Re: Most durable Hardwood Floor finish?
Jim Dillon
Bart, as it happens I am getting ready to install oak hardwood flooring in a bedroom. It has been 17 years since my wife and I installed oak, heartwood pine, and locust flooring and used an oil-based finish (Parks). Over those years we also had 4 70-80 pound dogs. My conclusion is that a lot depends on the hardness of the underlying wood. The pine got beaten up pretty badly, but the finish remained mostly intact; it was the underlying pine that got indented - especially in the sap wood. The oak survived pretty well but in all honesty, there wasn't that much dog traffic in that room. The locust was impervious and it saw a lot of dog traffic.
OK, flash forward. I have been investigating finishes again - this time water-based. Water-based finishes have improved a lot. Bona products (especially Bona Traffic HD Commercial) always seem to get good reviews. Another product I had never heard of is Streetshoe that gets good reviews and was recommended by my flooring supplier. Actually, all the water-based major brands like Varathane, Parks etc. seem to work well. One supposed measure of durability is the solids content (i.e. how much resin percent-wise) if you can locate that information on the can. And as Barry mentioned, the manufacturers are now adding finely divided ceramic particles to their higher end "commercial" finishes.
One downside to water-based finishes is that they leave a very slight blue tinge to the wood. Here is a tip I read about on a number of flooring sites and plan on using. Use a first coat of Zinsser's Seal Coat (dewaxed) shellac. It will warm up the water-based finish.
I haven't yet decided on what finish I will use. We now have only one 80 pound dog. From what I have read, I think you would be happy with the Bona Traffic, but the Varathane is half the price. Hope this helps. Jim