Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT - car tires

Posts

OT - car tires

#1

JL

OT - car tires

JL

The LOML has an older car w/ almost 220K miles. It is a 2004 Mazda 6 sedan (i).

It takes P205/60R16 tires.

She does not want to put the recommended tires (Michelin AS tires) as she figures she won't have the car for another 60K miles - she possibly doesn't want to spend the $135/tire either.

We live in the mountains of North GA so the roads wind and twist a bit. So she needs tires that handle the roads reasonably well.

Any suggestions as to brands? We can the usual Firestone, Cooper, Michelin and Toyo tires. We could probably order others.

Thanks.

Re: OT - car tires

#2

Re: OT - car tires

Bart S Goldberg

I checked on Costco website. Those Michelins now include a $70 rebate when you buy all 4.

Re: OT - car tires

#3

go to Tirerack....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....and read the reviews and professional evaluations

saving a few $ on tires at the expense of performance doesn't seem like a wise place to practice frugality.

Re: OT - car tires

#4

You have to be quick

Henry Higginbotham

. . . to buy them when there's NOT a $70 rebate. :D

But check carefully on installation before you buy there. I ordered a set over a year ago now, figuring that if I made an appointment I could get them installed while I shopped, and handle rotations the same way.

Nope. Earliest available appointment was three weeks out. But they said I could get them installed same-day if I just showed up. Average wait time for that: five hours. I peeked into that department as I walked out on my next visit, and they didn't look all that busy.

I went to a local dealer, paid a little more, and nothing ever takes more than an hour. YMMV

Re: OT - car tires

#5

JL

Re: go to Tirerack....

JL

Agreed. But there are less expensive tires.

The price for the Michelin tires OTD at Costco is on the order of $570 w/ the $70 discount. She would like to spend on the order of $80-100 a tire.

I am trying to talk her into the Michelin A/S tires.

Re: OT - car tires

#6

KUMHO SOLUS...

Mark Nowicki

.tires originally on my 2010 Dodge Journey.

I got about 75K miles out of them.

The Journey is not a sports car but it always felt secure in the rain and on twisty Vermont roads. They also survived Third World, sorry, Quebec roads without failure.

Re: OT - car tires

#7

Re: OT - car tires

Barry Irby

I usually buy Michilins. Once I decided to save bucks and buy the Costco store brand. They rated very well in almost every category. Nearly identical to Michilins. It was a terrible mistake. They were very noisey. Drove me nuts. Could not wait to get back to quieter tires. My friend got into the car and asked "What in the hell have you done to this car?"

What I am saying is there is more to it than meets the eye.

Re: OT - car tires

#8

Re: OT - car tires

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The last tires we had were Bridgestone Ecopia, which were very good, great in snow and ice, wet conditions. Very good mileage, which actually improved by 2 mpg on average, due to low rolling resistance. They were pretty quiet, too. We had to change this year and I put on Michelins. They handle even better and are quieter.

I realize both choices are more money than your wife wants to spend, but I can’t imagine driving a noisy tire for any distance just to save some money. Not worth it.

Re: OT - car tires

#9

Re: You have to be quick

Mark Nowicki

Wait five hours to save $70 on a set of tires, then wait another two hours to fill up at the Costco station to

save about $1.60.

Just a typical day for my in-laws, (who drive a $40K Venza.)

Re: OT - car tires

#10

Re: You have to be quick

Bart S Goldberg

I've recently bought tires at Costco. I didn't have to wait at all. Same thing with their gas. I hardly ever have to wait. I guess its true YMMV.

Re: OT - car tires

#11

Re: OT - car tires

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Not worth saving a few bucks to me. I always taught my children one very important lesson about automobiles. I told them to always make sure a car will whoa, with good tires and brakes. A car that won't start or runs poorly won't kill you ~ one with bad brakes or tires can!

I have purchased only Michelin tires for the last 40 or so years. I and my wife drive older vehicles (pay cash for all) and often when the vehicle is replaced the tires have many miles left, but I have never regretted the minor expense for the safety involved.

I recently purchased a used Dodge Van, it is a 2003, one owner garage kept, came with a car cover he said he used when it had to be left outside. (He sold due to purchasing a new Mercedes custom van). It is spotless inside and out with less than 100K mi, I purchased for $5K. He had replaced the tires about 10K before I purchased the van with Cooper, receipt was included with the paperwork he provided for the van. I hate the Cooper tires due to the road noise, and may replace them with Michelin long before they need replacement.

Re: OT - car tires

#12

Retirement, useful benefit when shopping at Costco

Dick Coers

Being retired lets me go to Costco at the low traffic periods. I also bought tires there, $70 off and free install. I always drop off a car for that kind of service. Nothing gets to me faster than sitting in a waiting room for 2 hours for a 30 minute job. For the last couple of years, I put a bicycle in the back, and ride while the vehicles are being serviced. That's the BEST way to wait!

Re: OT - car tires

#13

Re: OT - car tires  PS....

Barry Irby

When I was broke, I bought Michilins at the local junk yard. Good looking low mileage tires. $20 a tire installed.

I just tried to get ones that were not on a car where the occupants died.

Re: OT - car tires

#14

Re: OT - car tires Costco

fred in ct

I bought 4 Bridgestone (don't remember the model and I'm in the middle of a raging blizzard) tires at Costco about 3 years ago and driving home they felt great, over a short period of time they developed a flat spot when parked and it was my fault when I didn't bring them back within 30 days so I'm stuck with them and now the noise level is way up, last Bridgestones I'll buy.