Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

Posts

Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#1

Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

Barry Irby

A friend asked me to sharp a SS chef's knife. It was very dull and the edge was way too thick. I tried to sharpen it on abrasive paper on glass, but I was too old when I started. Finally pulled out my 4 x 24 belt sander. The finest belt I had was a 150 so I used that and all went fairly well. He was very impressed. I hope he doesn't cut himself.

My question is what grit should I have used? And to anyone who has one of the little 1" strip sanders, do you like it and which one do you like? And If not a 1" strip sander, what would you buy?

PS. I did a lot of work on the knife with abrasive sheets on glass and a Lasky system after I ground the edge thinner on the belt sander.

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#2

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

David Bassett

At one level any method will work, you are just removing the dull parts. However, some will give you more control and some will give you better finish than others. With belts (and wheel grinders) you need to be careful to not over heat the blade and to not go too far.

Many hobbyist knife sharpeners use 1" x 30" belt sanders for coarse work. Hock or Lee even show a homemade base for a HF sander in their sharpening book. It seems like more frequent / serious sharpeners prefer actual belt grinders (lower speed & more power, I think) with 2" x 72" being the common choice, even though it's much more expensive.

For my (very) limited use, I have the HF 1x30 sander but got some cheap metal belts. (Same abrasive, but different more suitable binder, I think.) I use it only for the really coarse reshaping work and shift to manual techniques to finish. It's real easy to screw up on the sander, but my slips have only left cosmetic blemishes that are OK for personal use.

As far as grit, I don't recall how the sandpaper scale matches with the waterstone grit scale. (Maybe Patrick or David will be along with more precise info.) For kitchen knives, 1000 to 6000 waterstone grit range seems most popular finish (to leave some "tooth".) Specialized knives, (e.g. Yanagibas for sushi), are often taken 8K-10K or beyond. I think any belt that gets you to an acceptable starting point for your finish work on stones is fine. Sounds like 150 worked for you.

ETA: I checked, I bought 80 to 320 grit Aluminum Oxide metal grinding belts. I don't remember which I used. I probably started at 80 and think I used one more before shifting to stones.

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#3

Mine uses three belts

John K Jordan

>>>...4 x 24 belt sander....My question is what grit should I have used? And to anyone who has one of the little 1" strip sanders, do you like it and which one do you like? And If not a 1" strip sander, what would you buy?

Barry,

I have a belt-based knife-sharpener that uses belts. It puts an amazing edge on knives - you can't quite slice through a piece of paper by dropping it on the edge but it's close! A friend of mine carries his to the local gun shows and sharpens knives all day for $4 each. When I sharpen our kitchen knives I have to warn my wife or she will get cut every time.

This uses three 1"x30" belts:

1: coarse 120 grit ceramic metal working belt to grind.

2: fine 600 grit silicon carbide belt to hone.

3: felt belt (with buffing compound added) to strop/polish

There are three different jigs to put different angles on different types of blades (a fillet knife needs a different angle than a hunting knife). The method used insures a consistent sharpening angle and puts a polished micro bevel on the edge. There is no need to use any other stones, hones, or strops.

Without the fine belt and the polished edge the knife may seem extremely sharp as you "saw" through something but a close look at the edge will show it to be very rough. A sharp, polished edge will stay sharp longer and cut as well pushed straight down.

You could sharpen on a standard 1" belt grinder/sander except for two things: One, the speed of the belts on the sharpening machine is quite low compared to a shop abrasive belt machine. Two, it would be very challenging to hold the blades so the angle is consistent throughout the process.

I also have the Work Sharp knife sharpener I bought at Northern Tool.

https://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200431964_200431964

It uses 80, 220, and 6000 grit belts, 1/2"x12". I liked it at first but after I got the other sharpener I realized it's not in the same class. It is cheap, though, and people who are not too particular seem to like it a lot. I haven't used it for years.

JKJ

JKJ

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#4

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

Gary Smyth

I mentioned earlier I bought a 1964 Rockwell 1 x 42 belt sander. I bought it for $10. That is less than the cost of a catalog/instruction book. Turned it on and the glued up pulley wheel shattered. Cost me fifty dollars for a new set, still available on line, and had to get the new wheels pressed on, but since then free sailing for the last six or seven years. Put on a 400 belt and over time burnished the grit down so I have no idea of actual grit now, but it is my primary grinder before heading to the Syderco ceramic. From cleavers, slicers. to chef, to boning, and paring. all have visited the grinder, never failed me and I’m particular about knives. By the way after viewing one in a pro butcher store a British Chantry porcelain honing guide (No matter what it says on the newer labels, it's not a sharpener -- it hones a good edge.) will do the job to keep things cutting clean.

Finally, in a pinch, if you turn over a porcelain plate and use the uncoated bottom rim. it can tune up a dulling knife.

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#5

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

John McGaw

I use a cheap 1" Dremel with German blue zirconia belts. I believe that the finest I have at the moment is 120-grit but that is OK since it is used mostly for rough re-shaping of edges. I even have a leather stropping belt for it that uses stick abrasive but it hasn't been used for so long that I figure it might rip if it was put under tension.

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#6

Tell me more.....

Barry Irby

John, did you buy this or make it? What is it and what did it cost?

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#7

This is what I have

John K Jordan

>>>John, did you buy this or make it? What is it and what did it cost?

I bought it, although the construction is simple and anyone with some machining ability could steal the design and make one for considerably less than the selling price.

I believe the usual price is about $500-600. I bought mine for less from a friend who is a dealer. I believe there are some knockoffs available, perhaps for less.

Check: http://realsharpllc.com// You can ask Mr Google to kindly give you more info. I believe you can see pictures and videos. Compared to standard belt sander the big advantages of this are the means to hold the blade at a specific angle and move it down the flat and through the curves of the edge, the means to put a gentle and consistent secondary bevel on the edge, the actual grinding/honing belts they provide, the polishing belt, and the graphite backing pad they use under the sharpening/polishing area. The polishing compound looks very much like the white diamond compound that came with my Beale buffing system. I like the very simple but quick and effective means they use to adjust the belt tracking too.

This may sound like I'm advertising for them but I'm not. I'm simply a satisfied user after a couple of years of use.

It is so quick to put a perfect edge on a knife compared to most other methods I've used. I've never timed it but probably takes me no longer than 1 to 2 minutes to sharpen one knife. This is nice when I sharpen the 15 knives most used by the live-in chef. The pocket knives I use around the farm have never been sharper. (I keep six or seven identical knives and just get a sharp one out of the drawer as needed.) BTW, my absolute favorite pocket knife, after trying a bunch: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0013AUCUE

JKJ

Re: Knife sharpening Question, sanding belt?

#8

Re: Me too

Steve jenkins

Bought mine a couple years ago and don’t regret it for an instant. After sharpening you can hold a piece of paper by the edge and without a sawing motion simply press the knife down to cut the paper. Sharpest I’ve ever been able to attain.