Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Another Victim

Posts

Another Victim

#1

Another Victim

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Picked this one up for $3 at an estate sale.

It's really pushing the limit though. Normally I would have skipped it. It's a newer saw and the blade appears to be loaded with rust (but no pitting). However, it's a panel saw and I've not seen many of those. Also, the blade is straight and the handle is solid.

We'll see how it cleans up.


Re: Another Victim

#2

Re: Another Victim

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Wish I would find a panel saw for $3. I've been looking for one. I'd love to find a Rip panel saw. There are some crazy prices on eBay.

Nice find.

Re: Another Victim

#3

Re: Panel Saw?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Not being a hand tool aficionado, help me out with definitions here.

I understand rip and cross-cut. What is a panel saw?

Henry

Re: Another Victim

#4

Re: Another Victim

Rick W

I think it will clean up just fine. I've cleaned up saws in far worse condition, and they turned out fine. I even found the remains of the original etch under a mass of rust on a saw I thought was hopeless.

I've found that removing most of the rust with a razor blade scraper really helps. If you hold the scraper at the proper angle, you can get almost all the rust off fairly quickly. Then I use a sanding block with 220 and 320 grit wet or dry sandpaper lubricated with mineral spirits to remove the rest of the rust.

Good luck with it!

Rick

Re: Another Victim

#5

Re: Panel Saw?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Henry, a panel saw is a shorter more compact saw.

Most of the saws we see are 26" long saws with wider blades and bigger handles that are more often used for carpentry.

Panel saws are around 16" to 24" long with smaller handles.

Re: Another Victim

#6

Re: Another Victim

William Duffield

If you want a finish that looks more like the original, use 600 grit paper, instead of 220 and 320, wrap it around a flat block, and sand only in the direction of the tooth line. (Don't use a ROS, for example). Of course, it will take longer and it won't improve the saw's functionality, but it may save the etch.

Re: Another Victim

#7

A bit of an odd saw....

Christopher Fitch Memphis

One thing to note: there's no etch to speak of... not even a hint. This makes it harder to date.

The saw blade is roughly 20 inches long. It appears to be 9 PPI.

Odd things:

- The medallion first appeared to be nickel plated which would put it near the end of the Disston line. However, the face of the medallion clearly matches one from before 1940. Also, upon cleaning it looks more like brass now.

Here's the medallion resting in the handle:


Here's the link to the medallions on the Disstionian Institute

http://disstonianinstitute.com/medezguide.html

- At first glance I thought the handle was from a D-23 but there's a few things wrong with that

* The handle is too nice. I have a D-23 and the handle is less polished and not as well made. The transition edges are much smoother on this saw.

* The handle has a notch on top. The D-23's really didn't have that. But the No. 12 and the No 16 handles do have something like that.

* The handle has three screws. D-23 Panel saws had four screws. No.12 and No. 16 panel saws had three screws.

Here's two pictures of the handle:



Comparing to the handles listed here:

http://disstonianinstitute.com/quickglance.html

I'd say it's closest to a No. 16.

Anyway...that's about all I can say for now.