Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Posts

Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#1

Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Michael van pelt

My next project is the Arts & Crafts bed on the cover of this months issue. I have both Festool Dominos, the regular and the big one. I was thinking about using dominos instead of the traditional mortise tenon construction. I know after it is all built no one except me will know I used dominos, but I am having trouble not using traditional mortise & tenon construction.

What are your feelings and thoughts?

Thanks

Mike

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#2

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

I know if I had a Domino - I would use it.

Henry

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#3

Alan Young

I keep saving up for a FD

Alan Young

but then end up making my own loose tenons. I know your question is related to authenticity or tradition of M&T vs Loose tenon. If you have the fancy tools I wouldn't hesitate to employ them.

-Alan

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#4

I've used loose tenons for almost 35 years

Dick Coers

I think I started when the first big plunge routers arrived in the USA from Hitachi. Then I bought a Multi Router in the early 90s. For bed construction, I use two floating 1/2" wide tenons, 1 on each vertical side of the bed bolt. You could park a truck on a bed built that way.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#5

go for it!

Joseph Piotrowski

loose tenon are very strong. i recall reading strength test and it up there maybe 2nd strongest joint of what they tested

i'm not historian but i'll bet they used a machine(hollow chisel mortise) . someone probably knows.

i'm betting if they had a a router setup instead, they would all be loose tenons. the speed of making this joint is unbelievable. i once made a baby changing dresser, just loose tenon every joint. it took me a short afternoon to make like 60 joints.

16 years later i stood on it and jumped up and down. i'm, 300 lbs.

look at the Greene and Greene furniture. the exquisite designs details. the one with ebony that cover up screws!

unless you are into some period reproduction cult that mandate you don overall and use period tools, i'd use the best way i can. after all it not some butt joint that will fail. it'll be rock solid to a 100 years.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#6

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Jim Dillon

Michael, I ended up using a combination of both Festool dominoes and 1/2 inch thick loose tenons fashioned with a router template on this recently finished G&G style bed based on Gary Rogowski's article in FWW June 2002 No. 156. I have the smaller Domino and could not justify buying the bigger one. I used the thicker loose tenons on the upper and bottom rails and the Dominos for the smaller stuff. This approach worked for me and the bed seems very sturdy. Good luck. Jim


Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Loose tenons are great

Ellis Walentine

Nice job, Jim! I'll mention it to Gary next time I see him. It's always nice to know that somebody is making your projects. In fact, maybe I'll email him a link to your post.

Regarding loose tenons, I've been using them almost exclusively since the mid 70s. There were always exceptions, of course, but a well designed loose tenon is just as strong as a sawn one, and usually much easier to make. It also saves wood and head-scratching, since you don't have to add the length of the tenons to the shoulder-shoulder dimension. And you can cut your ends nice and square and not have to worry about paring shoulders and such.

As for the knock-down joinery on a bed, I use a simple 1/2" or 3/4" W x 1/2" L stub tenon with a 3/8" cap screw through the middle of it to join the side rails to the legs. The stub tenon bears the weight and the bolt keeps the shoulder tight.

I'm heading out to the shop as we speak to use a little Domino to join up about 14 face frames for a kitchen I'm building--probably 80 loose tenons in all. I've got it down to a very quick and precise method, finally, although I think Festool makes things a bit more complicated than need be, at least for my style of woodworking. One thing I really like about the Domino joints is that if you cut the tight across the width and line them up perfectly when you cut them, there is zero side slop in the joint, something that you can't generally say for routed slots and shop-made tenon stock.

In the early days, I used one of my old Makita 3600 plunge routers with jigs for legs, stiles and rails. Then I had a big old Porter pin router that was perfect for mortising, especially oddball mortises.


By the time the shop burned down we had two horizontal mortisers -- one an Advantage Machinery unit with an XYZ table and a tilting feature, and the other a converted Whitney horizontal mill with a Reeves drive, a custom hold down table and draw collets for every size up-spiral bit from 1/8" to 7/8".


That little beast could put a 7/8" W x 4 1/2" D mortise into the end of a 4x8 x 10' mahogany gate rail. You couldn't make conventional tenons double tenons that size even if you had a big tenoning machine.




So, an investment in loose-tenon joinery, for whatever scale of work you're doing, is a good one in my opinion.

Ellis

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#8

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

William Duffield

Unless you are researching traditional practices and techniques and need to understand how or why the original was built a certain way, I would use the Dominos. They are faster, less tiring, safer, much less prone to making mistakes that would need to be redone, and use a bit less of your expensive primary wood. Properly sized and placed Domino joints are as strong as hand made mortises and tenons, and if you have individual inconsistencies in your traditional M&Ts, then the Dominos can be much stronger. If you use the Dominos, you will get done much quicker, and maybe get closer to the end of your bucket list before you kick it. I have both the DF500 and DF700XL Dominos. I have used hollow chisel mortisers and DP attachments, and have chopped mortises with mortise chisel and mallet, made them with a plunge router, and with a drill bit and paring chisel. I've cut tenons with a table saw, radial arm saw and tenon saw. By far, I prefer using the Dominos.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#9

Re: Loose tenons are great

Jim Dillon

Thanks for the kind words Ellis. Tell Mr. Rogowski that his article was so well written and illustrated that even I could follow it! I gave up on cutting tenons after forgetting way too many times to allow for the tenon length usually at BOTH ends of the board. And this was back when my brain had not turned to mush. So I built the fixture described in Bill Hylton's Router Magic book (see below) for cutting mortises, and started using loose tenons. I use it for cutting stopped grooves in door rails etc as well. It has proven very handy. The Festool Domino has somewhat replaced it, but not entirely. Jim


Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#10

good instincts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The loose tenons often used are shorter than what one would use if making them conventionally. I don't know how to say this, but there can be a lot of stress on a bed. It needs to be robust. I don't know if the large Domino can make a tenon as large as I would use in a bed. My rails are 5/4 and 5" high and the mortise they fit into is 2" deep and 4" tall by 5/8. The head and foot mortise is not quite this large. And do use bed bolts. They make a completely ridged frame. No squeeks or wiggles.

Bottom line- make conventional as big as the material will accommodate.

Post pictures of progress.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#11

Re: good instincts

Jim Dillon

I agree Bill. I seriously considered buying the larger Domino, but wasn't convinced that this was the solution to my problem of needing a nice thick sturdy loose tenon for the major pieces in a bed. IIRC, the large dominoes approach 1/2 inch thickness, but lack the width to make me feel comfortable. Yes, one can double them up etc. and yes, one can make a wider mortise, but I just don't do really large pieces of furniture that often. So I settled on the tried-and-true plunge router with a template for making the mortises in the rails, legs etc. Ellis' approach to using stub tenon also would work well to prevent racking of the side rails. Jim

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#12

Re: good instincts

William Duffield

Festool provides all dimensions in metric, but here is a rough conversion for the largest mortises and tenons that the larger Domino DF700XL will accommodate:

Thickness: 14 mm ~0.55" ~9/16"

Width: 27.5 mm ~1.08" ~1-1/8"

Depth: 70 mm, ~2.756" ~2-3/4"

If you think you need more strength than that, it is simple to lay out and cut multiple mortises.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#13

Re: good instincts

Dick Coers

There can be a lot of stresses on bed joinery, but if we are talking about loads on the bed rail joinery, the bed bolts and rail faces carry the major loads. The need of the tenon is to carry the vertical load. If the bed bolt loosens from crushed wood fiber, then a longer tenon will help. But, those joints have to be loose enough to allow disassembly and will not eliminate racking if the bolt is loose. I haven't done any finite element analysis on it, but I would be satisfied with bigger bed bolts on good mounting faces with stub tenons. I actually prefer large homemade barrel nuts as there is more contact area with wood fiber than the traditional square nut.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#14

A BIG THANK-YOU Everyone

Michael van pelt

I. Love this group! A wealth of very helpful suggestions! Thank-you! A group that is always sharing!!

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#15

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

TomD

I thought a lot of A&C joinery was faked anyway? It's from the machine age.

"My next project is the Arts & Crafts bed on the cover of this months issue. I have both Festool Dominos, the regular and the big one. I was thinking about using dominos instead of the traditional mortise tenon construction. I know after it is all built no one except me will know I used dominos, but I am having trouble not using traditional mortise & tenon construction.

What are your feelings and thoughts?"

There are two reasons for asking this kind of thing. One is you want to be told it will be OK, and it probably will be. Particularly since you own both machines. The other is because you want to know the real answer, and perhaps do something about it.

You want to consider the loads. Is the user single? As far as sizing the joinery is concerned, it seems very unlikely that just because the Domino exists, it is the right size for every job. I feel confident saying that, given that they more or less got it wrong with the sizing of the first one.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#16

Re: Loose tenons are great

TomD

Obviously your work is immaculate and well thought through.

That said, the tooling compromises are interesting. They consist first of dumbing down the tenon so that it is rounded on the ends; then making it so it is discontinuous with the grain aligned piece; then loose so that it has only the glue to rely on. Considering that I did some very heavily stressed Krenov sawhorses with biscuits, and they lasted through one particularly heavy boat project before failing (in a mode a domino probably wouldn't), these joints must be immensely strong, even though it is presumably only a mater of time before the crossgrains glue joints eventually fail. But we probably won't hear about it.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#17

Ellis Walentine

Compromises

Ellis Walentine

Tenpons, regardless of whether they are loose or integral, rely on cross-grain glue joinery to keep them from coming out. As with all glue ups, the strength is a function of how well the surfaces mate and how much tooth the surfaces have for the glue, particularly epoxy. Cross-grain wood movement will always be an issue, as with most types of joinery.

As for the rounded ends, I contend that they are not a material concern, unlike dowels, where all the interfaces are less than ideal. It is the flats of the tenons that contribute the gluing power. The rounded ends have the essential benefit of allowing the mortises to be excavated with highly-controlled, accurate and efficient machines. In the case of the Domino, the tenons are very accurate in width and the mortise can be cut to provide a zero-clearance fit on the edges, where a tiny ridge on the center of the rounded edge compresses just enough with a hammer blow to keep the parts in very accurate longitudinal alignment.

Biscuits are excellent for lots of things, but they only penetrate half an inch, so the glue area is considerably less than on a properly designed tenon.

Ellis

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#18

Re: Compromises

Barry Irby

I did some "testing" of mortise and tenon joints. Not a highly controlled test and not repeated enough to be conclusive, but what I think I discovered was that the shoulders were very important to the strength. If there was enough surface area on the tenons to resist being extracted from the mortise the joint was much stronger than a joint with minimal on no shoulders. I think the same principle would apply to loose tenons.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#19

Re: Loose tenons are great

William Duffield

The round ends of the mortises have a strength advantage, for the same reason fillets are used in cast metal and epoxy construction: They distribute the stresses so they are not concentrated in one line where two inside faces meet.

Loose tenons can be pegged, just like hand sawn tenons and chopped mortises have been done in most surviving joined furniture since at least the Middle Ages.

Loose tenons, and in particular Festool Dominos, have significant advantages over biscuits. First, they penetrate more deeply in into both members to be joined, they are not compressed wood so they fit more precisely, and the wood fibers are aligned with the fibers in one of the members, so they do not fail in that member with seasonal wood movement. From a convenience perspective: you can buy precisely machined tenons from Festool that fit their mortises exactly, in sipo, a rot resistant African mahogany, as well as in beech.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#20

Some disclaimers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Those suggesting should reveal if they ever made a bed and for how long it has lasted. I have made five, ranging from 4 to 40 years old. None have developed any looseness of mortises. In two cases the beds were loft beds with legs 5' tall so as to accommodate a desk underneath. My philosophy in making the mortise was to use as big a mortise and the lumber would accommodate. In all cases the resulting mortise was deeper than the typical loose tenon I see employed. In fact that is my objection to loose tenons. Most ways of cutting them don't result in a very deep mortise.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#21

Those suggesting what Bill?

Dick Coers

"Those suggesting should reveal if they ever made a bed"

Been making beds for over 40 years as well. Even had one go to Japan. Our son sleeps in one, a cherry and curly maple arts and crafts style. I still owe our daughter one. Made us all water beds in the 70s. Did a very traditional teester bed with faux rope suspension in the early 80s. It had traditional slatting, but he wanted to see the ropes through the rails. So put in the slats to carry the box spring, and the ropes wove under those. 7' 16/4 hard maple posts that tapered into octagons. Full grid on top of the posts, but no fabric hood. Traditional bed bolts with that fancy lug wrench included. That's the one that went to Japan when the executive was transferred. Did a double wide twin bed for an elderly couple. They wanted to sleep together, but didn't want any disturbance from the other person. It was an asian style with cloud lifts and a really nice spalted elm medallion centered in the headboard. Actually did the entire bedroom suite. A large step tansu, 2 night stands, and a wide chest of drawers in walnut and curly cherry. Stopped by Misugi Design in Berkley back in the day for the hand forged hardware from Japan for that job. That sure was back in the day. I had some crappy photos of that Asian style, but haven't seen those in years. Some goes for the teester bed.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#22

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Michael van pelt

Jim DIllion:

Great looking bed! I have decided that I too will use the Festool for the head & foot board construction and do mortise & tenon on the bed rails! Thanks!

Mike

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#23

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

Jim Dillon

Thanks. Just to be clear, I used large loose tenons (non-Domino) for the top and bottom rails of the header and footer (double on the bottom rail), and the Domino for the verticals and center rails. The skinny verticals were fastened with a half-lap joint. Good luck. Jim

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#24

Now that is what is needed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You have made enough beds to be a reliable source of advice on what worked to hold them together for a long time.

If I was engineering something I would want to know I was getting advice from people that had successfully built what I was asking advice on, or something similar. Then I would have some confidence that the advice was relevant.

As an alternative I seek out antiques that have stood the test of time and study to what standards they are put together.

As an example, the door assembly for modern frame and panel kitchen cabinets are not of the robust standards used to assemble a door in an 1850 cabinet. On the other hand, a kitchen cabinet door is not expected to endure what a door in a piece of furniture might endure (no moving for example) nor last more than a few decades, if that. If I knew that someone only built frame and panel doors for kitchens I would not seek their advice on a furniture cabinet, for example.

Re: Arts Crafts Bed Cover Fine WoodWorking ?

#25

Ellis Walentine

Furniture vs cabinetry

Ellis Walentine

I've always made a distinction between furniture and built-ins. Furniture is not connected to its surroundings, whereas cabinets and other architectural woodworking become part of the real estate. This basic distinction makes (or can make) a big difference in how the work is designed and built.

Ellis