Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Feather or Crotch Figure

Posts

Feather or Crotch Figure

#1

Feather or Crotch Figure

Don Stephan

A couple bowls from the base of a fork from an American elm have marvelous figure. Has anyone seen any discussion addressing why the tree makes this figure at the base of forks? Which direction(s) are the cells running, anyway? Just curious. Happy Earth Day.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#2

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The tree is trying to stitch the fork back together. Grain is running every which way but mainly perpendicular to the plane of the "Y".

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#3

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Dick Coers

Not dissimilar from the human body. If you do a repetitive motion that loads your body the same way for a long period of time, your body makes extra cells to reinforce the bones. Same with trees. The pith in large horizontal branches is not centered. Extra cells made to hold the weight. The buttress flare has magnificent grain in it, made to hold the tree against wind load. Extra cells sent to held branches together in the crotch. Often cells are made so quickly on the two branches, that bark is trapped inside as the tree reinforces itself. I like the research that trees and plants can communicate with each other. Even form their own microclimates and develop natural defenses. Unfortunately, humans introduced enemies faster than the trees could adapt. So we are killing them off in alarming rates! Nature is a wonder, and is very adaptive, if we give her a chance!

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#4

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Don Stephan

Thanks Bill and Dick for the informative responses. Now I can make visitors to my studio more fascinated with wood AND give accurate information. Wish there was more discussion of trees and wood.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#5

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Fetcham

I'm not familliar with this species. Any chance of some images?

Jim

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#6

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

philip f Duffy

Agree completely. Is it that we know so little about how trees grow? A good friend and gunsmith always wants the very bottom of walnut trees because that is where the "compression" of wood takes place as the tree develops and grows. Wish we knew more- - about all this world of wonderful trees. P.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#7

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

William Duffield

If you want some examples, search Google Images, and of course read the captions to make sure the picture you are looking at is American elm. Here is an example of crotch figure:


And here is a picture of the tree itself, Ulmus americana.


There are very few American Elms left because most of them succumbed to a European fungus, Dutch Elm Disease.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#8

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Larry Barrett

Here are a couple of photos of a black oak tree that had a very narrow fork, and as the tree grew, the fork was gradually subsumed by the tree. The bark you see was inside the log when I split it. When you look closely at the growth rings you can see the convolutions and wild grain the tree was going through as it grew.

I have thinned down this slab, hoping that I will have an inspiration and be able to preserve this in a table top, or something.




Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#9

ebd

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

ebd

Actually, I think a great deal is known. When in college and graduate school I took courses in plant anatomy. A great deal was known back then (the dark ages) most of which I've forgotten (now 70 and never got a job in my field - I ended up as a programmer/analyst). I'm sure that the field has progressed quite bit since then.

I think the problem is that it's a very academic area of study with it's own specific vocabulary. It's not approachable on an easy going, intuitive level. I don't think most woodworkers would want to put in the amount of effort and study time necessary to master the steep learning curve.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#10

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Dick Coers

Usually they want the bottom section of the tree for gunstocks because of the natural flow of the cells is the same as the angle of the butt to the fore stock for a rifle. It let the gun maker keep a narrow transition, but still let it be very strong since there was no runout of grain. The high figure was a major benefit.

Trees were also marked in virgin forests for ship building. Any white oak with a long flowing curve was marked and harvested for the knees from the keel to the deck. Also the long straight trees carried the mark of British Royalty. These were used for the masts. Unfortunately for the British, after a tea party, their supply dried up!

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#11

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Don Stephan

Compressed a photo more, hopefully it's still clear. Amazing to me how narrow the crotch figure is. The missing rim in the bowl is the base of the fork - I decided to make the bowl as large as possible to include as much figure as possible. The background is the center slab containing the pith, which is as a general rule not included in bowls because of the likelihood of cracks (and it is often hollow).

According the Bruce Hoadley's second wonderful book, Identifying Wood, American elm is one of a group of 5 or 6 elms and hackberry that have rows of wavy pores in late season growth rings, visible to the naked eye and absolutely fascinating. I highly recommend both his books - requires multiple readings but chocked full of information very useful to woodworkers of all levels.


Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#12

tree growth

Tom dunlap

There is a lot known about how trees grow. Deciphering the growth patterns might take some on line research

Basically...we're all taught that trees put on one growth increment per year or

Growth cycle. In the tropics there may be two growth cycles per

Calendar year. This growth isn't just in the trunk. Every twig and branch replicates Itself layer upon layer. In the spring the new growth starts at the branch tips as elongation then expansion. Think of a lava flow of new tissues. This layer expands and flows down to where it encounters another branch. At

That point the tissue flows around the branch. Since the branch has grown

Too there is an overlapping layer of tissues. This is the branch collar. We like to see this layering because the tissues change directions and layers meld together.

When two branches of roughly the same diameter grow

From the same union its called codominant stems. The bark in between

The two will be called included bark until the cambium layers in the two

Stems meld together. Then , every years growth will be as clear wood again

If you want to learn more about tree growth start by searching on the works of Dr. Alex Shigo who is called The Father of Modern Arborculture. His research with the USFS started out in the 60's to find a way to stop decay in tree trunks. Finding some sort of paint or elixir was a goal. What he found was how trees grow to isolate decay from wounds. The model is CODIT.

Tension and compression wood is way more than I care to write about. Lots of info online already

Tom

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#13

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

Don Stephan

Thanks to everyone who has contributed.

The two books by Bruce Hoadley I refer to constantly and I recommend them wholeheartedly. When working as a caretaker in the late 70's and early 80's I was able to attend a one day workshop by Alex Shigo, and later purchased some of his writings.

Unfortunately this forum, and a couple arborists I know, are the only sources for additional information on trees and wood - it's not a subject that's addressed in popular literature since a contributor to FWW passed away years ago. Might be wrong, but I'd guess if more people had even a superficial awareness of what can be seen in the surface of a bowl or furniture there might be a greater appreciation for fine pieces.

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#14

Wood books, pics, and ID

John K Jordan

Don,

I second the recommendation of Hoadley's books, "Understanding Wood" and "Identifying wood" - they have been my go-to books for years. Anyone who works with wood, flat or turning, NEEDS to read his first book, even if only to understand better why and how wood shrinks when drying and moves with the seasons. Reading the second would eliminate a lot of "What is this wood?" questions I see posted on various forums accompanied by a photo of the face of a board. My copy is so well used it is falling apart. The book inspired me to take up the hobby of wood ID and I now keep a supply of razor blades, microscopes and lighted hand lenses, and 365 nm UV lights for fluorescent ID for some species.

If anyone is interested, this is my favorite lens for looking at the pores and growth rings on wood cross sections - it is 10x, LED lighted, good optics, and quite inexpensive:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00CMDIOBK

Hoadley is not only an academic but a craftsman with a personal interest in wood. These two books are probably my favorites in my growing library of wood and tree books.

Another good resource is the Wood Database: http://www.wood-database.com/

Eric has a good article on Wood ID:

http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/wood-identification-guide/ and other great articles: http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/

I also bought his book which I can recommend.

Another web site interesting to wood fans is the HobbitHouseInc site. This guy has more pictures of more species than I've seen anywhere. If nothing else, a look at a few pages will show how much variety in figure and color are within even a single species: http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/

For example, here is his page on American Elm, one of six pages on elm:

http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/elm,%20american.htm

BTW, reading the HobbitHouseInc page on Pink Flamewood is how I found out that former WoodCentralian Jim King had died. (Jim King was the one who who first told me of the importance of boiling difficult woods.) Jim exported wonderful exotics from Peru and donated some for WC benefit auctions. I got some big blocks of wood this way including some amazing Pink Flame and made a bunch of things with it. I still have a little.


http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/pink%20flamewood.htm

JKJ

Re: Feather or Crotch Figure

#15

Thanks for Hobbit House, nice site.