Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Shop Lights and Lumens

Posts

Shop Lights and Lumens

#1

Shop Lights and Lumens

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

My shop is lighted mostly with T8 florescent lights. The life expectancy stated on the bulb packages is a joke. I find myself replacing bulbs routinely, and ballasts now and again.

Our power company has a financial incentive that would substantially fund my replacing the lights with LED shop lights. I looked at LED shop lights at a couple of local places. The boxes say the output is 4,000 lumens. The T8 bulbs are rated at 3,000 lumens. So for 2 T8 bulbs per fixture is the output 6,000 lumens? I'm not sure how to compare.

Any insight would be appreciated!

T.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#2

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

read my article on the topic in the Articles section. Lumens is lumens. What is on the box is the output of a new lamp, regardless of lamp type. The t'8's get weaker with age. Don't know about the LED.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#3

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

Barry Irby

I have read that while LED's will last a very long time the output diminishes over time until at the end they may only produce a 1/4 of their original output. Some of it it is the individual little lights deteriorate but some of it is some of them just fail. Don't take this as gospel. Do more research. May be dependent of the original quality.

I have also been told that there light and "apparent" light. In some cases to get what you perceive as a doubling in the brightness you must increase the output by tenfold. Clearly I need a better understanding.

I installed four 4' LED fixtures from Costco in place of two 8' two bulb T12 lights and am thrilled with the results. Great general illumination.

Read Bill's article.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#4

Don't rely solely on lumens *LINK*

Gary Smyth

LED's do lose output. But it tales a long time. Replacement isn't like we are used to -- complete failure. They have a stated life span identified a "L" which is 70% output as new. This ought to be available on the specs. For example a 30,000 hr. bulb will last 3750 eight hour days until a 70% dimming. It will regress faster after that, but still...

Brightness, measured in lumens, is one part light perception; the other part is color temperature. ... It is measured in degrees Kelvin. See diagram. In fact, the Kelvin scale goes backwards: The higher the color temperature, the cooler light gets, and the lower the color temperature, the warmer light gets. If you are trying to assess color in a specific setting, look at both. Adequate light is one thing, but human viewing can be something different. My preference is to get the highest number of lumens within budget but with the Kelvin temperature about 5500 degres K (daylight) which is close to (but less than "blue sky" outdoor daylight. I favor multiple light sources at the right temperature rather than lumens alone. Kodak real film is calibrated for 5500K daylight as an example. Artists favor North Light for their painting. Also LEDs have little or no UV so they are terrific for display and mort museums have switched to LEDs to protect their artwork.

View short video about lumen loss.






http://www.constructionjunkie.com/blog/2015/5/16/dont-be-fooled-leds-lose-brightness-over-time

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#5

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

Dave Bair

I replaced my incandescent bulbs with screw-in LEDs. They work very well but apparently create some sort of radio interference. Unless the station I tune is really strong, all I get is a loud electronic hum.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#6

North Light

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Visual artists preferred North light because of its evenness through the day and the lack of hard contrast shadows.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#7

Thanks!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Good info all. I appreciate the help. Learned a few things today!

T.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#9

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

John K Jordan

I had one light that interfered with one of my digital calipers. When I tried to use it at my lathe the numbers started jumping erratically when that bulb was on.

I'll check for the FCC mark when I buy new bulbs.

JKJ

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#10

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

Brian Holcombe

Bill's article on the subject is excellent. I took his advice into account when planning out my machine tool shop (really my bandsaw shop as that is the only tool out there.). The measurement to aim for is an appropriate level of foot candles.

I continue to add lighting to my handtool shop, not just overhead but spot lighting as well. I have spot lights at each work station.

I prefer 3500k color lighting but have studio white walls in my shop and also use it as a showroom.

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

#11

Re: Shop Lights and Lumens

Joseph Mulherin

Does the diminished light come down if you are using the strip lights (5500 50) those are the lights I am installing in my shop.