Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

How much to take off?

Posts

How much to take off?

#1

How much to take off?

Doug Reynolds

After jointing one face I am dimensioning some 4/4 and 8/4 rough sepelle lumber on the thickness planner. How much can safely be taken off at one time, and how long should the piece "rest" before taking more off in thickness? I am doing the usual stacking between cauls and such and would like to keep the stock as flat as possible before I start gluing.

I'm in no hurry so I was thinking 1/8" max per session, and two or so days between trips to the planner.

Thanks for your assistance. I'm making a pair of nightstands for each of my children and hope they get passed down to the next generation, etc.

Doug Reynolds in rainy Seattle

Re: How much to take off?

#2

Re: How much to take off?

Dick Coers

If the wood has been sitting in the shop for a while, I attempt to take the same amount on each side and use it right away. Never have let anything acclimate a second or third time. I am talking about kiln dried stock.

Re: How much to take off?

#3

Ellis Walentine

I wouldn't worry

Ellis Walentine

First, sapele is a stable wood and if you bought it kiln dried, or it has been acclimating in your shop for a while, it probably won't be doing any great amount of twisting, cupping or bowing after planing. That said, a good practice is to remove equal amounts of wood from both faces. So, after jointing one face, plane the other and then alternate planing faces until you're down to whatever thickness you want. You don't need to pause planing.

If you have the time and are the least bit concerned about the wood reacting badly after planing, the solution is to make a couple extra pieces and sticker everything under weight until you're ready to use it -- a couple days is usually enough. If any of your pieces have moved unacceptably, replace them with one of your extras. Slight amounts of reaction can usually be pulled flat and/or straight during glue-up.

Good luck with the project. It's very rewarding to think of your furniture being passed down in your family.

Ellis

Re: How much to take off?

#4

Things to not worry about

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I'm in no hurry so I was thinking 1/8" max per session"

What is the final thickness you are wanting to achieve? In most cases I plane to preserve as much thickness as the board allows. It would be rare that I would be taking off as much as 1/8" per side.

I almost never plane over more than one session to reach whatever final thickness I need. An exception would be when I skip plane, glue up a panel and then plane the panel to final thickness. Also, sometimes I skip plane a load of lumber to 15/16" for easier storage.

The only thing I worry about during and after planing is to ensure equal access for air on each side of the planed lumber. If there is any moisture gain or loss I want it to be equal on each side. All the other "rules" you have read about can be broken. For example, suppose the best side of a board cleans up after 1/16" of planing. The reverse side has a knot or other defect exposed. I have no reluctance to take as much off the "bad" side as I need to to get to the final thickness. If lumber misbehaves during or after planing it means it has stress in it and this stress can show up in finished work. Best to use stressed lumber in smaller pieces in noncritical areas.

Re: How much to take off?

#5

Re: Things to not worry about

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I agree with Bill. However you did not state where your lumber has been stored or how it was dried. As almost all of my projects are built from rough lumber that has been in storage in my shop for at least 3 ~ 4 years and has reached around or under 7% moisture content (shop is heated and Air conditioned 24/7), I do not worry about equal material removal from each side.

I normally remove 1/8" or less per pass, and do start by removing from each side, but when I see a grain pattern I really like or a defect I would like to remove, I plane the side needed to achieve that result. I always plane a few extra boards but can't remember when any would have not been usable due to warp. I use the extra to select the "best match or prettiest grain pattern" prior to using the material.

YMMV dependent on the dryness and acclimation time in your shop.

Re: How much to take off?

#6

Re: I wouldn't worry

Yonak

"...sticker everything under weight until you're ready to use it...."

Ellis, would you sticker kiln dried wood ? If it were dead stacked it would mitigate waviness (which, after the final planing, would be more noticeable) while storing it.

Also, how would Doug know to be concerned about the wood acting badly after planing ? Would the humid Seattle conditions be an indication ? If so, why wait before working it ? It seems to me, the sooner it is worked the less the likelihood of wood movement before locking it in place.

Re: How much to take off?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: I wouldn't worry

Ellis Walentine

There are reasons to be concerned about reaction, regardless of where you are. Specifically, I would be concerned if I did not know the storage conditions that the wood had lived in since it was kiln-dried, since that could cause a moisture gradient across the thickness which could influence a tendency to move after initial Machining. The point of stickering instead of dead stacking is to allow the surface fibers of the newly machined wood to come into equilibrium. If, for example, you were making cabinet doors you would want any twist to equalize prior to further Machining & joinery.

Ellis

Re: How much to take off?

#8

Depends on use

Dick Coers

There is no "locking into place" on a glass door frame as an example. But I agree on a table top or flat panels.

Re: How much to take off?

#9

Re: How much to take off?

Don Stephan

When I get a delivery of wood for a project, it has been on the road for 1.5 or more hours, sometimes in a box and sometimes on an open bed. So I always stack with stickers for at least a week to acclimatize to my workshop before touching it.

Almost every board has some amount of warp, so initial flattening and straightening will take more wood off some areas of the board than others. I expect the moisture content is not uniform throughout the board, so I expect the moisture content of the newly exposed surfaces is not uniform. So I will stack with stickers for another week to adjust. If more than two light passes on the jointer are needed to flatten one face after that week of "adjusting" I'll stack with stickers for another week for good measure.

It's a time consuming process, and I know at least one participant thinks I'm crazy, and I don't argue that anyone else has to do this, but I have not had any post-construction warping or other problems, and extra boards from a project have stayed flat and straight for years.