A friend came into a stash of Canadian red cherry logs. I looked it up and saw that's it's a decent tree for our climate but there's no information about its woodworking properties.
It doesn't specifically discuss working properties but from the endgrain pictures it looks much like other cherry species and my guess is the properties would be similar.
Maybe your friend will share some pieces and you can report back!
It's chokecherry, Prunus virginiana. It doesn't grow here in West Jersey, and I have no experience with it, but I've been told by noted wood turner Mark Sfirri that it is dangerous to turn it due to the incidence of ring shake. The photo in the link I supplied is useless, but if you do a Google image search for "ring shake" there are lots of clear examples.
Thanks for that info, John. Around here, the chokecherry is a bush that yields fruit that makes delightful jams and jellies. It's not used for anything else.
This is the size of my buddy's Canadian cherry:
That's a full size framing square in the foreground, so it would appear some of those logs are at least 12". At any rate, it's wood, so I told him to get it cut at 1-18" thick and sticker it for a couple years in his barn.
>>>I've been told by noted wood turner Mark Sfirri that it is dangerous to turn it due to the incidence of ring shake.
I know nothing specifically about that species but based on my experience with ring shake it varies widely from tree to tree. I've had walnut trees with horrible ring shake as well as chinese cherry. One walnut, in particular, fell into pieces when chainsawed into turning blanks. Other walnut trees grown in the same location (and even another part of the same tree) had no ring shake.
This makes wonder if the warning was based on broad or perhaps more limited experience.
Some interesting things about ring shake here, including comments from Gene Wengert:
Prunus serotina doesn't seem very likely, given that according to Wikipedia its distribtion doesn't seem to extend as far north as Canada. Another possibility is, although not known as red cherry, Prunus pensylvanica or pin cherry which is widely distributed in Canada. It's wood is descibed as " light, moderately soft, porous, and low in strength giving it little commercial value", so it doesn't seem likely to be suitable for furniture or flooring.
John, That was my thread and discussion with Dr Wengert. I don't think I swayed him away from his belief of the bacteria starting in the stump then progressing upward a few inches per year, which couldn't possibly have been the cause from what I've seen.
I wish I could find a student needing a masters or doctorate thesis that I could share some info with, but basically what it boils down to, is whole tree trunks and limbs split radially when they loose moisture, just as seen in firewood. However during long periods of drought once the heartwood has lost enough moisture to contract, whenever the rain returns again, the sapwood being on the outside plus more absorbent becomes saturated faster then swells. In all but a few species the compression perpendicular to the grain is many times greater than tension perpendicular to the grain, so it pops loose at that boundary line between sapwood and heartwood.
If there are no injuries to the tree before or afterwards which allow air and insects into the void, the tree can live a healthy life, but once an injury occurs that provides a port of entry, allowing ants to move in bringing plenty of stuff, but air is the only missing ingredient to allow wood to decay.
I have come to believe that lots of hollow trees were formally really shake riddled trees that later got injured allowing an entry point connecting to the existing void which becomes an express lane for decay.
Very interesting! I'd read that thread in the past and his comments about the bacteria but of course on that forum there's no telling who is posting (other than Gene).
It would be a great research and thesis topic.
The idea of hollow trees started by ring shake is interesting too. I'd have to think more about that. I've imagined some hollowing came from a breach at ground level underground. I know I've sawn a number of eastern red cedar trees, for example, that had small hollows in the center full of ants. I can't remember seeing ring shake on cedar, most likely a different issue there.
I assume a small hollowing in the center of a large tree might be different, since the ring shake caused by the compression you mention would be near the outside of the tree. I don't remember seeing ring shake on small diameter trees but can't say I've ever really looked for it. But it seems like we would see ants in ring cavities not far below the bark or evidence of ant colonies deeper in the wood even without central hollowing. Most hollowing I've seen is central to the tree so I assumed it was from some weakness related to the pith.
I do remember one cherry tree here about 18" dia that was essentially hollow except for about 2" around the outside. The center apparently decayed from that outside 2" inward which in hindsight could have begun with ring shake. In this case most of the center of the tree was still present but honeycombed with what appeared to be many years of carpenter bee nesting cavities. (I saved a big piece of that.) That tree had outside access down one side which I always assumed came from a lightning strike but it might have even been mechanical damage since tree is on my property boundary very close to the road (still standing).
BTW, the most interesting ant colony I found in a tree was in a hollow at least 60' above the ground in an oak tree. A storm broke the tree in half and I was cutting firewood when I cut into the nest. The breach was at decay from a broken limb with a huge nest of the biggest carpenter ants I can remember. The ants climbed the outside the whole way. Seems like they could have found something a little closer to the ground!
I have never seen ring shake in a cherry tree around here in NW PA. We have taken down more than a few. The only ring shake I have seen was a massive Box Elder that a few of us split up.
Some of the prettiest cherry I ever bought was from near twin cities. The farther north it grows the more distinct the growth rings and for me prettier grain. There is a color change also. But when it hits its northern limit it grows so slow that the trees acquire defects and they don't yield good lumber. The logs in the picture look like fine logs, though small, and they will yield good lumber.
About 4" of the center of cherry usually disintegrates upon drying. It is usually "boxed out" at the mill and used for pallet wood. If the person sawing knows his stuff the logs will be turned as they are sawed to get the better lumber from the outside of the log.
Sapwood shrinks more than heartwood in cherry. Boards with sap on one side will cup severely upon drying unless they are crushed flat under a heavy pile.
Fresh sawed cherry turns some interesting colors as it dries.
I live in Ontario roughly parallel to Ottawa. Pin and Choke cherry grow like weeds around here and ring shake is indeed an issue with the wood. Our trees which only get to 6-8 inches in diameter and by that time the centers are usually rotting. Quite often there are multiple trunks from the same "root".
They do not look like the trunks in the picture. The pin cherry and perhaps the choke cherry bark looks more like a white paper birch bark surface but is brown.