Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

pie safe tin punch techniques?

Posts

pie safe tin punch techniques?

#1

pie safe tin punch techniques?

Michael van pelt

I have a commision to build a pie safe and I have never " punched tin". Any words of wisdom? tools? source of supplies? thanks!

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#2

JL

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

JL

My personal preferences would be to buy tin that has already been punched.

I made a pies safe for my wife many years ago, and that's what I did. I don't remember the vendor for the tin.

So search for a suitable pattern and buy it - that way you don't have tools that you might never use again.

If you really want to do it yourself, I can ask over at the Folk School - they have classes on tinsmithing and making punched designs.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#3

Kneale Brownson

A nail will work.

Kneale Brownson

You can buy metal in rolls. Tin, aluminum and copper are common.

Print your pattern on a paper you can tape to the metal.

Practice on scrap so you develop a feel for how hard to hit the nail.

Punch outward from the center.

Personalized pattern designs--like initials, names, places or simple images--would make more sense than traditional patterns because you can get those already made for pretty reasonable prices.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#4

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

John McGaw

A number of years ago I was going to build one so I did some experiments on a piece of scrap tin. The old tried-and-true method of hammer and nail worked fine but left the inside surface rough enough to use for cheese grating. I also tried a tiny bit in the drill press but that was a serious PITA and slow. I guess if one was preparing a half-dozen sheets then drilling them all at once might be viable.

Given that this is the 21st century one possible method might be to find someone with a small laser cutter for hire. One of the more powerful Epilog units should be able to zap holes in tin pretty readily. I don't know if having holes place too neatly and uniformly might actually decrease the value of a folk piece.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#6

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

Ron in Sterling, CT

Many years ago I made two small cabinets with a punched tin panel in the door. One of them was for LOML and the other was for my daughter. I bought two tools specifically for punching tin. One was a single point, and the other made a slot. The deal was that I would make the cabinets and the women would punch the tin. The pattern was taped to the tin. Punching tin wasn't hard, just tedious and repetitive. They came out nice. Oh, by the way, the two punches still reside in my toolbox having been used only the one time. Good luck.

Ron

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#8

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques? *LINK*

William Duffield

Norm will show you how to do it, starting at 9:55.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4o6f1vkwKa4

New Yankee Workshop, Season 3, Episode 12

For more info, search Google for "new yankee workshop pie safe"

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#9

Re: I'm with JL...

Michael van pelt

I have never tin punched. It does look straight forward. I know I can buy ready made but I want to learn a new skill and my wife is very intetested in learning as well. She is the artist in the family. Love working in the shop with her. Thanks for all the great tips and advise! You guys are great!

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#10

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

Michael van pelt

thanks guys. appreciate your input!

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#11

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

John Veerkamp

I've punched copper for a small cabinet door. Made my own punches from various nails. For the patterns I used quilting patterns. endless selection of styles, sizes and motifs. You can find quilting templates at any hobby store or better yet a quilt store.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#12

Re: I'm with JL...

Barry Irby

I would use a large hardened steel (concrete) nail and grind various points on it until I got what I wanted. Or maybe a small drift punch ground down. You will need a consistent backer plate to support the tin and punch into it. Clear white pine would work. You get different results punching into a knot. You might try some kind of high density foam.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#13

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

Gary Smyth

I once had an acquaintance who interned at PBS Boston. He informed me that Russ Morash the producer of TOH had people punching tin "forever" to complete that show.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#14

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

John C Lucas

My dad probably made a.dozen of them. He punched the first two. Bought pre punched after that. He wasnt strong on patience. I would punch them myself but then im a stickler for doing it all and have the patience to do it.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#15

Re: I'm with JL...

Joseph Mulherin

To prevent the angst which one gets from doing all the nailing .....go buy the already made ones as mentioned by JL.

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

#16

Re: pie safe tin punch techniques?

Dave Nichols

I made a pie safe with 6 metal panels, each panel had about 1800 holes which needed to be punched. I used a small tool like a center punch put it had a sharper point on it. You need to have a solid backing to support the tin while you punch it. I used particle board and used it only one time so I wouldn't have any problem with the punch drifting into a hole from a prior panel. It took a long time for the first one but if I remember correctly the last one only took about 45 minutes.