Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Bench length for table?

Posts

Bench length for table?

#1

JL

Bench length for table?

JL

Going to buy lumber and start on benches for a dining room table.

The table is going to be 8' long.

How long to make the benches?

My first thought was to also make them 8' long.

My second thoughts are to make them shorter - 7' 6" to make it easier to get around the table. It also makes construction a bit easier.

Re: Bench length for table?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Another consideration?

Ellis Walentine

Personally, I don't like to have to get into or out of a middle seat on a bench. Assuming you plan on having seating for four people on each side of this table, how about making two 4' benches for each side, with just enough room between them for each person to have an end seat? Other than that, your idea of shortening the benches is possibly a reasonable one, though I doubt that the 3" you'll save at each end will be very noticeable to people walking around the table.

Hey, you're a chairmaker. How about that for an idea? :)

Ellis

Re: Bench length for table?

#3

Re: Another consideration?

George Koch

When I made some I made them so they would fit entirely between the table legs, so the bench could move push under the table if desired. George

Re: Bench length for table?

#4

JL

Re: Another consideration?

JL

A interesting thought.

It would mean making 12 legs and 6 leg stretchers for each side - so all told instead of 16 legs and 8 stretchers, I would be making 24 legs and 12 stretchers. I would be making 4 center stretchers per side instead of 3.

Fortunately I can turn bamboo style rather quickly.

It is doable. I will ask my niece - after all, it is for her.

Re: Bench length for table?

#5

Alan Young

Yes

Alan Young

My clients went with shorter benches for this project-




Re: Bench length for table?

#6

Re: Another consideration?

John K Jordan

Having had a table with four chairs and one long bench (great when the boys were small, they had no problem with the access) I really like the two-bench per side idea. Benches of unequal lengths might even be interesting, especially if there were kids in the family.

JKJ

Re: Bench length for table?

#7

Re: Another consideration?

John McGaw

If the leg/trestle design of the table is amenable then, as a matter of practicality, I'd certainly lean toward a bench that will fit underneath. I guess it is a matter of balancing out the seating -- if the legs or trestle are relatively far from the table's end then the loss of seating capacity could cancel out the convenience.

Re: Bench length for table?

#8

Re: Yes

William Duffield

In your third photo, wouldn't it make more sense to put the shorter benches at the ends and the longer benches along the long sides of the table? Of course, I realize they can be rearranged any way you like them for the current event.

Re: Bench length for table?

#9

Alan Young

I think that is an optical illusion

Alan Young

This was done in 2007 so I don't recall everything but I believe the benches were all the same length- That picture to which you refer does make it look like the bench at the end is longer than the bench on the side and if that were the case I would swith them-but I think it's just an optical illusion and that the benches were all the same length...

Re: Bench length for table?

#11

Second Ellis, and...

Grant Smith

Consider if the table will have people seated at its ends. If so, and depending on the width of the table, the benches might be made significantly shorter than at a table with no end "sitters". Otherwise, bench sitters and end sitters will have to fight over space for their tableware.

Another thing to think about is the location of table legs. The legs should be located out of knee banging range of both end sitters and bench sitters. If there are no end sitters, then the table legs should be located such that side sitters don't (easily) bang their knees.

If this is an heirloom quality project, it may be worth while to create a plywood mock up, or at least visit some furniture stores and take some dimensions of their offerings. You don't have to like the style or build quality of a table to learn something from its construction.

You can also learn an incredible amount by googling "standard dimensions for dining tables"

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Bench length for table?

#12

JL

Re: Second Ellis, and...

JL

Looked up table and bench configurations online.

Majority of benches were slightly shorter than the tables (3-6").

I will talk to my niece to see if she wants two benches per side or one.

Re: Bench length for table?

#13

something to consider....

Joseph Piotrowski

two benches on at least one side allow easy handicap access.

Re: Bench length for table?

#14

Go Whole Hog

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

with eight 18" stools? 4 per side with open table ends or 3 on a side and one on the ends with lots of clearance. Maximum flexibility and easy individual access.

Re: Bench length for table?

#15

Re: Go Whole Hog

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does anyone here enjoy eating dinner on a seating device that has no back and a flat seat- stool or bench? As far as a bench, next time there is an opportunity observe the different distances individuals prefer for sitting at a table to eat.

Re: Bench length for table?

#16

Re: Go Whole Hog

William Duffield

The only place I have ever found picnic table and bench seating appropriate and enjoyable was at the Hofbraühaus München. :D

Re: Bench length for table?

#17

Stools

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

prevent you from taking others with you when you go horizontal :D

Re: Bench length for table?

#18

Re: The Ultimate Demise of the Bench Seat

William Duffield

The latest revolution in picnic tables has arrived.

http://benchcrafted.blogspot.com/2017/03/the-benchcrafted-swing-away-seat.html


Re: Bench length for table?

#19

Now that is way cool!!!


Re: Bench length for table?

#20

JL

Did you see the price??

JL

I have no fear that benches will go away for that price!

Re: Bench length for table?

#21

Re: Did you see the price??

William Duffield

Of course, some people will still want picnic benches just for nostalgia reasons, no matter the inconvenience and discomfort, and because there are lots of people out there (whose only tool is a hammer) who couldn't figure out how to install one of the Benchcrafted stools. But if they become popular enough, Ikea will have them mass produced in China, and the price will come down substantially.