I had a call from a chap in WI who has a number of various sized cherry burls for sale.He was seeking advice on a selling price. I left it that I would attempt to answer his question by inquiring here. The trees are still standing and will be harvested by cutting the stem about a foot on either side of the burl.
I don't know how anyone could say without knowing what they're like. I've been offered burls that were exquisite and probably worth a small fortune but just as often they've been suitable for firewood. I'd have to see what the eye structure looks like first.
Probably 95% of people couldn't tell you the difference between a burl and a canker, and in my area it will be a canker about that same percent of the time.
You should suggest that he take some good photos to show his offerings, and if they are really good someone will make an offer.
Is there not a standard or semi-standard price per pound paid assuming the burl is sound/pristine/solid? The old rule of thumb was about $2.00 per lb for quality cherry in the late '90s but am sure its higher today.
depends, in part, on MC. People don't buy water at wood prices. Your description is that they are fully wet. When dry they may be 1/2 the weight. Savvy buyer will ask for the MC.
Are these to be harvested with log sections attached? A burl "cap" that might weigh 20lbs. attached to 80lbs. of trunk won't bring the same price as an 100lb. burl
Without the burl cut open so the buyer can see the inside buying one is a huge gamble. I've cut a number and some are nearly worthless with rot and bark inclusions. Some are beautiful.
The problem is cutting it to take a look may severely limit the use. Still, if I wanted to sell a burl I would proceed exactly as if I was cutting one open for myself: examine it carefully, make my best guess judgement call, then make an initial cut. Once I see the inside from that cut I make a further guesses and more cuts. Sometimes I'll end up with a number of smaller pieces which are still useful. I'm sure the guy could even sell small pieces for pen blanks, perhaps about 3/4"x3/4"x5". I'm always surprised at how much people will pay for pen blanks.
For my own use once all the cuts are made I would seal with wax and let air dry for 5-10 years. That may not be a good business model for someone wanting to make some money right away.
Another way to price is to do some research and find out what kind of prices sellers are asking. The guy can do that himself.
BTW, I love cherry burls. I have a number growing in my woods that I'm keeping an eye on. One came down in a storm - it wasn't very big but still brought a reasonable price when I donated it for a club auction.