Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

I think I picked a fight *LINK*

Posts

I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#1

Alan Young

I think I picked a fight *LINK*

Alan Young

I saw this video come across my facebook news feed- A nice looking rustic farmhouse styled dining table. I watched the video that has no verbal comments on what is happening just some text here and there. I get the main construction techniques until the bread board end application where the builder puts dominoes in every long piece and matches in the bread board end. He then "pins" the center long pieces- I assume through the glued in dominoes. The pinning process is normally done on the BB end itself though an elongated hole in the tenon fashioned on the long pieces.


Only the center pin gets glued. I asked the maker about his technique and found his answer unconvincing. I posted his video and if I did it correctly you'll see the part where he starts to make the BB end.. other wise the process starts at 4:45 minutes into the video..I am not one to pick a fight but when I see a technique that I don't understand or understand it to be counter productive I want to hear from the maker. If I am missing something here let me know- Otherwise I think his technique does nothing to counteract the wood movement of the loang pieces attached to the BB end-

-Alan


Bread Board End technique????

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#2

Not Clear

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

He's using the dominoes as a substitute for integral haunched tenons, but he doesn't show any elongated mortises that would allow the expansion of the long boards nor oblong pin holes. While he may reply upon the dominos for his tenons, prediction is something's gonna bust or split or both.

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#3

Alan Young

That-- and the pinning dowels

Alan Young

are through the long boards not the Bread board ends. The pinning dowels are supposed to be on the Bread Board end going through the (in this case) dominoes which are functioning as tenons and would keep the BB tight to the ends of the long boards. Sooner or later the BB will loosen from the long boards...

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#4

6 of 1

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've seen it done either way, but there still must be a way for the pins to move with the expanding/contracting board. THAT is what he's not showing. Even if he uses 22mm tenons in 24mm slots, it would no give sufficient room for lateral movement, even if he could center the pins perfectly.

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#5

Re: 6 of 1

jesse cloud

Its pretty easy to make extra wide mortises with a domino by taking multiple plunges after moving the machine between plunges.

But there is no evidence that he did that.

My money would be on something breaking real soon.

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#6

Alan Young

Re: 6 of 1

Alan Young

He said "Yep, theyre pinned on the "long boards" and glued into the BB. It has a loose joint which compensates for the movement in the wood"

Well I am not seeing a "loose joint" and if he did make the mortices larger in the BB he counter acted the ability of the dominos to move by gluing each domino in the BB end. I see too many possibilities for something to go wrong. His video is sponsored by Woodcraft- I would like to think that someone in their editorial staff would have some understanding of basic technique and make sure their sponsored videos demonstrated techniques in a reliable fashion....

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#7

Selling

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Dominos, you think? :D

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#8

YouTube with poor info, that's unpossible!


Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#9

Re: I think I picked a fight

Rum

Just remember:

You can't tell nobody nothing, especially if its something they didn't want to know.

Re: I think I picked a fight *LINK*

#10

Not sure what's worse ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... the technique or the music!

That is not a breadboard end. The object of the breadboard to to allow for lateral movement due to humidity. He has not done so there - the end cap is a rigid, unmoving piece. He even glued both sides of the Dominos! He adds pins to the Dominos in the tabletop, demonstrating that he has no idea what he is doing (the pins should be as per your illustration, that is, pinning the breadboard to the tenons, with slots for lateral movement).

It is quite possible to build a breadboard end using Dominos. He has not done that here.

Regards from Perth

Derek