Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Terminology clarification requested

Posts

Terminology clarification requested

#1

Terminology clarification requested

CJ in MPLS

I have been seeing a lot of posts by relatively new woodworkers on the internets these days, which is good. What is a bit confusing however, is their use of terminology to describe their work.

For example, I have come to automatically associate the words "rustic" or "vintage" with the use of pallet or other previously used and most likely abused wood. That is fine. I don't really want pallet wood stuff in my house, but then I cannot see Chippendale stuff fitting in either.

Where I'm really in a quandary is in the use of the terms 'Amish' and 'Farmhouse'. I recently saw a coffee table that was described as Amish and as it turns out, the gentlemen that made the table had obtained the wood from an Amish fellow. The top looked like weathered barn wood, albeit 8/4 planks.

Another piece was a Farmhouse coffee table. This piece was made from planed dimensional lumber. Both pieces were well executed and creditable pieces of work. I am merely trying to keep up with new or modified terminology so that I can determine what folks are talking about.

So, how would you characterize the foregoing furniture styles? Myself, I don't really think that there is an Amish style and that the term 'Amish', aside from being a religious group, is more of a marketing term indicating source and perhaps quality. Farmhouse, for me, is a chunky type of table that was intended for hard work, but which also includes a few nods to more refined furniture styles that were current at the time that the table in question was built.

What are your thoughts?

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#2

Re: Terminology clarification requested

Ralph Lipeles

Not all woodworkers know the right words but it is a good feeling hear about so many people out there doing woodwork and many of them are trying and learning new things. So, to me it's not serious that they don't always use the correct words to describe their work. it's like some of my postings. I type with 2 fingers, so often introduce spelling errors in my descriptions.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#3

Re: Terminology clarification requested

CJ in MPLS

You are correct. There is no need to be perfectly categorical about this. I am just trying to keep up here. I just learned, I think, to properly use the term 'fam' from the kids over break.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#4

Labels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

May be used by those less experienced to lend a certain cache to what they do. The Amish have thriving furniture-making and lumber businesses in a number of locations. While their furniture tends to concentrate on "plane and simple" (similar to Shaker) rather than "fancy", they can work in most any style when specially requested.

OTH, using such labels may be little more than marketing. Making something and then attaching a title to it tries to attach literary meanings to the object in order to increase its perceived value or make up for poor performance. I've seen items labeled as "rustic" when, in fact, it was just poorly made junk.

Suggest you forget the pigeon-holes and the taxonomic effort. Labels are of no use in forming an opinion as to the quality of the physical work.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#5

Re: Terminology clarification requested

John McGaw

I don't know that there is any universally-accepted style definition for such furniture. I sometimes call my stuff "Shaker-inspired" not because it looks like any particular piece of real Shaker-made furniture but because I have studied much of what remains of their historical pieces and add little touches that seem to be similar in what I make. Usually the internal dialogue has questions like "would the Shakers find this piece offensive?" Even that is futile since the real Shaker craftsmen (and it was men who made most of the furniture) were invariably inspired by what was in the world outside their communities -- there are pieces that are incredibly primitive and others that look much like later Victorian. Some scholars have compared some high-period Shaker furniture to Danish modern or at least have shown a connection in the clean simple lines and forms.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#6

Re: Labels

CJ in MPLS

I have NEVER used pigeon holes. How dare you! ;)

I use Venn diagrams. Ones with really indistinct boundaries.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#7

OT:This is English

John Foster

I have read a couple of books on the English language lately. I think there is no greater moving target than our language. English picks up new words from other languages, new technology or slang faster than a dog can pick up fleas, and the current words pick up additional meanings or existing meanings drift constantly.

Lots of fun, lots of confusion.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#8

How I would define it....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"So, how would you characterize the foregoing furniture styles?"

Fleetingly stylish trash bought by furniture ignorant Millennials

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#9

Re: How I would define it....

Sgian Dubh

<"Fleetingly stylish trash bought by furniture ignorant Millennials">

Bill, there's no need for you to be reserved and mealy-mouthed in your criticism of what you define as both trash and ignorant Millenials. Come back and say what you really think .. I'm sure all of us could handle it. Slainte.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#11

I can't complain.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Someone from up north (where fleeting fads come from) paid me $500 for a weathered barn I was going to burn with the promise of paying $1000 for a larger one in the spring. Here in East TN we have a large supply of abandoned tobacco barns available to feed the fashion for this kind of furniture.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#12

Re: Used furniture and "antique" dealers

Hank Knight

Used furniture and so-callerd "antique" dealers (not the legitimate, high-end types) label their goods with little regard to recognized classical styles. I've seen really nice American Federal tables with some moderate wear labeled as "farmhouse" style and anything with straight lines labeled "Shaker." The term "rustic" can refer to anything from a dilapidated Chippendale piece to a piece made from rough, unfinished branches and logs - it's an inclusive term. I think you're wasting your time if you try to define these usages. For the most part, they are simply words plucked out of the air by the dealer and applied to merchandise in the hope of giving it some cachet that it doesn't otherwise deserve. It's all about making a buck.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#13

Re: Sounds like a business opportunity

Hank Knight

You have the dubious honor of ridding the landscape of dilapidated, weathered barns only to see it repopulated it with dilapidated, weathered furniture.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#14

Ellis Walentine

Nah

Ellis Walentine

I bought and sold a couple barns and barn wood in my youth. In those days, at least, it was in demand mostly for wall paneling in restaurants and commercial establishments. There's actually a decent profit to be made on disassembling and selling barn components, though taking roof structures down is not for the faint of heart or the elderly. :)

I don't know if the aroma of tobacco barn siding would be acceptable to the architects that are designing these spaces.

Ellis

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#15

how they disassemble

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They pull them down with a Bobcat. No odor in these barns. Maybe you are thinking flu curing structures. These are Burly barns- just brief air drying.

Re: Terminology clarification requested

#16

johannaj

Re: Terminology clarification requested

johannaj

When asked about my "style", I call it Southwest Shaker - like this: