Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Shop Vac Filter question

Posts

Shop Vac Filter question

#1

Shop Vac Filter question

Barry Irby

I have a Rigid Shop Vac and hooked it up to my stationary sander. And I use it on my ROS as well. The trouble is that the cylindrical pleated filter gets completely packed with dust. Its a PITA to take it outside and beat it out and blow it out. It gets thick enough to seriously reduce the suction.

Do any of the units that claim to have a self cleaning system actually work?

Is there a simple solution? Some kind of bag or cover?

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#2

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

Alan Marchbanks

Barry,

I set my shopvac up with the small Dust Deputy 3-4 years ago. It is used with my sanders and general cleanup and very little dust makes it to the vac container. I had a hard time believing the revues about the Dust Deputy and how little dust went to the vac. I was very pleasantly surprised, an have since added one to a second vac used mainly with my router table. After that, I added a Super Dust Deputy ahead of my Jet dust collector for my main dust system and am very happy with it also. I think my first one has paid for itself by not having to buy so many filters. The filter will still collect fines over time but has not clogged any near as bad as it used to. Hope this helps. There are many reviews in the forums.

Alan

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#3

I use bags...

John in NM

For precisely this reason. Why collect all that dust just to have the mess of cleaning the filter? Bags are nice, only get a little mess around the inlet when you change them.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#4

Re: I use bags...

Barry Irby

Where do you get the bags? Are they universal?

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#5

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

Paul Leuba

I can affirm the value of the Dust Deputy system in keeping vacuum filters/bags from getting loaded with small particles and clogging. My vacuum has been fronted with a Dust Deputy for about 5 years and I've changed the vacuum bag only twice during this period, even though I have used it frequently with a ROS and a belt sander. Additionally, my shop dust collector system is a single stage Delta that is fronted with the Rockler trash can style equivalent of the Dust Deputy, and this does a good job of pulling the larger particles and chips from the vacuum stream before they get to the collection filter and bag.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#7

pretty much universal...

John in NM

just need the appropriate size for your vacuum. Home Depot or Lowes is where I get them. I usually try to get the matching brand, but I don't think it matters.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#8

Re: pretty much universal...

John McGaw

Size is one consideration but to me the fitting that connects the inlet hose to the bag would seem more important. The rubber connector that seals the bag to the fitting inside the canister on my Fein wouldn't necessarily be the same for every other brand. The brand-name Fein bags are pretty pricey so the next time I need to buy some perhaps I should check out the 'universal' types to see if they might work.

I do something which would probably not be advisable for some cheaper vacs (and it might not be advisable for my Fein although I've been doing it for a decade or so): I use the pleated HEPA filter along with the paper filter bag. The motor cooling on the Fein is supposed to be independent of the regular vac air flow so a bit of obstruction can't lead to overheating. I find that the combination works for even nasty stuff like drywall sanding.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#9

Wouldn't expect it for Fein or Festool...

John in NM

But Shop Vac and Rigdid? Bags are pretty much all the same for the domestic brands. I get the brand of the vac if I can, but I've had others work fine too.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#10

Just looked them up....

Barry Irby

Home Depot sell them for about $9 each in a 2 pack. I will get some and try them. I am a tightwad. do you use them for everything or just when you are sanding and getting a lot of fines? When you are getting a lot of fines does the suction drop off dramatically like it does with just the pleated filter or does it hold up better?

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#11

Kneale Brownson

Big fan of Dust Deputy and Bags for my Ridgid


Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#12

Re: Just looked them up....

John in NM

I'm a tightwad too :D so I use them for everything, even wet vacing if its only a little fluid. Too much and the bag will probably break.

They do drop off some in suction as they load up, but I don't find it to be as bad as with those cartridges. Perhaps the filter area is larger or perhaps it has to do with the loading being more dispersed than with a cartridge.

I also run them longer than I probably should, being a tightwad. The trouble with that is the bag can rip easily if its really full, in addition to the reduced filter efficiency.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#13

Drywall Bags Are Best

Dave's Not Here

I don't just use bags, I use the bags made for drywall sanding. Instead of the regular filter I also use a HEPA filter made for my RIDGID shop vacs. Between the drywall bags and the HEPA filter I'm pretty sure that I keep almost all of the dust within the vacs canister and I only have to clean the filter maybe every third or fourth bag replacement.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Wouldn't expect it for Fein or Festool...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

The 12 gallon ShopVac bags work well in a Fein Turbo II.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#15

Don't laugh

Joe W, Detroit

but, I have used a used pair of panty hose in the past. Not as efficient as bags designed for the purpose, but in a pinch it helped reduce the clogging to a manageable level. And they were free. Cut the legs off with enough leftover to tie a know and slipped it over the pleated filter.

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

#16

Re: Shop Vac Filter question

rockytoptim

+1 on dust deputy. Best $ I have ever spent. I loved it so much after a year I gave one as a christmas present to a good friend.