Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Walnut bench

Posts

Walnut bench

#1

JL

Walnut bench

JL

7.5' long x 14" wide.


Re: Walnut bench

#2

Pssst

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Looks like you need a leg stretcher on a few there.

:D

Re: Walnut bench

#3

Re: Walnut bench

Barry Irby

Looking good. Let us see it finished.

Aren't those little knobs going to be uncomfortable to sit on? :)

Re: Walnut bench

#4

Re: PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Turnings look nicely uniform. Freehand or replicator?

Re: Walnut bench

#5

Camera distortion?

Dick Coers

Is there distortion in the photo, or are the stretchers curved? Also seems like a lot of legs for that length, but the proportions could be right when seen at a different angle.

Re: Walnut bench

#6

Re: Walnut bench

Joe Mohnike

Neceessary, they keep you from sliding off when you have had one too many.

Re: Walnut bench

#7

JL

Re: PS

JL

I am cheap. I do things freehand.

Re: Walnut bench

#8

JL

"Fitting" picture

JL

Before the glue up. I like to make sure all the pieces fit together before I glue. Though I wouldn't discount camera distortion - it was a cell phone camera.


Re: Walnut bench

#9

JL

Too many legs?

JL

The bench is 7.5' long. There is a set of legs about every 28" or so. Figuring that as many as 4 people might sit on it - I don't think 4 sets of legs is too many. I could be wrong. The slab is 14" W x 90" L x 1 3/8" thick.

Re: Walnut bench

#10

I suppose it depends on sizes

Dick Coers

I've read where the airlines in the United States will start bumping passengers as they near the passenger weight limits on the planes.

Personally, I would have inset the end legs a little more and eliminated one set of legs. 4' is not a long span for 6/4 walnut used for sitting.

Nice work!

Re: Walnut bench

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I suppose it depends on sizes

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Trust me--you don't want the legs inset on the end unless they are splayed out to the length of the bench. We own a bench made by a friend's son for a 4H project, and each end has about a 8" overhang. It's led to a few surprise moments when either one person sits on the very end or one person gets left sitting on the end...

Jason

Re: Walnut bench

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Walnut bench

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ambitious project. Angles everywhere.I know how hard it is to line up all those separate elements. Please post the final result. Nice work.---Jack

Re: Walnut bench

#13

Re: Camera distortion?

Brian Holcombe

Camera distortion for sure, I take most photos with my iPhone and the barrel distortion drives me crazy at times. Other than that it takes nice photos.

Re: Walnut bench

#14

Re: Camera distortion?

William Duffield

There are plug-ins for photo editing applications such as PhotoShop that will remove barrel distortion, pincushion distortion and other non-linearities.

Re: Walnut bench

#15

Re: Camera distortion?

John K Jordan

I see only minor lens distortion in that photo, other than the normal perspective issues. The sides of the workbench are straight lines. Curvature in the central part of the photo is not where I would expect distortion.

A quick perspective adjustment does not, of course, change the curvature of the central element.


Based on my experience I can't imagine a comprehensive correction making a big difference unless the lens was unusually and severely warped. A photo of a simple rectangular grid at the same zoom level would reveal the type and extent of any distortion.

I think the bench is beautiful. I like the number of legs - seems perfect for a bench that long. I like the shape of the legs too. I would like to see some pics from different positions.

JKJ

Re: Walnut bench

#16

Re: Camera distortion?

Brian Holcombe

Thanks William, I may need to start putting that to use.