Staining Poplar
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
I have a Black Walnut stain I want to use. Should I use a wood conditioner first?
Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge
Staining Poplar
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
I have a Black Walnut stain I want to use. Should I use a wood conditioner first?
Depends on how even you want the color.
Dick Coers
Practice on scrap.
Re: Staining Poplar
AZ in Colorado Springs
We use poplar for projects in introductory wood working classes. I've seen it stained many times. I have never observed any blotching.
Nah
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Sanding evenly is the key to controlling the even absorption of the stain. Poplar grows straight and tall with very little in the way of compression wood in my area. We have a number of poplars that run up to 100' or better with the first lead above 40'. Makes for straight even grain.
Re: Staining Poplar
ebd
I've used Minwax (?) Ipswitch Pine on poplar extensively. Just sanded as normal and applied. It always comes out looking like butternut. Almost impossible to tell the difference (I chose the grain carefully when picking boards). Don't see why your stain should act any different.
Re: Staining Poplar
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
I went ahead and used the conditioner before staining and it turned out pretty good. Will apply a topcoat today. Only took a few minutes as this is a small project. (Christmas present) Mostly I was asking for future reference in case I'm making a larger project. Thanks all for the responses.
Bottle of Wine for Every Project? NM
Re: Bottle of Wine for Every Project?
William Duffield
It seems to me he didn't do the math. One bottle of wine and accommodations for FOUR wine goblets? 
Re: Staining Poplar
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
Try using the steel wool/vinegar solution on Poplar. It gives a nice warm brown result.
Did it once by accident (don't ask!) and ended up liking it. Have used it several times since.
Re: Bottle of Wine for Every Project?
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
LOL. But that one is a gift for a classy lady. The stuff I drink comes in a box.
Re: Staining Poplar
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
Interesting. I'll give it a try sometime.
Re: Bottle of Wine for Every Project?
William Duffield
I agree. It is an elegant idea.
Designing and building something equivalent for box wine and goblets would be quite a bit more challenging. I once suggested it to my lady, but she nixed the idea.
Nixed
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
The Box?
The Goblets?
or
The Project?
Re: Nixed
William Duffield
The project
. She'd never nix a box of wine, or a glass to pour it into. 
Psssst
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
SWMBO may be doing "keggers" in the cooking wine.