Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

Posts

Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#1

JL

Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

JL

What is your preference?

I've been going to a new lumberyard (primarily for their prices and quality of lumber).

They plane down their lumber before they rack it - which is different from my other lumberyard which typically just skip planes their lumber.

The "new" lumberyard's 8/4 is 2 1/16" to 2 1/4" in the rough - which I like for turning legs and such.

When they plane it, they typically take the 8/4 down to 1 3/4" - 1 7/8" - which is fine for most things - but not some legs.

So, I have to call to make sure they have some rough boards in stock before I go. They will custom plane it if desired.

But it got me to wondering - how y'all prefer to get your boards?

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#2

Lumber

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When I buy hardwood I only buy rough lumber. That gives me total control over what I get from a given board. I have a planer, a jointer, and a Performax, any one or all of which may be used to get a piece to final thickness.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

Jack Guzman from Maine

I always buy rough lumber for the same reason Mark stated. There's no reason to pay for that extra step(planing) if I'm going to have to redimension everything anyhow.---Jack

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#4

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

Dick Coers

Skip dressed if they have the right equipment. If they have a Stratoplaner, or similar, it's a huge time saver. If they only have a thickness planer, I order rough.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#5

I want control!  Therefore Rough is right


Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#7

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

jesse cloud

Rough is my preference. Unfortunately, its getting harder to find these days. My favorite lumber yard just turned over ownership and went from rough to planed. Feel like I lost an old friend.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#8

Ruff.

Virgil

the ruffer the better.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#9

Shopping Tool

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Your option: Take a No. 5 smoother with you to do your own "skip"

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#10

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

Don Stephan

All the planed boards I've ever seen were not flat and straight; making them so would leave the final thickness even less.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#11

Besides...

H.C. Sakman (Chico)

....wood is going to move if it wants to. Planing somewhat is going to make it worse, counterproductive and waste of time. Species like madrone (arbutus) may appreciate some planing after it has been seasoned for 1,5 years per inch, for further storage.

I used arbutus as an example, because it is practically alive (unstable, moving) until it is well seasoned.

Planing without jointing first (after cutting smaller sizes to be used) is also total waste of wood and time.

Chico

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#12

The problem with skip planing and thicknessing ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The problem with skip planing is that it will roughly level a side of a board without concern for maximising thickness. Wide boards are more vulnerable here.

Wood moves, so even planed and thicknessed boards will need to be redone.

Rough boards offer one the opportunity to plane and thickness only the section required. Planing a short section will remove less waste than planing a long section.

Therefore, choose only rough timber/lumber and maximise the thickness possible.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#13

Re: Rough boards only!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

It is rare that you use lumber in its rough sawn dimensions. I prefer to breakdown the rough lumber to somewhat near the length and width I need for a project. Sometimes you can expose figure by planing off more of one side (after full cure) other times you can retain thickness much better. I would never purchase skip or full planed lumber except when building a house or building!

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#14

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

Dave Bair

I usually get rough-sawn lumber but sometimes buy packaged lumber that's planed. The advantage with the planed lumber is that you can see grain figure clearly instead of just hints from the rough.

Re: Rough boards, planed or skip planed?

#15

Rough for me too...

John in NM

Once you're geared up to work with them - face joint and plane to desired thickness, working with rough lumber just gives you so many options! I'll take rough whenever I get the choice.