Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

Posts

Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#1

Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

Dick Coers

I've been in this home many times in Springfield, Il, but the first time arriving on a bicycle. Went for an urban ride to historical sites today. For all the Wright homes I've been in, this one ranks #1 for glass work. Truly stunning! This is the east facade, with the master bedroom centered between the columns. It was located so the morning light cascades through that wonderful art work! Such a wonderful way to wake up! The frieze work above the brick is also stunning. I love this place with all the references to sumac in the colors and geometric shapes.


Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#2

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

Brian Holcombe

A thing of beauty! I find much inspiration in Wright's work, he is an absolute master of proportion.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#3

Wright Chuckle

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When he was commissioned to do the Guggenheim Museum in New York, the state raised a fuss because he didn't have a New York license.

They demanded that he sit for the licensing exam.

Frank's reported to have replied "Sure, I'll take your test, but who are you going to get to grade my answers?"

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#4

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

Hank Knight

I agree completely. Wright's work is stunning and inspirational. The most inspirational thing, for me at least, is that he didn't really hit his stride until he was past 70.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#5

My favorite story was the Fallingwater design *LINK*

Dick Coers

Perhaps the most famous tale to come out of the lore of Fallingwater is the improbable story that Wright, after receiving the commission procrastinated for nine months until he was forced to draw up the complete plans while his patron was driving the 140 miles from Milwaukee to Taliesin. However, the essential story is validated by several witnesses. Apprentice Edgar Taffel recalled that after talking with Kaufmann on the phone, Wright “briskly emerged from his office...sat down at the table set with the plot plan and started to draw…The design just poured out of him. 'Liliane and E.J. will have tea on the balcony…they’ll cross the bridge to walk in the woods…' Pencils being used up as fast as we could sharpen them....Erasures, overdrawing, modifying. Flipping sheets back and forth. Then, the bold title across the bottom ‘Fallingwater.’ A house has to have a name.”2 There seems to be agreement that the whole process took about two hours.


https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/ap-art-history/later-europe-and-americas/modernity-ap/a/frank-lloyd-wright-fallingwater

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#6

Fallingwater design.....

Brian Roberts

proved to be a failure in many potentially disastrous.....and VERY expensive to repair and stabilize..... ways!

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#7

Re: Fallingwater, Wondering

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

if it could be made with modern methods and materials advances since the 30's. I've seen larger cantilevers that seem to do fine.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#8

And not the only one that needed reinforcement

Dick Coers

I visited the May House in Grand Rapids. They tell of filling that attic with structural steel to hold the cantilevers for the restoration. They were lucky enough to have the attic to work with, Fallingwater did not.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#9

Re: And not the only one that needed reinforcement

Barry Irby

Wright was a better Architect than Engineer. He often drew the impossible and expected the "lowly" engineers to figure out how to build it.

I visited Fallingwater in the 90's while it was being repaired and reinforced. They told stories of the men on the original site stuffing as much reinforcement as they could sneak into the cantilevers.

Unfortunately, steel reinforced concrete is nowhere near permanent. MANY of the bridges on the Interstates have had to be replaced and they are younger than Fallingwater. The life expectancy of any steel reinforced concrete exposed to weather may be closer to fifty years than a hundred. Water finds its way in and the steel rusts and expands about 5 to 1 and bursts the concrete. We are slowly learning to reinforce concrete with other materials such as fiberglass and alumabronze.

Wright may not have done so badly for the times.

BTW, Fallingwater is amazing.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#10

Kneale Brownson

Salt

Kneale Brownson

Part of the issue with road bridges is salt. Not only in the north, but also near the oceans.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#11

does that mean

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That there's hope for us?

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#12

Nice at Christmas too.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I've been to the Thomas House a few times. Truly an interesting house. They have a nice Christmas tour as well. I just went through "Wingspread" in Racine WI. Also a cool house. But agree that the glass in the Thomas House is outstanding. So hard to pick a favorite. Falling Water is amazing. T.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#13

He certainly had less turmoil in latter years

Dick Coers

From being fired by Sullivan, affairs and marriage problems, and constant financial woes, his early life had enough baggage to certainly affect his work. Likely once he got all that behind him, he could do the creative work. Personally, I prefer the earlier work of the Prairie Style.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright's Dana Thomas home

#14

Re: He certainly had less turmoil in latter years

Hank Knight

FLW was very much a ladies man, which certainly contributed to his earlier difficulties. I think that continued into his later years, but he probably "outgrew" it - which may be part of the explanation of his late-in-life vigor and productivity.