In the Keynote speech at the 2017 Colonial Williamsburg Woodworking in the Eighteenth Century banquet, Don Williams proposed an inspirational "bucket list" of skills for hand tool woodworkers.
I have done all of those, a few to black belt level. Except 7, which doesn't interest me as a woodworking challenge, but I do wish I was an "artist". That is wish in the longing without commitment sense. I do try it on from time to time, but I haven't developed any real skill. Most recently I tried a few things in my leather work.
I wouldn't call that a bucket list as most of those things are tedious (sawing your own veneer by hand (I made the frame saw also)), or begginerish. Other than 7, another toughie, is learning to sharpen everything. That is a life time challenge, and you are kidding yourself if you limit it to hand sharpening methods. For one thing, that isn't how hand tools are made. Sharpening will ease your life passage well beyond woodworking.
I know who Don is and have taken a short course from him. When he was my employee (my taxes were paying his salary) he declined to give me a tour of the furniture conservation lab. Maybe my reluctance to accept his teaching on the matter of how stretch my hand tool skills is colored by this and another unfavorable experience with his willingness to teach. But here goes anyway.
I'll stretch my hand tools skills in a direction that supports my wood working goals. Unless someone is able to judge these goals their advice on stretching is presumptuous. I'm not acquiring hand tool skills for the sake of emulating some 18th Century craftsman. Nor am I going to waste precious woodworking time learning skills I have no foreseeable use for, and that includes most of what is on his list. I'll buy the sharpening exercise.
I don't think much of his minimalist finishing notions either.
II agree with you Bill. My woodworking machines take me pretty close to what i am seeking , but then the hand tools take it further still, then hand finishing.....that gives me complete control and pleasure.
Right on. That assumes, as in your case, that people are working towards some material goal, which a lot of people aren't. But whether they are or aren't, I don't see much thought went into that list. There is no logic too it. It's like a list for improving your driving skills: Learn to change a tire; Go to a country where they drive on the wrong side of the road; Start of a food truck; take up hang gliding;...
I agree that "giving assignments" to his audience may have been a little presumptuous. Also the list was part of a speech to a group interested in 18th century woodworking, perhaps explaining some of the more obscure items.
Nonetheless, I like the idea of a bucket list. I've got maybe 10 years left of the eyesight and physical stamina needed for many types of woodworking. As I don't do woodwork full time, this means I need to
choose new skills to master carefully. Its also fun just fantasizing about what would be most interesting to do.
Maybe this thought project will get me through the tedium of reupholstering our dining room chairs!
I don't understand you labeling of anything either I or Don suggested as being presumptuous: (of a person or their behavior) failing to observe the limits of what is permitted or appropriate.
It might be a useful exercise to calculate about how many pennies of your taxes were used to pay the salary of a Smithsonian scientist. I don't think the job description of "chief furniture conservator" includes the function of "tour guide". The conservation labs are not set up for tours: They are not museums, and thus not in general open to the public. That said, I've not had any problem being granted access to a tour of the Smithsonian labs or others, including Williamsburg, MESDA, Winterthur, etc. You don't explain any details of how you made your request or why it was declined.
emulating some 18th Century craftsman
I don't think the issue is emulating the craftsman as much as it is emulating the finer points of the products of that artisanship. Don's list of skills, at least in my mind, is one effective way to accomplish that.
Don't knock 'em until you've tried 'em. Pre-industrial finishes were used for centuries to adequately protect and pleasingly present wooden furniture, before the invention of plastics like nitrocellulose, and polyurinate by the petrochemical industry.
I have a different take on hand tools. The ONLY time I will attempt to "master" a hand tool technique is when I can't find a modern method that is more accurate or that a task cannot be completed with a power tool. I worked several times with a skilled carpenter in the late 40's / 50's when I was a young lad. Yeah he could cut a board using a hand saw either ripping or crosscutting and the cut edge would show 1/2 the line drawn and the cut would be 90 deg to the surface. but he finally acquired a geared electric hand saw. The only time I ever seen him use a hand saw after that was when electricity was not available.
The "art and or skill" of the hand tool uses and techniques were learned during a long apprenticeship. They were FAR more labor intensive and much slower completing a task. In addition in whole they were far less accurate. Yes they made the furniture parts fit and the furniture was "tweaked" until it functioned properly and was straight and true.
I would pretty much guarantee that if the old masters were shown the options of the electric planer, joiner, sander, table saw, router etc. they would have jumped to use these tools and abandoned many of their hand tools.
Yes I do try to learn the best sharpening methods, however I prepare my blades when possible by grinding the starting bevel on an old Boyer-Shultz 12" grinder. I can guarantee the bevel is at 90 deg. perpendicular to the edge and the proper angle. Then I use stones to finish the sharpening. While I do attempt to cut dovetails with my Lie Nielsen dovetail saw, I use my Leigh jig in most cases, as it is far more accurate than I.
I don't disparage those who attempt to learn and master the old techniques, it is great if they are interested in doing that. However I set out to make furniture, as accurately and as well as I could in a minimum of time.
I know that I did not, nor will have the time or inclination to spend the years necessary to master all the old ways. To me that task is far harder than building all the furniture that I will build in my life, and I see no advantage (other than bragging rights and self satisfaction) in using hand tools to do all the work that my power tools and jigs will do faster and more accurately.