Hi y'all. Spring in West Texas. 180'acres. Fertilizer, herbicides and pre-emergents.
No woodworking to speak if....but, I am putting a new floor in my 16' trailer. I purchased treated wood in hopes of getting many years out of it. When I was taking off the old boards I couldn't help but notice that many of the self-tapping screws that were put in had snapped off. I "assume" they snapped off during installation. I am going to be putting a LOT of screws in.
Does anyone have a suggestion as to how to make this process go quickly and minimize breaking off some screws. Pre-drill? Lubricate with "something" before driving them in?
Re: OT. Putting new floor in 16' work trailer *LINK*
Jim Dillon
Hi Terry out in West Texas. For years, I've used a tube of Lenox wax to lubricate both my bandsaw blades and any wood screws. Having said that, I almost always pre-drill pilot holes for my woodworking stuff. I have used Spax screws from McFeely's for deck repair that allege no pilot holes are needed. They worked pretty much with no lubricant but camed out a lot - when no pilot holes were used. I would try on some scrap using a lube to see if you really do need pilot holes as that is a lot of extra work. I have had good luck with the quality of screws from McFeeley's and they offer a huge selection. No affiliation, just a happy customer. Good to hear your voice again. Jim
I decked a trailer recently with 2" treated lumber. I used self taping screws from Fastenal (sp?) and an impact driver and I didn't break any. The screws were pricey. Maybe that is why they didn't break
Are the screws through the wood into the steel frame? My trailers are like that. When reflooring one last I used quality flat head self-drilling/self-tapping screws driven, I think, with a large torx bit in an impact driver. These screws were very tough. I bought screws from an local industrial fastener company.
I did see some broken off. I thought it was a combination of rust and flexing and impact forces from the road and load. Rather than trying to remove the broken hardened steel screw I just put the screw a little bit to one side.
Thinking about it just now, I'm not sure it had screws down length of the boards, I might have been just on the ends. I'll have to go look. This was one of my smaller trailers. I haven't had to refloor the bigger trailers yet, but the 18' gooseneck is getting close to needing it.
Re: OT. Putting new floor in 16' work trailer *LINK*
Keith Newton
Terry, Im going to be having to replace the deck on my 16' car / log hauler soon as well, so here is what I'm planning.
Another issue is that of choosing the lumber. I'm sure you'll be using treated SYP, as I will also. Mine was decked with 2x8" which is good from the respect of the bridging between cross frames, but sucks when it comes to the typical quality of that dimension. If you can find it even without knot issues, it usually has too much heartwood which doesn't allow the chemical penetration of the preservatives. While this would outlast the sapwood many times over in untreated wood, that part will decay faster than the treated will. I can usually find 2x6 that will be clear as well as totally treated without any heartwood.
Another consideration when drilling and screwing the new lumber down is the expansion and contraction which is inevitable. Since treated lumber comes totally saturated, it's not likely to ever be any larger than when installed, so shrinkage as it dries should be considered. SYP typically will shrink 1/6" per inch, so if you use 2x8", 7.5" actually, then use 2 screws one inch in from each edge, that is 5.5" apart, or over 5/16" of shrinkage between those two fasteners.
If you use two side by side near the ends, I'll assure you they will split.
My Big Tex trailer has an angle iron welded upside down to capture both ends, so there is no need for fasteners there once they are sprung into place. Then what I plan to do, is use one fastener per frame alternating left to right about 2" in from each side as I go forward in a zigzag pattern. This ought to be enough to keep it flat.
I'm also going to use wafer head screws with an oversize hole through the deck, then drill toward the inside of it through the steel rather than centered in anticipation of the shrinkage.
This is about the same thing as screwing a solid wood top to the apron without any wiggle room in the apron. You can't stop it from moving, so just plan on letting it move while holding it down.
When I was building decks I had problems with screws not going down as far as I wanted. Then I found coated screws. It wasn't a plating but more like a plastic coating. Those screws were much easier to drive and seated properly. Predrilling will make it easier to drive the screws and reduce the bumps created by the screwhead.
Since you haven't bought your lumber yet (too late for Terry ), you might want to consider purpleheart or ipe instead of PTSYP. Yes, those timbers would necessarily be predrilled, but the finished deck would probably outlast everyone reading this forum. They are denser than YP, but also stronger, so thinner boards would decrease the weight and still hold the load.
Keith mentioned how much PTSYP shrinks because its sold soaking wet and completely swollen.
I have done what he suggested, zig zagging the fasteners from side to side, and it worked it well. Clients were skeptical but in the rare occasion it warped, we went back and put the opposite ones in where needed. Another thought might be to put all the left ones in now and wait a month or two for it to dry and then install all the right ones. Also, If you use 2 x 6's or 2 x 8's install them tight edge to edge and they will shrink substantially and leave sufficient cracks. If you space them while installing wet ones, you will have oversized cracks. (may be OK on a trailer).
And, You can buy treated lumber that is Air Dried After Treatment (ADAT) or Kiln Dried After Treatment (KDAT). This will eliminate the initial shrinkage issue. If you find and install dry ones you may want to space them.
Might want to check with local lumber yards for black locust or other decay resistant lumber.
I took all of your advise....a little here....a little there.
I should finish the floor today. I did have to pre-drill and I broke the 2 bits that fit late yesterday afternoon. I am using my clamps to snug each board next to each other. I'll try to post a pic when finished.