Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

Posts

Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#1

Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

Howard Pollack

Does anyone know anything about the Robland XSDB310 jointer/planer? I have an opportunity to buy one close to home. The asking price is $1300. I can find next to nothing about it on the web. Thanks.

-Howard

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#2

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

John McGaw

Well, the main parts of the unit -- the castings etc -- look to be identical to the old standby X31 jointer/planer. That includes the add-on mortiser. I have the full X31 combination machine and have found the jointer/planer (and the mortiser) to be quite functional and reliable. One must work out the subtleties of working with a combination machine to make it efficient since the changeover, while pretty easy and quick, is not so quick as moving between one separate machine and another. Probably the weakest link is the relatively short jointer tables; for a 12" jointer a couple of extra feet would be nice to have. Then again, since making the changeover requires flipping both tables upward on their pivots it would involve a lot of weightlifting if they were much longer.

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#3

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Probably the weakest link is the relatively short jointer tables; for a 12" jointer a couple of extra feet would be nice to have.

I have a Hammer A3-31 combination machine, and not felt that the "shorter" table length was a disadvantage. The Robland looks similar to the Hammer. In the past I had an 8" dedicated jointer (a Delta) with a long bed. It did not offer more in this area. In my opinion, a bed just needs to be "long enough". More important than the length is its width. A 12" wide bed offers up a lot more functionality.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#4

question for Derek

Howard Pollack

Derek does you Hammer machine have straight blades or a helical head? I'm also thinking of buying the Hammer, but with the helical head the price becomes very high. If you do have the straight blade cutter head, what do you think of it? Thanks.

-Howard

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#5

Re: question for Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Howard

The Hammer A3-31 is a superb machine. That's it on the left. I also have a Hammer N4400 bandsaw ..


The A3-31 has a 310mm wide bed (about 12 3/4") and is 4 hp. Mine does have the helical "silent head" blades, which were fitted by the agent at purchase. These are incredible - not only do they produce a fantastic finish, but they reduce noise levels to such as extent that it is possible to have a normal conversation with the machine running.

Two other essential accessories are the digital gauge (for determining thickness), which is very accurate, and wheels to move the machine around, if you are short of space, like myself. Keep in mind that this machine is metric, and the digital gauge is in mm.

The original straight blade machine is rated at 20 amps, just like the N4400 bandsaw. However, while the bandsaw must have 20 amps to run (I needed to install a circuit for that), the A3-31 with helical heads will run comfortably on 15 amps. The helical heads appear to reduce the need for extra power.

The fence is accurate and solid. It has a European guard. The change over is quite quick. It takes me about 2-3 minutes each way now.

I've had the A3-31 for about 4 years now, and tomorrow I will rotate the blades to their second edge. That is amazing longevity. I would purchase this machine again in a flash.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#6

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"and not felt that the "shorter" table length was a disadvantage"

Is your statement influenced by your ability to correct lack of straightness off the machine with a hand plane?

I don' t hand plane edges. I upgraded to an 8" long bed to get the extra length that leads to easier straightening.

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#7

Re: question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

"and not felt that the "shorter" table length was a disadvantage"

Is your statement influenced by your ability to correct lack of straightness off the machine with a hand plane?

I don' t hand plane edges. I upgraded to an 8" long bed to get the extra length that leads to easier straightening.

Hi Bill

The bed of the Hammer A3-31 is 1400mm. My previous jointer was a long bed 8", which was about 500mm longer.

I've had the Hammer about 3 or 4 years now and run some longish boards (around 3m) through it. I have never felt like I needed a longer bed, or that I had to finish with a hand plane (I do re-edge boards with a jointer plane, but that is because the handplane puts on a smoother edge for better joining).

I am not sure whether I use a different technique with the Hammer compared to the longer 8" machine. I suspect that I did the same with the latter. It is a matter of ensuring that the board is flat to the bed as it enters and especially as it exits the head. This is just hand pressure.

The other issue is that most of the boards I run though the machine are under 1 1/2m. I would rather joint boards that have been shortened than left long since less waste needs to be removed, and thickness is preserved. On the relatively few occasions where I have jointed long and wide boards, the advantage of the extra length of an 8" machine lies in preventing the board tipping at the exit end. In this case, I just add a roller stand.

A large part of the motivation to get the Hammer was that it was a way to get a wide bed (310mm). A dedicated jointer with this width would be an aircraft carrier, and I do not have room for one in my shop. The combo was the logical way to do this. The shorter bed was the compromise.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#8

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

John McGaw

My problem with shortish jointer tables is not with 'ordinary' work with light boards. The problem comes when trying to handle long thick heavy wood where supporting the far end of the stock is impossible when working single handed. Using a roller stand would seem like an option but in my experience they are unreliable and likely to shift and when the far end of the stock gets to the roller there is invariably a momentary shift which affects the outcome. One of the first tasks I set the jointer to was two slabs of laminated red oak about 2m long, 300cm wide and about 10cm thick that taught me a lot of lessons about my and my machine's limitations.

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

#9

Re: Robland XSDB310 Jointer/planer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One of the first tasks I set the jointer to was two slabs of laminated red oak about 2m long, 300cm wide and about 10cm thick that taught me a lot of lessons about my and my machine's limitations.

Hi John

Not disagreeing with you. It is a choice between what you work mostly, and what you may work occasionally.

Much of my recent machining has been with rough sawn Hard Maple boards about 2m long, 250mm wide and 50mm thick. They are heavy. The Hammer handled them quite easily. The table beds were long enough to work without the need for a roller stand. These are, however, the exception.

More commonly, I have boards that are 1 - 1.5m long, about 300mm wide and 50mm thick. These dimensions place an emphasis on a jointer that can take the board width. This is where a wide jointer scores. A combo machine is one of the more cost effective ways to achieve this goal.

Regards from Perth

Derek