Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Posts

Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#1

Bart Goldberg

Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bart Goldberg

Looking to make some gift boxes and want to make raised panel tops. Anyone have a suggestion for a decent small raised panel bit? Not looking for an ogee design, but just flat cuts.

Thanks

Bart

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#2

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I make this kind of panel on the table saw.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bart Goldberg

Thanks, but that wasn't what I was asking.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#4

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

William Duffield

I'm sure I don't understand what you are looking for either, and I am not surprised Bill couldn't guess. I will recommend that you don't try to use them freehand. They are much safer in a router table. If you don't have a 3-1/4 hp. variable speed router in your router table, I would also recommend you use a vertical panel raising bit, with a tall fence. The bits themselves come in several different profiles, straight, ogee, etc. Some (but not vertical, of course)also come with a back cutter, to center the panel within the frame. If you are looking for a brand name, I prefer Whiteside and Freud bits.

You might also want to check out a badger plane.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bart Goldberg

Bill and Will,

Why is this a confusing request? I'm looking for a suggestion on a decent junior raise panel router bit. Yes for a Router table. Yes I have a 3 hp router. Not that is needed info to answer my simple question. Why is this confusing?

Bart

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#6

Re: OK, Pick One

William Duffield

We're getting closer. These are high quality, but you are going to need to decide on the style and size:


You might be able to get them directly from the manufacturer,

http://www.whitesiderouterbits.com/default.html

but I usually buy my router bits from my closest Woodcraft retail store. They also carry Freud bits, which I might choose, if I couldn't find exactly the profile and size I wanted in Whiteside.

If I were making just one or two doors, and wanted a traditional Colonial or Shaker style, I'd still do it on the table saw, and clean up the cut with a scraper and a shoulder plane.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#7

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Barry Irby

What machine do you want to cut them with? Shaper, table saw, hand held router, router table, or hand plane?

I have a shaper cutter that will do it in the vertical position and you can use as much or as little of the cutter as suits you. I have had it for almost fifty years but have only used it for a few minutes. I have a second set that cuts in the horizontal position but have not used it.

I think similar cutters are available for router tables, but having a shaper I tend to use it for the "big" jobs. I would be leary of trying this with a hand held router on what I presume is a small piece of wood. Shop Whiteside and Amanna.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#8

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Ron Pemberton

Early raised panels in my shop were made on the table saw due to lack of raised panel bits. I like the table saw raised panels so well that is my method of choice. PS not made a lot of raised panels.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#9

Bart Goldberg

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bart Goldberg

Barry - I have a very decent router table with a 3/14 hp router. I tend to like horizontal bits over vertical cause I have better control against the table then the fence.

Bart

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#10

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Barry Irby

Just be careful. Try a reduced speed. Use hold down blocks and another to push it through. I would feed a scrap through behind it for better control and to help prevent tear out at the ends. Experiment. I think it's better to cut the long grain first and then the ends. Sneak up on the cut, taking light passes. Make the final pass very light.

Do be careful. Visualize where your hands will be if the wood disappeared instantly. If you get a kick back it will be so fast it's over before you know it even happened. I have a few battle scars I could show you.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#11

Bart Goldberg

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bart Goldberg

Barry, thanks for the advice - but I have made large raise panels using large bits on my router table before. Interesting advice on doing long grain first. I always assumed to do the end grain first, then the long grain as this helps with blow out. Wonder why you suggest the opposite?

Bart

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#12

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions? *LINK*

John in NM

I've not used their panel bits, but I've used a bunch of others from these guys - the bits are probably made in China, but I've never had a bad one out of a dozen or so I've bought - so the company seems to have good QA. I found these guys while looking for some oddball bits, and they had them.

This panel bit is 1" diameter so would cut a 1/2" total profile, seems about right for what you're doing - maybe 3/8" visible profile. They seem to have a lot of others to choose from if this doesn't suit your needs.


Magnate Carbide

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#13

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

same here but he didn' t like that suggestion

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#14

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I've not purchased these but seen them advertised by Eagle America and MLCS. I get their catalogs in the mail a couple of times a year and have considered trying it out. I think I'd use the upright version, since the radius of the cutter is shorter, but that's your choice, if course.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#15

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

AZ in Colorado Springs

Since you're looking for a bevel instead of a curve, a 10 or 15° bit might work with the panel held vertically. You'd have to cut the tongue as well, using a separate set up.

(I realize this is similar to what others suggested with the TS, but it's a router table alternative.)

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#16

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions? *LINK*

Jim Dillon

Hi Bart, here is a link to a simple Shaker-style (i.e. "flat-style") router bit that, IMHO, would make very elegant tops for small gift boxes. You could then, if desired, round over the edge a bit with some sandpaper. I might vary the size of the bearing to get closer to your final size requirement, but you could use as-is and trim to final size. I have this bit and it is quite nice. Jim

Edit: Regarding end grain vs long grain routing, I've always (when I can remember) to rout end grain first, then long grain. Seems to work for me.


Shaker-style Router Bit

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#17

how small is small?

Ian from Sydney

Hi Bart

I get that you know what you are doing. But how small is small?

I know of no reason that a 3-1/2" raised panel bit couldn't be buried in the fence so that it's only cutting a 1" wide bevel.

Of course, depending on your design, you might have to make a second run with a rebating bit to cut a tongue.

Lee Valley does a 1-1/2" diameter 15 degree bevel bit (1/2" shank) -- Stock number 16J66.61

and some of the reversible panel frame bits can be used to raise small panels. Just remove the bottom [slot] cutter.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#18

is 5/8" including a tongue about the right size?

Ian from Sydney

CMT do a panel raising bit that is 47.6 mm in diameter (about 1-7/8")

cutting depth is 9.5 mm (this is about 3/8", so should work with a 1/2" thick panel)

the tongue is 3.2 mm (near enough to 1/8")

1/2" shank

the whole "raise" including the tongue is 5/8" wide

CMT part No. 890.512.11

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#19

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Barry Irby

Bart, I may be wrong. I think you are right. But, It may depend on the wood and technique. It sticks in my mind that on some really straight grained quarter sawn wood the cutter will blow a big chunk off the corner and side unless you really back it up well, maybe even clamping the backer piece to the panel. By cutting the long grain first you cut away the part the cutter would get a hold of at the last second and blow off.

Fragile wood is very difficult. Tough interlocking grain works better for once.

Experiment and maybe have a spare or two if you have the wood.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#20

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Jim Dillon

Good morning Barry. I forgot to mention that I do indeed use a backer board when routing the end first. I suppose, in theory, routing the long grain last would remove any minor tearout on the end even if a backer board was not used. But, just in case, using the backer board should minimize any tearout. Jim

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#21

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

Barry Irby

You are correct. At least in theory. If the backer is not firmly held against the workpiece it doesn't help much. I find this process to be a little frightening and requiring a lot of concentration and good dexterity. I find a wide scrap that helps hold the piece square to the fence and is big enough for a secure grip to be the best.

Re: Small raised panel bit Suggestions?

#23

Bart Goldberg

Re: Late to the game

Bart Goldberg

Thanks you all for your replies! In think your've all given me enough to review to find just what I need.

And Happy Easter to all you Christian Members

Bart