

Agree with Dick

John in NM

Nice classic design, going to look better with just a broken edge.

Sometimes I do use a 1/16th inch roundover bit in a laminate trimmer, but that is about as far as I'd go.

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#5

Re: Agree with Dick

john lucas

I agree with them also, no rounded corners. It's just too nice as is.

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#6

Yep.

Virgil Johnson

What William said. The square front is at best a corner to chip or at worst a corner to bang an appendage on.

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Leave it

Jack Guzman from Maine

I vote for no roundover. It looks right as it is.---Jack

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#8

Ellis Walentine

Off the cuff...

Ellis Walentine

... my eye wants to see some kind of curve treatment to complement that curvy detail at the back of the piece. I'd rather see an elliptical curve than a round one.

Ellis

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#9

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Long axis of ellipse vertical?

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#10

Ellis Walentine

No, horizontal...IMHO


Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#11

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

Jim Dillon

Bill, nice project and pics. Hope you are paying minimum wage to your helper :) . I am assuming this bookshelf is for your granddaughter? If so, I would present the options to her and let her decide. Anyway, FWIW, I like the curve suggestions, especially Williams as a way to compliment the curves at the rear and bottom. My 2 cents. Jim

Re: Christmas project book shelf, and question

#12

Re: Well ...?

Hank Knight

What did you decide to do? Inquiring minds want to know.

Your granddaughter looks like she is having fun! I know you are.

Happy New Year! Off to a good start.