Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

Posts

Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#1

Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

David G

I started out with a quick little project, a dovetailed box for my small collection of pocket knives. As most woodworking things I do, it turned into a learning experience. The design is lightly modified from Derek Cohen's box for his Veritas chisels.

Anyway, the lid of the box has a bit of sapwood in it and it looked OK, until I fumed it( 10% "Janitorial Ammonia" , 24 hours). Then the sapwood really stood out, as it seemed to be almost unaffected by the ammonia. I tried staining just the sapwood with some alcohol based dye stain, but it was taken up unevenly by the different densities of wood within the sapwood. Either the darker sapwood was too dark compared to the heartwood or the lighter sapwood was too light. I hoped that my next treatment with boiled linseed oil sould even things out. Not so much.

Any suggestions? It's not terrible right now, but far from ideal. I am not planning on using any kind of pore filler and my next planned treatment if a few coats of blond shellac to keep the current color, that I like.

Thanks!

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#2

Air brush on the dye *LINK*

Dick Coers

An air brush and dye would be my idea of how to tint the sapwood. I've read that Stickley did a lot of dye and glaze work to provide the uniform color on production furniture. I hope you aren't experimenting on the finished box! Here's a good reference on color.


http://homesteadfinishingproducts.com/stickley.pdf

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#3

Re: Air brush on the dye

David G

Thanks for that link! Yes, I am experimenting with the finish directly on my box. Since I didn't plan on having to address the sapwood, I don't have a fumed piece of scrap with sapwood in it.

I don't have an airbrush to apply the dye with, so am just using an acid brush. From your link , I learned that a double concentration of dye stain yields a deeper color than two coats of single concentration stain. I think if I add a bit of green dye I will be at least closer in color , if not quite the same relative staining of the rays and "regular" wood.

My big finishing lesson from this project( so far) is don't include any sapwood when fuming . I purposely included the sapwood because that allowed me to select the piece of wood with the best ray pattern.

Can anyone tell me if dye stains ( instead of fuming) also accentuate the difference between heart and sap wood?

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#4

Dyes or dye stains?

Dick Coers

Two different animals, stain implies pigments that lodge in the pores of the wood. DIY stain like Minwax has dye and stain. It's likely that you would see the difference between the sapwood and heartwood with dyes since the base color is lighter. But if you use a highly concentrated color, it will be minimal.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#5

Yes, don't mess with it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are already victim of one chemistry experiment done on a finished project instead of a test piece. Do you really want to risk another?

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#6

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak *LINK*

Bob Lang

I use aniline dye (either trans tint or lockwood) in alcohol and clear shellac. The idea is to get close to the color tones and layer on a thin colored glaze until the sapwood matches the fumed wood. You don't need an airbrush, but I wouldn't use an acid brush. The color can be layered on with a rag or an artist's brush then use a skotch brite or fine sandpaper to get a smooth surface. If you top coat with shellac it should blend well.

This is one of the reasons that fuming isn't such a good idea. There is good evidence that Gus Stickley switched to aniline dyes around 1906-1907. Dyes are much more consistent and predictable. There is a link to an article by Gus Stickley at the link below about his process, which includes "what to do to touch up the sap wood".

Bob Lang


Stickley's Finishing Process

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#7

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

Don Stephan

On the one hand, tinting a bit of shellac and applying can be reversed with a rag and alcohol if it turns out bad; on the other hand, if the finish will be padded shellac you might lift and move the tinted shellac after getting the color you want.

As Bill suggested, you can still experiment with tinted shellac on a scrap piece to see if it holds promise.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#8

Dye stains and pigment stains

David G

My understanding is that there are two main types of stain, dye stains and pigment stains (and also a combination of the two). My small bottle of Transtint , an aniline dye, states "reduce to make a dye stain."

My understanding, which is not experience based ,is that in general dye stains produce a more even coloration than pigment stains as relatively more pigment is taken up in the pores.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#9

Re: Yes, don't mess with it

David G

I am not sure if I am the victim of this crime or more likely the perpetrator. On second thought, this is probably a victimless crime, unless you choose to anthropomorphize the wood. It hates when you do that.

Upon buying a new car, some people sit home and read the owners manual and others just take it out and see "what it can do." I suspect you can predict which camp I'm in. I know which group has nicer finished projects. I did manage to find the offcut from the top to play with a bit before I wreak more havoc. :-)

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#10

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

David G

Your recommendation to make a glaze sounds great to me. I have black, green and medium brown alcohol based dyes and blond and garnet shellac flakes. The sapwood right now looks to me like a medium dark brown with a bit of gray and green. I will experiment to get things close, but can you give me a rough starting point for mixing this? Do you get close by looking at the liquid or just keep adding dye until it tests out right?

I read your link, but though interesting doesn't sound practical. The article states the to adjust the sapwood one should" mix... Vandyke brown,ground in japan with German lacquer, commonly known as 'banana liquid,' and adding a very little lampblack also ground in japan. " I noticed that "japan" is not capitalized and thus does not refer to the country itself. A little bit of discussion with Mr. Google leads me to believe that it may refer to particle size.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#11

Re: Correcting sapwood color of fumed white oak

David G

I think I will try the glaze technique using shellac and dye and then brush on two or three more coats of shellac. I presume the first post glaze coat will blend things a bit and subsequent coats won't change things much. I was planning on a 2# cut of shellac for finishing. Is this appropriate for the glaze too? Blond for the glaze and either garnet or blonde for the final coats depending on my test piece. I have a guest visiting and probably won't have time to try this and report back until Monday or so.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#12

How to match color

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

put a piece of glass over the area to be colored. Mix stuff on the glass until the mixed color matches the surrounding color. Then transfer mix to the place to be colored. People that are experienced get a perfect match in a minute and the colored spot blends perfectly with the surround.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#13

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

Tony-Memphis

I have had pretty good luck using gel stains as glazes and for some color matching. Easy to get at the box stores too. There is also a couple of articles in FWW that describe making a glaze out of finish and oil paints. My wife is an artist, so I tried a little of her paints and that worked pretty well too. Anyway, good luck and let us know how it comes out.

Tony

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#14

Re: How to match color

William Duffield

That's a great tip, Bill. Now I wonder why I never thought of it.

Another way to match sap to heart wood for fuming or ebonizing, if you are starting from bare wood, is to brew a cup of strong black tea (no sugar or cream, of course) and paint it on the sap wood. The ammonia or iron acetate react with the tannin in the wood, and there is much less tannin in the sap wood naturally. The tea adds extra.

As with all finishing processes, try it first with scrap wood, because you can't see what you've done until it is done.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#15

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

Bob Lang

I take a small quantity of thin, clear shellac, add a little dye to it and test on a piece of scrap. I aim for color close to the heartwood color but a shade lighter, figuring that additional layers will let me sneak up on a good match.

My reason for referencing the article wasn't to send you off on a chase for "banana lacquer", it was to point you to this description of technique:

The mixture may be thinned

with wood alcohol to the right consis-

tency for use, and the color of the piece

to be touched up will decide the proportion

of black to be added to the brown. In

touching up the lighter portions of the

wood, the stain may be smoothly blended

with the dark tint of the perfectly fumed

parts by rubbing along the line where they

join with a piece of soft, dry cheesecloth,

closely following the brush. If the stain

should dry too fast and the color is left

uneven, dampen the cloth slightly with

alcohol.

At the time (1905) aniline dyes and early forms of lacquer were being developed. My interpretation of the mixture was Van Dyke Brown pigment (available still as artists oil colors). I'm not sure what "japan" means, but I think the reference is to some mix of oil and dryers to carry the pigment. If you have a modern brown dye you should be in the ballpark. I use Lockwood "Fumed Oak" and haven't had to add any black.

Next time, I'm going to take Bill's suggestion and use a piece of glass to adjust the color.

Bob Lang

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#16

Re: Great Tip Bill!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have never thought of that. However I have discovered (the hard way) many years ago that my method of using scrap is only accurate if the scrap is sanded exactly the same as the project. I do use oil stains and correct to what I want by adding oil based artist paints. Has worked quite well for me, but I may try the glass method next time I need to match.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#17

Evil sapwood is at rest

David G

So, I finally got around to final finishing of my fumed white oak box. I will admit that I spent more time trying to correct the sapwood than I did with the joinery on the box (hand-cut dovetails). The suggestion of a glaze was a good one. I tried a number of versions of glaze on scrap, then tried the "put the glaze on an overlying piece of glass" trick. I found that trick worked better for me in theory, than in practice. Then again, that is the way many things work for me. :-)

I ended up putting on glaze, not liking it, and removing it with alcohol. I did that numerous times. Part of the problem is that I don't have a great eye for color though I am not color blind. I could get the right intensity of color, but not exactly the right color. I ended up going with amber shellac and used medium brown and green Trans Tint. Without enough green in my glaze, the sapwood was redder than the fumed heartwood. Many tries then came out too green. After about ten tries on the piece( and a bazillion on scrap), I settled. It came out good enough that it is not ugly, though certainly not anywhere close to invisible.

Next time I will skip the fuming, though the fuming itself was quite easy. 20 minutes to build a tent that looked like a small table without a top. 10% janitorial ammonia from my local Ace hardware. About 3-4 oz. of ammonia on a dinner plate. The white oak was quite dark in less than 24 hours. No respirator, just did this in my garage( AKA shop) with the door up. Once the tent was sealed, I shut the garage door after 15 minutes. No smell of ammonia in the shop except when I checked on the box. I think the 10% ammonia worked so well because I gave it a big surface area from which to off gas.

Thanks everyone for your suggestions!

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#18

Re: Evil sapwood is at rest

Keith Newton

Glad to hear it's over, and sorry I didn't get around to tossing in my 2 cents. Even though I haven't tried this, I think I read somewhere that you can brush some tannin on the sapwood before the ammonia process, which will cause it to turn.

I don't know where you can get tannin over the counter, but I was boiling some large Swamp Chestnut Oak acorns last year, and kept the liquid from that, which is already pretty dark brown.

When I've done some of my turnings, I put the ammonia in a tuna can, over a little candle, then put the turning on a rack above, finally flipped a plastic garbage drum over that. I used the same grade ammonia as you, but only for about one hour before it was darker than I wanted.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#19

Re: Evil sapwood is at rest

Don Stephan

Glad you worked through to something acceptable. Nothing wrong with fuming, if you can identify the sapwood (difficult for me with oak) and simply trim it off early.

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#20

Re: Evil sapwood is at rest

David G

Your technique of putting a candle underneath the ammonia to drive up the concentration of ammonia in the air and thereby speed things up is brilliant.

I have read, after the problem arose, of course, that one can paint some black tea on the sapwood to provide tannin. I suspect that one would have to get the tannin concentration in the sapwood close to the naturally occurring tannin in the heartwood if one were planning to stop fuming before maximum darkening has occurred.

Does anyone here have experience with tea?

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#21

Re: Evil sapwood is at rest *LINK*

Larry Barrett

In 2009 Brian Boggs wrote an article for Pop Woodworking about the method he uses for ebonizing wood. Its a different, and better in his opinion, method of increasing the tannic acid for almost any type of wood.

See link below.


http://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/ebonizing_wood

Re: Correctiong sapwood color of fumed white oak

#22

Matched for now...maybe not later

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The colored product of ammonia and tannin will photo bleach more or less over time. I have found through experimentation with accelerated photobleaching that the tannin colored material is far less light stable than the premetallized dyes typically used to formulate TransTint.

Long term matching of two different woods with two or more different colorants is always a long term potential problem. Over time the two woods won't respond to light the same, nor will the coloring materials.

Factory furniture now days is diddled with to make the crappy wood used to make it appear uniform in color. We need to not become accustomed to thinking that this is what wood should look like. Variations in color and color intensity are not defects in the finishing. Rather they are a product of using a natural material and not plastic.

For example, some color variations that I find attractive and interesting, and maybe other's don't. But in any case that's my take on it.