I'm aways away from finishing a Cherry Morris chair but have started considering the final finish. I will set the sanded pieces in the sun for a few days to age and darken prior to assembling. As of now I think I'll use a water based poly as a finish and let the wood continue to darken without using stain or dye. Will this have any effect of blotching? Should I use Charles Neil's conditioner to help prevent blotching prior to spraying the poly?
BUT, do some samples first. Only water based poly on cherry will give you a very "cold" finish. Not something I would like on my furniture. As far as I am concerned, water based should never be used on walnut and cherry. You will have plenty of advice opposing my opinion on this I'm sure!
As Dick suggested, begin making finish samples now. You might start with an oil based finish like danish oil or even just boiled linseed oil on one piece, a water borne acrylic on another, a water borne emulsified urethane on a third for starters. An emulsified urethane like EnduroVar might leave a look between an oil based finish and a water borne acrylic. No doubt there are other products like EnduroVar, that is the only water borne urethane I have used, and that was 5 or 6 years ago.
With samples of those three, you will be in good position to ask for targeted suggestions based on those.
And yes, you will see blotching with the boiled linseed oil and maybe with a product like EnduroVar if it is applied by hand rather than sprayed.
Cherry blotches naturally, so my personal taste a cherry finish without blotching doesn't look "natural." Everyone is entitled to their opinions and tastes.
Stuart, don't forget plain old DEWAXED clear (minimum color) shellac as your first coat under the water-based poly. [I believe many sealers are shellac-based, but I could be wrong.] You can either mix your own, or buy premixed. I have used this technique often on cherry, albeit followed by an oil based finish with minimum blotching. However, I am about to use the same technique followed by a water-based poly on oak flooring. Although blotching is not a concern with the oak, warming up the color of the water-based poly is. And, it is my understanding that dewaxed shellac is compatible with the water-based polys. Nonetheless, I plan to experiment on scrap first. Good luck. Jim
Take good notes with the samples. It is far too easy to forget exactly what you did after a couple of days. You can hasten evaporative finishes with a heat gun when making the samples.
... would be to wipe on a thin coat of Waterlox to warm things up, then topcoat with an oil-based polyurethane, probably one or two coats of gloss followed by a coat of satin. I don't like oil finishes on seating furniture. They can soften or esterify or whatever they do over time and become sticky. I don't use water-based poly often enough to lend you any advice there, except that I've always regarded water-based finishes as cool-looking, though they've come a long way.
I have had good luck with General Arm-R-Seal urethane. It wipes on nicely and dries relatively fast. I've also had successes with Minwax Helmsman spar urethane, straight from the big box store.
Ellis, You said "I don't like oil finishes on seating furniture. They can soften or esterify or whatever they do over time and become sticky."
I'm not sure how much "time" you're referring to. I have been using Watco Danish Oil since the 1970's and have never had any get soft and/or sticky. Maybe I'm just fortunate that it hasn't happened yet. I've used it on a Red Oak rolltop desk, Cherry entertainment center, White Oak Morris chair and numerous bowls.
Blotching is related to sanding. Some areas absorb more finish than others, and the more even the surface preparation the less uneven absorption occurs.
When finishing with wipe on finishes (eg. oil, poly) I always sand cherry to 400 grit, and blotchiness is managed. Some blotchiness always occurs - it's the nature and figure of the wood. However some blotchiness looks good and some looks awful. Bad looking blotchiness is reduced by increased sanding.
Try it yourself - find some cherry that is prone to blotch (not all of it is), then sand half to 120 grit and sand half to 400 grit before finishing. See the difference.
Also make sure you're sanding properly and sufficiently. Sanding technique is greatly underestimated as a factor in finishing success.
No idea what the finishes were that failed. I've seen chairs that are so sticky and dirty on the top back rail, you can peel it with your fingernail. I always assumed it was from natural hand oils and purchased hand creams and lotions. I've also seen that around knobs on kitchen cabinets. But when cleaned off with mineral spirits, it was basically down to bare wood.
Re: I've seen chairs where you can peel the finish
Don Stephan
My family's factory kitchen cabinets and dining chairs from about 1964 were like that after 15 years. I was told or read somewhere that oil from our skin does that to nitrocellulose lacquer over time.
All cents are welcome, Doug. I think I've confused things by calling out "oil finishes," which is always a squishy term. I was flashing back on a hearthstone at my mother-in-law's house that had been finished with linseed oil, which, as you know doesn't harden; and it always had a sticky feel. Your pants would stick when you sat on it.
There are distinct differences between long oils, such as linseed and tung, and oil-varnish mixes, which are often sold as "Danish oils." Both these build very slowly, cure soft because of the unmodified oil and leave a matte finish. They have advantages for application but they don't give much protection from water, water vapor or abrasion. I regard them as most useful for things that don't get a lot of wear and tear or handling -- sculptural pieces, treen, vertical surfaces, things that are primarily for display, where the matte finish is desirable and the softness is not a problem.
Hard-curing films such as shellac, lacquer, and the various varnishes -- including wiping varnishes -- are (IMO) the better choice for tabletops, seating and things that will be handled or abused. They build up on the wood, form a continuous film over the pores and provide more protection from abrasion. You can approximate the close-to-the-wood look of a long oil finish with film finishes by either using a matte or satin sheen for the final coat or rubbing out to a satin finish.