JKJ's post on bees swarming made me think of this. A friend and I stopped for lunch at Kentucky Fried Chicken the other day and he asked for honey. They gave him packets of "Honey Sauce." The label listed High Fructose Corn Syrup as the first ingredient and three other things before it got to honey. Maybe John's bees have one less wholesale customer. It tasted sweet, but had little or ho honey taste.
Look at the labels in the grocery store on products that are sold as honey. Some say "honey blend" in tiny print, a sure bet it contains inexpensive high fructose corn syrup. An independent laboratory claimed tests on MOST of the products in stores like Kroger, Walmart, etc. were not pure honey. Some simply lied with deceptive labels. Some contain preservatives.
What is worse, big-name commercial products that say "pure honey" are often highly filtered by heating and force-filtering. This does two things: first it removes the useful pollens. Second, the honey is usually heated to reduce viscosity and make it easier to pump through the fine filters. This destroys the natural taste and destroys some of the healthy things about honey.
Some critics of the study rightly point out that even filtering the honey to remove the pollen doesn't change the fact that it is still honey. However, pollen is used as a fingerprinting technique to find where the honey originated since honey originating in China has pollen from different plants than honey coming from Tennessee. Two reasons this is important: one, to get the allergy benefits from honey it needs to contain pollen from plants found in your region. Two, the Chinese have been accused of purposely removing pollen to hide where it came from. Chinese honey has often been found with increased levels of pesticides and antibiotics. I read of a shipment of contaminated honey that was rejected at a port on the east coast only to get into the US somehow through New Orleans. Since Chinese honey has gotten such a bad reputation, they have taken to shipping it in bulk to other countries in Europe and South America where it bottled and sold as Turkish honey, etc.
I heard a rumor that some importers were mixing in local pollens to further deceive their customers and increase their profits. If true, shame on them.
To be sure of the honey and get the benefits of local pollens, buy local honey from independent beekeepers (especially those you know and trust). These people often sell at farmer's markets and co-ops, rural markets, etc. It may be more expensive but probably worth it. I don't sell wholesale, but when I let the word out I have fresh honey it is quickly gone. Since it only comes once a year I have people buy it by the gallon so they won't run out. On a good year I sell a few thousand dollars from just a few hives.
Don't pay much attention to labels that say "wildflower", or "basswood", "clover", "blueberry". Bees typically travel up to two miles (sometimes four) in all directions to find nectar and honey is almost always from a mix of flowers. Unless the hives sit smack in the middle of 12-50 sq miles of nothing but blueberry plants the honey that blueberry honey is probably going to contain some dandilion, various trees, clover, buttercup, and many more. Some unscrupulous sellers have been known to add a bit of flavoring. An exception to this can be honey collected when nothing else is blooming - for example, a guy Ii know transports hives to mountain locations where sourwood trees are practically the only thing in bloom.
Look for the words "Pure" and "raw" on the label. And "local" doesn't mean it has to come from within a few miles of your house - they trees and plants common in your area are usually found over a large region, for example here in TN half the eastern US is "local".
Note that all honey is lightly filtered to remove natural things like bits of honeycomb wax, propolis, and an occasional bee's wing.
BTW, one reason the big chains buy force-filtered honey is it is slower to crystallize. This keeps Krogers from having to deal with customers upset their honey has gone "bad". Honey will NEVER go bad unless it has too much moisture, then it will ferment. All honey will crystallize eventually but it doesn't hurt anything. To delay crystallization, don't store honey in the fridge or someplace too cool - it crystallizes most quickly at 54 deg F or lower. If it does crystallize, gently warm the bottle in a pan of water at about 110 deg or less - don't overheat and never boil. What I do is set the bottles out on my covered porch where it might be 95 deg on a hot summer afternoon. It changes back to liquid in a day or so. In the winter I put it in a warm but not hot place like behind my wood-burning stove.
I started buying honey from a local beekeeper last year. I'll never go back to the store-bought stuff. It's more expensive but worth every penny, the taste is phenomenal. Good enough that I eat it by the spoonful as a treat - better than candy!!
Some of what is stated above is more myth than fact.
There is little if any hard actual medical data that shows the small amount of pollen in honey will do anything to reduce allergies. Bees collect pollen, but the pollen they collect is not airborne pollens. They collect sticky pollen (such as dandelion and goldenrod) which they can stick to their hind legs. Hay fever is typically caused by ragweed or tree pollen, both of which are airborne. Bees do not collect those pollens. I make no claims of curative properties for any of the local honey I sell.
Filtering honey does nothing to the taste as long as it is not over heated (140 degrees). Heating above 140 degrees would also melt the wax making it impossible to remove from the honey. The extraction process requires the cappings to be removed from the honey comb. Removing the cappings breaks the cell walls and leaves bits of wax behind mixed with the honey. There may also be bits of propolis and possible parts of bee legs or wings. Filtering removes these bits and pieces and may also remove pollen if present and if the filter is fine enough.
Honey is a supersaturated liquid and any bit of solid can be a nucleation site for crystals to form. Once crystals start to form, it creates more surfaces for crystals to form and the entire container can quickly turn solid. This process can be reversed by heating.
Honey can and does spoil. While it is true they found honey in Egyptian tombs, it was not edible. Honey will darken with age and exposure to the air. When honey crystalizes, there is a surface layer than contains more water than sugar which can develop mold from airborne spores. Harvesting uncured honey (honey that is not properly capped) can also result in spoilage.
Commercial producers want their product to be consistant, so they often blend honey from several sources to make and maintain a uniform color and taste hence the name blended honey. Honey from black locust is very light colored. Honey from the buck wheat flower is very dark and the color of molasses. Clover honey and wild flower honey are somewhere in between. Honey from lima bean flowers has a green tint. Honey from tulip poplar is reddish in color.
I don't want anything done to the honey to keep it from crystallizing. I like it crystallized, to the point where I can barely get it to spread on fresh bread without tearing the bread. Yummy!!!!!
There is in fact a lot of controversy concerning honey, some from people who have read an article, found something on a web site, or listened to someone at a beekeepers meeting. I've heard all kinds of contradictory things over the years.
For example, I've had beekeepers and read things by "experts" who said bees do not collect wax. Then I watched a bunch of bees collecting wax after cleaning all traces of honey from from extracted frames. (It's kind of fun standing on the deck with maybe 10000 bees frantically cleaning up frames!)
Much is controversial and some is lore and nonsense, some anecdotal "evidence." Some of is fact based on observation and research and experience from long-time beekeepers.
My doctor is one who believes honey containing local pollen helps with allergies. This is based on his education and from reports over the years from some of his patients. My neighbor gets in to a panic when she gets low on honey after finding over the years that it really helps her allergies - when she run out she gets miserable after a month or so. Allergies to something other than pollen, such as cats and dust mites, will not be helped of course.
The bees here certainly do gather pollen from trees as well as ragweed - I've watched them in yellow poplar, golden rain tree, redbud, and maple trees, about the first available around here. I suspect even some of the non-tree/ragweed "sticky" pollen you mention gets into the air. Watch the bees gathering pollen from corn tassels. I imagine there are people allergic to many types of pollen.
As I stated, honey with too much moisture can ferment, or mold, as you mentioned. The bees are very good at sealing the combs with wax when the moisture is perfect. Where beekeepers get into trouble is extracting honey from frames with partially capped honey which can add excess water to the entire batch. It is best to extract those frames separately then dry the honey them in a closed room with warmth and a dehumidifier. I use a calibrated refractometer to test all honey before bottling.
Note that some varieties of honey can "stand" higher moisture than others. I shoot for 17-18%. It is easy to dry a 5-gal bucket of honey from 20% to 17%.
Since honey is hydroscopic another way to accidentally add water is to process and let it settle in a room with high humidity, common in the summer in areas without air conditioning.
Note that when honey in a bottle crystalizes it usually starts at the bottom and there is no surface exposed to air to be affected by mold.
Honey does indeed darken with age and the taste changes for the worse. I keep a small bottle from each year to compare the color. One quart jar from 10 years ago with mostly some chucks of comb is now mostly air as much of the honey ran out. It was water white at the time and now is thick, crystallized, and darker than blackstrap molasses. Another quart from the same year is full, also crystallized and just as black. No mold or fermentation is evident in either when I've opened to check. I would not eat it though.
This girl is collecting from a tree by my deck. I didn't catch it in this picture but I did see some with pollen "in" there baskets. I watched these bees for many hours (and took over 400 macro photos to get a few that were useful.)
Honey bees do indeed collect pollen from trees, but only the sticky kind that does not become airborne. Tulip Poplar is a a favorite for bees and they readily collect the pollen and nectar. This pollen is sticky and not air borne.
Crystals in honey can start at any nucleation site and larger crystals settle to the bottom.
Golden rod and rag weed bloom at the same time. The Golden Rod is yellow and obvious to anyone walking by a field. Rag weeds don't show up much but they are there and their pollen is airborne. To get an allergic reaction to Golden rod you would need to touch it or ingest it as it stays on the plant unless removed by an insect.
I've had people claim that honey from the spring blossoms help with their fall allergies which would indicate it is not the pollen having any effect at all since fall pollens would not be present. The Mayo clinic disagrees.
>>>John do you process(?) or sell the wax? i read somewhere that the best place to get beeswax was from a local keeper.
John,
How much wax you get depends on the number of frames you process and how you go about it. I used to crush the comb to extract the honey which provided a lot of wax but was wasteful. Now I use a centrifugal extractor after using a hot knife to cut off just the tops of the cells, the "cappings". This provides much less wax but is far more efficient for the next year since the bees can reuse the honeycomb and not have to make new wax from scratch. (It takes a great deal of honey to produce a small amount of beeswax.) The cappings are the best wax too.
I wash and save the cappings and every few years I have enough to make it worth while to process. I melt it in an old crockpot, filter, then pour into molds. I have sold some but since I don't usually have a lot I usually just give it to friends and woodturners for finishes. I passed some around our woodturning club once. I like to use it on eastern red cedar since I like the subtle sheen it gives.
Note that the natural color of beeswax is yellow. If you buy white beeswax it is bleached somehow, either in the sun or chemically.