Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Stains for walnut

Posts

Stains for walnut

#1

JL

Stains for walnut

JL

Bill mentioned a burnt umber stain for staining walnut. Not available at Home Depot - so should I use a Minwax walnut stain (or something similar) to even out black walnut?

I will have a large table and a couple of benches that I have to finish this summer - so if I have to order a quart, then so be it.

Re: Stains for walnut

#2

Re: Stains for walnut

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I tnink that Bill is talking about making his own colorant from artist's burnt umber oil color mixed with oil and some MS. {I could be wrong ;) }

I have used Minwax oil stains, both "Special" as well as "Dark" walnut without any problems. If, however, you are looking to blend light/white sapwood with the heartwood, I've had better results using alcohol dyes (medium or dark walnut Transtint) to get a base color first and then, when dry, topping with the oil stain.

Re: Stains for walnut

#3

Re: Stains for walnut *LINK*

jesse cloud

I have used Behlen Burnt Umber shade and glaze many times with good results. Its meant to go on between two sealer coats of shellac.

Here's a link from Woodworker's Supply


Belen 916-787

Re: Stains for walnut

#4

JL

Re: Stains for walnut

JL

I hadn't really thought about black walnut having a fugitive color. So I wanted to even out the color and keep it dark. I have some Transtint in dark brown, so I could try that on some scrap. I also have a small can of Minwax special walnut.

Re: Stains for walnut

#5

Thinning a glaze

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

like Behlen's Burnt Umber can work too. I've never mused one so can't speak to that option.

Re: Stains for walnut

#6

I thought burnt umber had a lot of orange

Dick Coers

Not sure dark brown will give you the same affect.

Re: Stains for walnut

#7

Make your own stain

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The components are burnt umber Japan Color or a tube of artist pigment burnt umber, linseed oil and either mineral spirits or General Finishes "Pre-stain Conditioner" "Natural". Vary the amount of pigment to get depth you want. Start about 15% by weight pigment and about 15% oil.

So, how did I come up with that? I didn't. A chemist at General Finishes told me their pigment stains are simply mineral pigment plus this conditioner. I add the oil for depth. Let dry until you don't smell oil any more- about 2 days if warm.

Advantages: pigment stains don't fade....ever. And you can control the depth.

" Store stains" often contain dye, which can fade and change the color of the piece.

Re: Stains for walnut

#8

burnt umber is not orange

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

see any walnut piece I have in the Gallery

Re: Stains for walnut

#9

Ellis Walentine

Re: Stains for walnut

Ellis Walentine

I have a friend who restores priceless antiques, and often he has to re-create elements of furniture pieces using fresh walnut, which has strong purplish tones, while the well-aged original wood has turned some shade of reddish brown. He uses a strong yellow dye stain to negate the blues in the fresh wood and to provide warm undertones, then follows up with an appropriate water-based stain mixed specifically to match the piece he's working on -- usually a combination of reds and browns. While pigment stains (e.g., most Minwax stains) are more permanent (light-fast), they also accentuate grain and add contrast that you may or may not want. Water-based dyes are generally more resistant to fading than alcohol or lacquer-soluble dyes, and pigments are even better, but the best defense against walnut lightening over time is to keep it out of direct sunlight. I built our dining table over 35 years ago from a walnut tree I took down on the property. I didn't stain it at all, and it is still a very nice natural brown after all this time, because it's been protected from the sun.

I guess the message here is that coloring wood is a little like alchemy, at least for me, because I'm always looking for exactly the right hue and value. Sometimes it takes multiple steps. Most often I begin with one or more dye stains to create an even coloring, and then sometimes I follow up with an oil-based pigment stain to add warmth or contrast depending on the wood. Whatever you do, remember Mike Dresdner's famous "FFF" advice, "finish firewood first," before you work on the real deal.

Ellis

Re: Stains for walnut

#10

Burnt Umber

Gary Smyth

Art color and chart.

Re: Stains for walnut

#11

You're thinking of burnt ochre...

John in NM

Easy to mix them up by name - both "burnt" followed by a perhaps unfamiliar pigment name.

Re: Stains for walnut

#12

JL

Other sources for the pigment?

JL

I found a can of "Ronan Superfine Japan Color" in burnt umber online. I will check at the art store next time I go down to the city. I figure an 8 oz can would make a quart of "stain". The tubes look somewhat problematic - they wouldn't make much.

Any other sources that you would recommend?

Re: Stains for walnut

#13

Re: Other sources for the pigment?

William Duffield

I buy my dry artists pigment from Jerry's Art-A-Rama. I prefer the Sennelier pigments.

http://www.jerrysartarama.com/sennelier-artist-dry-pigments

You can mix them with a binder (typically linseed oil) and a carrier (typically mineral spirits) to use as a stain or glaze. You can even add them directly to your oil based finish. You can mix them with Por-O-Pac grain filler. I mix them with beeswax or Johnson's paste wax, prewarmed in my glue pot. I also mix them with epoxy as a knot and crack filler.

The colors I currently have in my shop are burnt umber, raw umber, burnt sienna, raw sienna, yellow ochre, titanium white, van dyke brown, vegetable black and chrome green. I probably have a couple of cans of other earth pigments in oil back on a shelf, but they are likely hardened beyond use. If I need those colors (brighter yellow or brighter reds) I'll go to a craft store and buy a tube of oil paint in the appropriate color.

If you just need enough for glazing or staining a single piece of furniture, you might consider oil paints in a tube from the same merchant or from your local retailer (e.g., Michaels, A. C. Moore, etc. They come already mixed with a hardening oil binder.

For staining walnut, I usually use a mixture of burnt umber, burnt sienna and van dyke brown. I usually start with a ratio of about 6:3:1.

Re: Stains for walnut

#14

Way wrong

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Have you followed how I stain? A half pint of Japan colors lasted me several years until it hardened. This stain did everything walnut in my Gallery and I used less than half of it. I did the two night stands and used an unnoticeable amount of stain from a tube.

Re: Stains for walnut

#15

Re: Other sources for the pigment?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"For staining walnut, I usually use a mixture of burnt umber, burnt sienna and van dyke brown. I usually start with a ratio of about 6:3:1. "

Will you post a picture of the result?

Re: Stains for walnut

#16

JL

Re: Way wrong??

JL

I have to stain a trestle style dining room table (8' L x 42" W) and two benches.

Going by your formula (15% pigment, 15% oil, 70% mineral spirits), a small tube (37 ml) should shield 1 pint (247 ml). I have no problem w/ getting two tubes.

Re: Stains for walnut

#17

that will work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If staining as I do it, a pint will last for many projects. A quart of Sherwin Williams pigment stain from the 70's (back when it was made from Burnt Umber mineral pigment) lasted me decades. I recall mixing about 50 mL for the two bed side chests and had some left over.

I recently bought some 6 oz tubes of art pigment for about $5. (It was more yellow than I preferred but ok. Burnt umber should be reddish brown) I prefer the Mosher Japan colors if you can find it. My former supplier quit stocking it.

Re: Stains for walnut

#18

Re: Way wrong

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Wow, a tube of oil based artist colors, the way I mix and use it would probably stain half of my shop walls if not all. I certainly am not an expert, but I am quite satisfied with my results.

I purchased a whole box of oil stains at a flea market about 20 years ago. Most were standard stains, some were custom mixed. I also purchased a "set" of oil based artist pigment tubes (think there are about 16 or so tubes. When I mix my stain, I usually find the closest colors I am looking for in the old cans, then either mix some of these together in a small container and/or add the artist pigments with it until I am satisfied.

The biggest issue for me is viewing the sample stained boards in various lights. IE: Sunlight, incandescent, florescent sunlight and daylight bulbs, etc., as each will show different colors. This is very necessary when matching the color on a repair of a project like antique furniture. I would say the tubes, and my stain stash will last me and probably my son for our lifetime.

The only exception to this was when we made all the baseboard and trim for my sons house from white oak, then we sprayed on a commercial Minwax stain, and wiped it down with a rag. That involved several board feet of lumber. I would estimate I discard 70 to 80% of the stain I use with the staining brushes, rags and wiping rags.

Re: Stains for walnut

#19

Thanks Bill!

Denny

I just tried your recipe out today, easy to mix and it looks good too.

Denny

Re: Stains for walnut

#21

Re: Have you watched how I apply it?

Denny

I don't think I have. I just rubbed on a light coat and rubbed off any excess. I did another test on some maple just to see how much (and how evenly) it was being applied. Any tricks???

Re: Stains for walnut

#22

You will need to obtain a staining aid

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well, actually you need at least one and preferably two stain aids. The first is a ball of absorbent cotton. The second is someone to dip this ball into the stain and rub/dab it onto the wood. If there is not excess stain in the rubber you can control the take onto the wood by how much and how hard you rub. For a porous wood be sure stain is dabbed into the pores. You will need good light to be sure.




Re: Stains for walnut

#23

Re: You will need to obtain a staining aid

Denny

The first staining aid looks like the same approach I use with shellac, but your assistant looks irreplaceable.

Thanks again,

Denny

Re: Stains for walnut

#24

Yes indeed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Treat the stain as though it was to be rubbed on shellac. You will be amazed how little stain gets used on a typical project.

Re: Stains for walnut

#25

Re: Other sources for the pigment?

William Duffield

I should have said "I have used…" It's been a while. Sorry, I can't find a picture of an example. I should have kept better notes and used a better camera and lighting.

In any case, it's only a starting point, and the results depend on the walnut you start with, and whatever coats of finish you put over the top of the stain. For example, we finished with yellow waxed shellac (called 3 lb. Orange back then) and a nitrocellulose lacquer product from Behlens. As someone else in this thread quipped, "FFF."