and the answer is a resounding NO for a counter top that will see use. Made a kitchen island for my daughter with a bowling ally type top in hard maple; finished in Waterlox. Looked lovely until someone put a hot pot down on it.
Tung gives a very nice soft finish. Takes many sleeps to cure.
tell them you hold no responsibility for wood failure if they fail to maintain and oil it properly. Get it in writing. I wouldn't strip the finish, I'd take it off with a card scraper and then sand. Having a harsh chemical stripper in the pores of the wood would not be a good thing when they plan on cutting on it.
This actually works better on a soft to medium density wood than on really dense wood, so should do fine on Walnut if you can get it down to bare wood.
Start with Smith's Clear Penetrating Epoxy Sealer, which is about as thin as lacquer thinner, and will really soak into the wood. Keep adding it as long as it will soak it up. Then wipe of, like using most oil finishes. When it has cured, sand with very fine grit to remove any left on the surface. Then one coat of wipe-on poly looks like about 8 coats of oil finish, but will stand up to a glass filled with ice left on it without circling.
I don't know how it would do under a hot pot, but nobody ought to set a hot pot on a wood top anyway whether it has a finish or not.
If it seems expensive to you, just think how much your time is worth if it saves you from applying even two more coats.
We have had **working** maple counter tops for decades. The only maintenance is an occasional scraping and oiling with whatever vegie oil is handy. But mostly using them keeps them adequately oiled. Kneaded pizza dough on one last night and oil from dough transfers to the wood as needed by the wood. However, they look like working counter tops. Functional, not something from Southern Living feature of E. TN. farm houses.
Several years ago I investigated the thinned epoxy finish and was told that it contains harsh chemicals as thinners. If true, not sure if would be good on a food prep surface. Also wonder about odors as it dries/cures. I decided not to even experiment with the product.
Yes there are a lot of VOCs and I wouldn't recommend using lots of it in a small kitchen with a potential source of ignition. However, it's probably now worse than spraying lacquer and I'm usually not mixing over a half cup at a time. After the volatile stuff evaporates the epoxy is down in the wood, which is now tuffer than it was without, plus no longer absorbent, or at least less absorbent.
I used it on the Eastern Redcedar, Juniperus virginiana down at my cabin, which would really be too soft for an island work surface, but seems about as tough as formica, and holding up really well. I even left a full glass of ice-water on it until it melted by accident last week, with no sign of penetration, even though there was a wide puddle of condensation around it.
Also, it seems to have kept the red color which has faded on all the legs and drawer fronts of the same wood which only had the wipe on poly.
Most any film-forming "finish", be it oil, solvent, or waterbased, is going to get trashed when the film gets cracked/cut/melted/etm. If the customer wants a cutting board for a counter, and doesn't mind the look of a "used" cutting board, I'd use a sealer coat of something that's got a bit of resin involved, light application of a wipe-on varnish like Waterlox red-can, then use butcher block treatments like wax/mineral oil to refresh the look.
if you're going to recoat with a waterborne/based top coat. The steel will leave small particles of steel in the wood pores that will then rust and discolor your finish film.
Personally, I'd just sand the surface to an even sheen and then wipe on a coat or two of oil-based sealer like Waterlox Red-Can
Hi Mike. Did she say why she wants the counters stripped? If she's not happy with the look of a bulletproof finish after a few years, I doubt she'll be happy with an oil finish. Could be that the varathane is too glossy/plastic looking if it was applied thick?
Will she be happy with the smell of pure tung oil - especially when it will need to be periodically reapplied?
Personally I would not use wood counters anywhere near a sink; I had pine counters with an oil finish in a kitchen in Australia and the area around the sink rapidly looked terrible.
However, I have used polymerized tung oil (from Lee Valley) as a finish for my kitchen table that receives hard use. Two young kids leaving milky cereal bowls glued to the table, standing water, sharpie doodling, homework, etc. have tested the finish. After about 8 years the finish is looking very thin in areas and needs attention - but I've been satisfied with that finish. When I get all the other projects out of my shop I'll haul the table into the shop, give it a light sanding, and apply five more coats of polymerized oil. This is a stinky and messy process that I wouldn't want to do in my kitchen.
The table was not finished with pure tung oil - it was finished with polymerized tung oil, which forms a nice satin gloss finish after about 5 wipe-on/wipe-off coats. The polymerized tung oil has a strong odour when applied, but dries fairly rapidly and does not smell once cured. I cut the first coat about 50% with odourless paint thinner, the second coat with about 25% thinner, and the final coats are applied uncut. Wipe each coat down well with clean rags until the surface is almost dry and give each coat at least 24 hours to cure. Don't let your rags catch fire!
Here's a photo of the kitchen table and a bench finished with polymerized tung oil.
Here's the same table surface after 8 years of daily use; the gloss is mostly gone and it's almost down to bare wood in the high wear areas.