I bought some butcher block table tops made of walnut at an auction. The company that makes them describes them as being made of quarter sawn walnut. They are made of pieces 1 3/4" square. Looking from the end they appear to have paid no attention to the orientation of the strips. A fairly high percentage have the pith in them and even more have sapwood.
With the exception of the ones with the pith, wouldn't any strip 1 3/4" square have to be either quarter sawn or rift sawn?
And, If you are trying to orient the strips to reduce warping of the top wouldn't you turn the all the same way?
I've read were rift sawn has the annular rings at 30-60 degrees to the face, quarter is 60 to 90 degrees. It would take a really small tree to not have those conditions in a 1 3/4" square board as you said.
Given that somebody made those table tops out of that lumber without cutting out at least the pith, the only conclusion I can think of is that this particular somebody didn't know what he or she was doing, or knew and didn't care, or the wood was chemically stabilized so it didn't matter.
Sounds like marketing hype from someone who doesn't know or doesn't care, or both. Almost as bad as selling quarter sawn spindle turning squares. :-)
I forget the "generally" accepted incident angles for quartersawn lumber but I could look it up if needed.
Some people alternate the curvature to even out the movement and help keep the entire glued-up surface from cupping. Walnut should be pretty stable to start with, though, regardless of how the grain is oriented.
Your table tops might make some nice shop bench tops, if perhaps a little dark. I'll be glad to take one off your hands. I made a workbench from a left-over hard maple counter top about that thick.
OK, I walked down to check on the llamas and peacocks then visited my shop library and pulled some of my favorite authorities off the shelf. One was Sir Google on my iPad.
The consensus is few agree except that "definitions vary" and "terms are confusing".
On one end of the issue Hoadley and others agree that quartersawn has been defined as with rings "more or less" at 90-deg to the surface but goes with 45-90 degrees for those who want numbers. Except for oak.
The National Hardwood Lumber Association defines quartersawn oak and locust as where at least 90 percent of one face has ray figure where the rays "must show well", whatever that means. They must have a calibrated ray fleck gauge.
The Hardwood Distributors Association defines quartersawn as 60-90 degrees but further reports accepted definitions include 45-90, 60-90, and 75-90, depending on who is doing the defining.
The US Forest Products Laboratory defines it as 45-90 degrees.
Well-respected Gene Wengert relates the "common industry definition" splits that into 45-75 as rift sawn and 75-90 deg as quartersawn.
My copy of the Encyclopedia of Wood (USDA) specifies 45-90 degrees.
The UT Extension document on quarter-sawing goes with the 75-90 deg as "fully" quartersawn since boards with 45-75 deg have less prominent rays, whatever that means, but admits that the terms are indeed confusing. I actually sketched out a quartersawn authority chart but it got confusing too.
So the exact numbers evidently depend on the specific authority. Who's your daddy?
Since it looks like anyone can make a definition, the very newly published JKJ definition for quartersawn walnut is where the rings are from 77.5 degrees to 102.5 degrees to the face of the board - see, I'm the first one to avoid confusion when the board is turned around. And let's define quartersawn burl and MDF at 0-360 degrees. I think I'll apply for a research grant to study whether very light or dark woods should be defined differently, specifically for woods where the rings are almost impossible to see, let alone measure.
somebody who was selling dowels that were quartersawn.
These tops are interesting. They are 3' by 4' and have pieces in them I wouldn't have used. Terrible grain, the pith, knots, voids that have been filled, sap wood and some that are just plain ugly. I called the company that made them and asked what one would sell for. $600 I was so flummoxed I just said thank you and hung up. Thinking about it I have no idea what I expected. Looked them up on Amazon and similar tops were $400. (You do buy EVERYTHING on Amazon, right?) I am seriously out of touch.
Incidentally, There was no evidence they made any effort to orient the strips.
These types of tops are typically made in a factory setting, about as far removed as you can get from the obsessive way most of us would make one. Things move so fast that there isn't time to think about matching or orienting the grain.
I think that's a little harsh John. They are certainly told to use every single board because it will be filled and sanded at a latter stage. In a factory, a good employee is an obedient one. A lot of factory furniture is done the same way. The most skilled worker is in the finishing room. They know how to use filler and toner to produce a uniform looking piece.
The description is only pejorative if you want it to be. Some of the shops I worked in it would be simply accurate. Come to think of it, some of the drill rigs I worked at it was more than accurate. And a few of those guys were good workers in spite of their lack of education or restraint. Most were not however.
>>>The description is only pejorative if you want it to be. Some of the shops I worked in it would be simply accurate. Come to think of it, some of the drill rigs I worked at it was more than accurate. And a few of those guys were good workers in spite of their lack of education or restraint. Most were not however.
Unfortunately, I've seen too many like that in places I've worked and people I know have told their stories.
Due to the bottom line companies skimp on training, have low quality standards, low pay, and push the employees until the better ones leave. Some of those are overworked due to the huge problem of some others just not showing up that day.
With low wages, high pressure, substandard materials (as Barry described), and overpriced produce (as Barry described) someone in the company is probably having a good life - just not the worker!
I've also worked in a wood shop where everyone was respected, even the new person with zero experience. What a difference.
That all inferior work is the result of hungover high school dropouts. I consider it a form of discrimination, a method of degrading a group of people when the whole group is put into a category of inferiority. "Unless you have walked in their shoes" story to me. All too real currently, just like those folks that toil in our fields to pick our lettuce and strawberries. They are really taking it on the chin right now!