Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

opinions please oil vs water

Posts

opinions please oil vs water

#1

opinions please oil vs water

Michael van pelt

I am working on an article on finishing. Wanted your experience and opinion on water based stains and finishes vs oil based? thanks Any one here use General Finishes? thanks

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#2

JL

Re: opinions please oil vs water

JL

I have used the General Finishes water based wood stains on a number of occasions.

Typically I raise the grain on the piece w/ an application of water (which also gets some of the sanding dust off) followed by a final sanding. After the application of the stain, I go over the piece w/ an abrasive pad.

The color is even and uniform even over different woods.

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#3

Clarify please

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"water based stains". Are you asking about water soluble dyes or water dispersed pigment stain?

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#4

Re: opinions please oil vs water

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The chemist at General Finishes told me that their oil based pigment stains are formulated from mineral pigments. Mineral pigments don't fade, ever. Other companies formulate "oil stain" in one name or another with unknown pigment and dye combinations. Unknown means the fading properties are unknown so I avoid them.

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#5

Re: opinions please oil vs water

Bob in NP

In 1990 or thereabouts, I Remodeled our kitchen with cabinets in a box from a local lumber yard. They were decent but definitely low budget. the guy at the paint counter showed me this new stuff from Varathane, Water based, low odor, extremely durable. I bought a gallon of Diamond Varathane water based finish. I painstakingly brushed this finish on my new cabinets. Took some time but they looked great! That kitchen served us well until 1999 when our income had risen to a point that we could afford a pro remodel of our kitchen. Saved all the cabinets and re used them when I built a shop with an apartment above in 2002. The cabinets are still in use, both in my shop and the apartment which I now live in. Cabinet hardware is getting tired, but the finish looks great. I am strictly an amateur woodworker but I have built and installed 5 kitchens and finished them with both water and oil based. All are holding up well. Friend of mine bought an Amish unfinished kitchen table, actually had it finished professionally. They used shellac with some kind of wax and it failed miserably when water hit it the finish. They quit using the table. Anyway 3 yrs ago , I was visiting and we refinished it with General Uerthane w/cross linker water based. His wife tells me every time she sees me how well it's holding up. They have a large family and bought the table mostly for holiday use. I'm sold on this product when I need extreme durability. But I like the grain enhancement of shellac and oil on furniture not subject to harder use.

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#6

Re: opinions please oil vs water

Tony-Memphis

I use water based (Lockwood) almost exclusively when I do stain (which I try to avoid). Actually just used some a day or two ago on some mahogany. I like them because I can easily control the intensity, they are easy to use, I can mix and match to get better control of the colors, and I like water vs. oil. I also like that they last forever in powder form and pretty much when mixed as well.

Tony

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#7

Prepackaged water based stains

Dick Coers

For prepackaged water based, they all seem to look like mud to me. I haven't used one for years after trying General Finishes stain. But, I never stain wood any more either! LOL

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#8

Re: opinions please oil vs water

Don Stephan

When I was spraying, I loved using General Finishes Enduro-Var.

When I needed to color wood I used Homestead Finishing's Transfast and Transtint. My experience with them was that, after drying on the wood, they looked terrible. Had to apply the first coat of finish to see how the color looked on the wood. The support from Homestead was always first rate.

Re: opinions please oil vs water

#9

Yep!

Tony-Memphis

After the dye dries. you look at your work in shock thinking OMG, what have I done to this poor beautiful wood! But then, that first wetting with the finish..and wow! I just had that experience with some mahogany last week...again.

With dye, you really have to experiment all the way to the finish (and perhaps a couple of three coats).

On mahogany, I use a red (looks AWFUL)followed by a brown (looks better), then finish...looks great.

Tony