Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

To biscuit or not to biscuit

Posts

To biscuit or not to biscuit

#1

JL

To biscuit or not to biscuit

JL

that is the question.

I usually don't biscuit when gluing boards together. I have used biscuits to put face frames on cabinets that I have made for myself. I have used biscuits in mitered joints.

I will be gluing some 8' boards together.

Also, when y'all are gluing several boards together - do you do them all at once? Or glue them in pairs and then glue the pairs together? I usually do them all at once (clamping cauls are your friends:)).

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#2

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

C John Hebert

In all the years I've done woodworking as a profession...I've never ever used them to join. just a waste of precious time.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#3

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

John McGaw

I sometimes do it when it seems that keeping boards in alignment will be difficult. There seems to be no other benefit when making a long-grain-to-long-grain glue joint is possible. I've sometimes had problems when doing multiple-board glue-ups with a joint or two slipping out of alignment unnoticed -- I don't own any of the big parallel jaw bar clamps that many folks swear by. That is probably more of a commentary on my technique than anything.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#4

Same Here

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I make my living making furniture too. I never use biscuits for gluing panels. For big or difficult panels I will glue 2 or 3 boards at a time and then join the subsets into a full panel. T.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#5

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

Jim Dillon

JL, 8 feet is a pretty long board to glue up and "hope-for-the-best". I would place a few biscuits along the board to help things out. Having a Domino, I no longer use biscuits but the same concept applies. As Thomas suggests, gluing up in pairs reduces the anxiety of a glue up. Plus it gives you time to clean up the squeeze-out using whatever method you are comfortable with. As I am sure you are aware, make sure you cut the slots using the same face side of the board pairs. I make sure to mark with chalk the "working side" of any piece I am cutting slots on using either a Biscuit cutter or a Domino. My 2 cents. Jim

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#6

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

Brian Holcombe

Biscuits are not necessarily and impractical imo. I edge joint boards then align them in a glue up, afterward I face joint them and finally thickness. Having to plan out and avoid reaching things like biscuits is something to be avoided.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#7

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

Don Stephan

Haven't used biscuits for this in years, in part because I seemed to have as many alignment issues with biscuits as without. Now I use lots of clamping cauls. During a "dry run" I will space the cauls pretty darn close together, and mark the position with a "C" on each outside edge.

My usual adhesive is hot hide glue, and even after warming the edges with a hot air gun I would glue at most 3 edge pairs across the panel at a time. I do however put all of the boards in the clamp each time, not just the few being glued, so that I can't accidentally introduce a crook that would make an open joint during a following glueup.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#8

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

Barry Irby

I have had a biscuit cutter for probably 15 years. At first I used it a lot, now not so much. I agree with those who say use a few on big edge to edge glue ups to help you keep things lined up and moving quickly. but, I don't wet them with glue anymore for fear they will "show" in the final panel. They can swell when wet, causing a bulge and then you plane or sand the panel, and as it dries the bulges shrink and can leave a depression. Also, Plan carefully. I put some near the two ends of a panel and then decided to trim one end more heavily than the other and a biscuit came into view.

OTOH, I am also careful placing Kreg/Pocket screws. If you hit a biscuit, you may ruin a panel, hit a pocket screw and you ruin a nice saw blade. DAMHIKT

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#9

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

Ray Newman

C John: good to see you around again! Hope you are doing well. I recall your threads and comments from Jace Weber's(??) old site and others.

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#10

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

C John Hebert

I'm sill kickin, good Lord willin ;-)

Re: To biscuit or not to biscuit

#11

JL

Thanks

JL

No biscuits, except for dinner :D