Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Market report from saw mill

Posts

Market report from saw mill

#1

Market report from saw mill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This report is for local mills in E. TN. White oak and walnut are in strong demand. Good white oak logs are bringing 2$/bdft. Log yards have piles of white oak logs and I have not seen a red oak log on a yard.

Walnut is crazy. I saw logs as short as 6' and 6" diameter on the log yard. Logs only 12" diameter are being bought for veneer. Demand must be extreme. I didn't ask what price was being paid for walnut.

Surprisingly there is good demand for ash. I placed an order for some large prime logs to be rift cut.

The mill was not buying red oak. No demand. Ditto cherry, and that is amazing. This would be a good time to lay in a supply of cherry and a bad time to need walnut.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#2

Re: Market report from saw mill

John K Jordan

I have piles of white oak logs if you need some for personal use. What I can't saw will be firewood or rot. I have walnut too and hickory.

JKJ

Re: Market report from saw mill

#3

Re: Market report from saw mill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought 1000bdft of slow growth white oak veneer logs some years back. Still have most of it (4/4), more than I will ever need.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#4

Re: Market report from saw mill

Brian Holcombe

That's not surprising to me, local pricing on walnut and white oak are high, but more important the quality of supply available in dimensional lumber is low to the point that it is quite difficult to find real quality outside of oddly figured boards.

I prefer rift/VG material straight grain the full length of the board. I have one supplier who puts these types of boards aside (in walnut) and that would be an average of 1 board in 4000' in walnut. More common in oak, enough at least that I can reasonably secure stock for parts.

I've found this to be even fairly uncommon in softwoods typically known for it. I recently was party to an order of Alaskan Cedar, of 1000' board feet I was able to find one board that was true VG (rift and straight on all sides), and three others that were close enough to buy and use for less critical work. I've been able to source it in WRC with moderate success and Douglas fir also with moderate success.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#5

That's a tall order

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

White oak trees taper from butt to top, more than most any tree. It would be normal for a 12' white oak log to be several inches less on the small end. The way logs are sawed will result in grain running at an angle to the board edge, 2 or 3" per 12' even on an otherwise perfectly straight log.

Walnut that grows deep in the forest with ample competition tends to have little taper over the length of the first log cut from the tree. However, the veneer mills are taking walnut down to an astonishing 12" diameter (it was once 16' and then 14"). And, they are paying at least $4/bdft for these logs. If the logger and mill are selling into the most profitable market there is little chance of finding a walnut board to meet your desires, as you already know.

Occasionally walnut falls out of favor, as it did a few years ago. I saw packs of walnut with 12" wide boards in them at that time. If it happens again I suggest buying a lifetime supply for otherwise your requirements for walnut are not sustainable.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#6

Re: That's a tall order

John K Jordan

>>>White oak trees taper from butt to top, more than most any tree. It would be normal for a 12' white oak log to be several inches less on the small end. The way logs are sawed will result in grain running at an angle to the board edge, 2 or 3" per 12' even on an otherwise perfectly straight log.

When I get an exceptionally good log I'll use the bandmill technique of blocking up one end of the log to eliminate the slope at the top. This gives a few great boards on each side. Then block to level the pith, waste a taper, and continue to cut. Flip 180 and repeat. It sure takes longer.

You still get rings with different radii on each end especially for long boards and as you get closer to the center, but the crooking, bowing and twisting is minimized.

JKJ

Re: Market report from saw mill

#7

Re: That's a tall order

Brian Holcombe

I tend to agree, and with my requirements when I find such boards I buy them wether I need them or otherwise.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#8

Re: Market report from saw mill

Josko Catipovic

I've been mulling over the phrase "This would be a good time to lay in a supply of cherry..." ever since I read it, and am tempted to take advantage of good pricing to get in maybe 1000-2000 bft of cherry, but, in my area (Eastern MA), I see no signs of a price decrease, and am looking at ~$7-$8 bft, (for 500+ bft) with a bit of a premium for wide or figured stock. Is there any reason to expect that price to decrease over the next few months?

I'm a hobbyist who usually buys a couple planks or a project's worth at a time and no experience in larger orders. I do have a humidity-controlled indoor space to store the lumber and have looked for fresh-sawn stock, but couldn't find any locally. Most of this will sit for a year or more before it's used, and I think I can sticker and monitor it adequately. I'd also be very interested in buying whole logs sawn through but couldn't find any local sellers.

Any advice from more experienced wood buyers would be very welcome, and thanks in advance.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#9

Re: Market report from saw mill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lumber is marketed in various stages. Briefly summarized- logger to saw mill, mill to wholesaler (truck loads), wholesaler to wholesaler of smaller volume (packs), retail of various sizes (tens of bdft to single boards). At the prices you quoted you are at the top of this food chain buying at single board prices. Packs of lumber are about 1000bdft depending on length. You should be able to buy a pack of FAS 1F&Btr cherry for half what you were quoted and a prime log for half again less than that.

That said , I don't know anything about the lumber market in eastern MA. There probably aren't any forests there and hence no mills other than tiny custom ones, if that.

How to find saw mills and loggers if you are starting at zero- contact your state forester and ask. They know them all.

How to find a wholesaler- visit any place that works a lot of lumber and ask there. You might even get them to drop ship a pack there from their supplier if it doesn't cause them much aggravation.

The closest mill I know of is near Utica, NY. It saws cherry and maple exclusively. Another is in Booneville. There will be plenty others in western MA and eastern NY.

If you contemplate buying logs contact me for some advice... too much to type.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#10

Re: Market report from saw mill

Josko Catipovic

Bill, I would be delighted to buy, say, $4k worth of prime cherry logs, sawn straight across to 8/4, but have absolutely no idea how to go about doing that, or into what sorts of risks I'd be getting myself into.

FWIW, I have a standing offer to buy a white oak log from a local sawmill at whatever price he thinks fair. I placed it in October, and still no joy. It seems the local boatbuilders have a longer term relationship and an insatiable interest in green white oak. Oh, well.

Feel free to reply to my email addrress, but I get a feeling this topic is of much interest to hobbyists like myself, and a knowlegable reply would be widely appreciated.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#11

Re: Market report from saw mill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bring your truck to TN and I can load it with how ever much white oak logs you can haul. $4K would buy you a log truck full. It would be nothing to find thousands of bdft of white oak logs on a yard here. Or I'll sell you some of the lumber I had sawed from veneer logs a few years back. We have white oak in our woodlands that scale over 1000 bdft per tree. It is not a rare tree where it prefers to grow.

Ditto for cherry. We are on the southern edge here and central NYS is on the northern edge of good timber. But there are millions of bdft in between.

If you want to find logs, find a logger. To find a logger go to your state forester. If you don't live where there are forests you will have to rely on urban trees. I suppose tree service people might be helpful here, but no personal experience.

Sorry I can't be of much help 800 miles away.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#12

Urban wood source

Tom dunlap

Here in Minnesota the DNR has an urban tree use specialist. Their job is to find better uses for city trees than chips or firewood

A connection to their equal in your state would put you in touch with arborists and

Companies that do lot clearing.

When I ran my treecare company I cut down some trees that became fine lumber. Some came out of yards in Minneapolis and others from doing lot clearing in the old savanna and Big Woods areas in the western suburbs

Re: Market report from saw mill

#13

You need a specialist to figure out what to do?

Dick Coers

Sounds like a classic government job. Did they pay a consulting firm to study if they needed a position like that?

I harvested urban trees for quite a while. I had a little trouble figuring out what to do with that ash tree crotch that had been filled with concrete to stop the rot. Unfortunately, I found the concrete with my big Husky with the 3' bar. Darned thing came out with less teeth after that encounter!

Re: Market report from saw mill

#14

Re: You need a specialist to figure out what to do

Josko Catipovic

Actually, I have two prime white oaks on my property, but the sawyers I tyalked to won't touch them because of a danger of metal in the trunks. Some years ago, I had a cherry trunk sawed up, and sure 'nough, we hit a big carriage bolt. The (portable bandsaw mill) sawyer was thoroughly unhappy with me.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#15

more angst than justified

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A blade for a Woodmiser is less than a blade for my 20" band saw (less then $20) at Misenheimer. It' s not like hitting metal on a circle saw mill. Bring your own blades and saw away.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#16

Re: Market report from saw mill

Josko Catipovic

I'm about to start calling around for a 'pack' of cherry, but before I do, could use a bit of help with the exact definition. For instance, can I order a pack of 9" and wider or figured stock? Are 'they' willing to split a pack, i.e. half 4/4 and half 8/4? Exactly how big is a pack? I see it's ~1000 bft, but how close is it in practice? Can I order green as well as kiln-dried? If someone delivers a pack to my driveway, will they be OK with 2-3 guys manually offloading it, or do they expect me to have a forklift? Any other details wrt word 'pack' and what it implies in the lumber trade would be welcome. Once again, thanks in advance.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#17

Re: You need a specialist to figure out what to do

Barry Irby

A few years ago my son told me a big cherry tree down as a wind fall in a local park. We went and looked at it and sure enough it was about thirty inches in diameter and ten or twelve feet to the first limb. Tried every way I could think of to get permission to get it out of there. Nope. "If we let you do it we would have to let everyone." No we can't sell it to you. No you can't buy a permit. I laid there until it rotted.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#18

Re: Market report from saw mill

John M in Mid Mich

Josko:

Just one thought: be very careful with cherry, especially if green - it seems to be a favorite of powder post beetle in my stacks. Prepare to treat with one of the borate products. Buying kiln dried might save you money in the long run if it never gets infested.

Re: Market report from saw mill

#19

On powder post beetles

Grant Smith

Hi John,

It is true there are some woods that PPB's like a lot. Cherry, ash, and the sapwood of many other trees are among them.

But it takes wood that is above 13% mc for most PPB's to re-infest a wood pile. They simply won't bore in to wood much drier than that. So your dry lumber should not attract them.

Many mistakenly believe they have found an active infestation by discovering the frass piles in their wood collection. What they are likely seeing is the beetles emerging and seeking a mate. These beetles can take up to five years to emerge, so they may have been in the wood since before it was in your pile. Once they mate, they seek new suitable moist wood to infest. So long as your wood is below their 13% thresh hold, you should be fine, and they will either die or go elsewhere.

If you indeed have wood to their liking and they re-infest, one approach is to dehumidify, or better yet install an air conditioner to dehumidify and cool. Then they will not be able to re-infest, and their life cycle will be broken.

There is much written about PPB's on the web, just do a little studying how they "tick" and the path forward is much easier.

Fun fact: a dehumidifier is an air conditioner with both the condenser and the evaporator in the same space. So it dehumidifies, but also has a by product of heat. This is fine when it is cold, but not a smart machine to run in a space you don't want heated like your shop in the summer. Instead, get a small window air conditioner. It will still dehumidify, but you get the added benefit of a cool shop. I run an 8000 btu one in my 1400 square foot shop and it is both dry and cool all summer long. I've done the math, and even if it ran wide open all month (it doesn't), the cost would be under $15. A small price to pay for my shop to be a happy place in the dog days of summer. It also helps keep the lumber at a similar MC as the wood in my home, which is also air conditioned.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Market report from saw mill

#20

Re: You need a specialist to figure out what to do

Ron in Sterling, CT

I had 3 large eastern white pine trees turned into over 2500 board feet of lumber several years ago by a friend with a wood mizer. The trees came out of our front yard. My agreement with the sawyer was that I would replace any blades ruined during the sawing operation. It cost me one blade when we hit a clothes line retaining hook. No damage to the machine.