Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

To make or mend?

Posts

To make or mend?

#1

To make or mend?

CJ in MPLS

Coming home from work last night I stepped past a shop cabinet I'm building to help clear up the mess in the garage and noticed that two of the drawer boxes I've made are a bit large. These are large 21" deep x 30" wide drawers and are made with 1/2" plywood (the Ecuadorian stuff) from the Home Depot. What I did is to make the boxes 1/2" narrower than the opening into which they will fit. As 1/2" inch is needed at both sides of the drawer box, I cannot use the slides I had planned to use.

I don't think that I can cut an end off of the box and reattach it. I could route a 1/4" dado in the cabinet sides on each side to gain my 1/2" clearance. Alternatively, I could simply remake the two drawer boxes. The latter two options are easy enough to do.

So, what say you? New boxes (out some time and $) or the quick fix that I'll be looking at for some decades to come?

CJ

Re: To make or mend?

#2

Re: To make or mend?

jessecloud

That 1/4 dado would bug you to your grave! Don't do it!

A couple of ideas:

Route a 1/4" stopped dado in the drawer sides and screw drawer runners in the carcass.

Buy new slides for this piece, then make a second piece appropriate to the slides you already have.

Re: To make or mend?

#3

What kind of joinery on the drawer?

Dick Coers

I'll vote for cutting a side off the drawer, then rebuilding them.

Re: To make or mend?

#4

Re: What kind of joinery on the drawer?

CJ in MPLS

I cut a 1/4" tongue on the end of the front and back and a matching dado on the sides. I suppose I could cut off the side and route the joinery again.

Re: To make or mend?

#5

Re: To make or mend?

William Duffield

You could make a new larger cabinet to fit the larger drawers. :D Then shim out the two smaller drawers to fit the cabinet.

Or, how about building one new larger cabinet, two large drawers and two smaller drawers? That would allow you to clean up an even larger mess. That still wouldn't be enough to make a dent in the disorganization of my overstuffed shop.

Re: To make or mend?

#6

Re: To make or mend?

CJ in MPLS

I can call it a design element but not explain it. It will be art. ;)

Re: To make or mend?

#7

Re: To make or mend?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I did something similar when I built an entertainment center for a friend. I made a new drawer, and original is now a tote for materials for the woodworking classes I teach. Fortunately it fits nicely on the back seat of my pickup truck.

Re: To make or mend?

#8

Re: To make or mend?

John McGaw

I'd think that reducing the sides of the drawers to 1/4" thick (1/2" stock - 1/4") would be a non-starter for a shop cabinet which will invariably see some heavy loads and rough treatment. and you would not have much material to screw the slides into. You don't say what sort of drawers these are. Are they inset and flush or do they have overlay fronts? If the latter you could simply take the 1/4" from the carcass on the assumption that the notches wouldn't be seen if the overlay covered them. On the other hand every time I've tried to cover my tracks on a project I always felt that something wasn't right even though nobody else would ever notice. If you get that sort of feeling you probably won't be happy until you do the right thing (whatever that means to you).

Re: To make or mend?

#9

fine furniture or utility?

Joseph Piotrowski

although i'm still a beginner in my book, i always have a slight disdain for any errors in the final product.

however, i'm learning to temper my expectations to match the goal. i set a goals new for garage/shop cabinets for the upcoming year. mostly created towards speed and cost.

1. they are not a showcase project. no fine joinery unless i want to learn/practice something. screw/glue/ nails if i need to get it done

2. they must be cheap. no exotic woods

3. no over designing. i suffer from the paralysis by analysis syndrome.

so think about what you wanted to achieve?

create something that showcases fine craftsmanship to your highest level of construction and artistic ability or just something to not trip over your tools?

fine construction would mean doing it over to me(depending). utility is whatever it took to get it done. replace them later if they need it.

just my 2. with me setting clear goals, i'm forever lost.

Re: To make or mend?

#10

Re: To make or mend?

Joe Mohnike

Could change from side guides to bottom guides?

Re: To make or mend?

#11

Re: To make or mend?

Mark Hennebury

The most important thing to do is learn from this; analyze why and how you made this mistake and how you can avoid it in the future.

As mistakes go this is insignificant; it's a toolbox don't sweat it.

As an opportunity to learn it's invaluable! don't overlook the significance of this opportunity.

There are several main reasons for mistakes, lack of knowledge, lack of patience/ discipline and bad methodology...

Determine why and how you made this mistake and how you can avoid it next time.

Make this a big deal, because it will be, if you don't change your method of working.

Once you have the knowledge to do good work the main focus becomes avoiding mistakes; For that you need to develop methods of working that remove or minimize the chance of error, then you need to discipline your self to follow those procedures.

Learn to use story sticks and develop error-checking procedures and this type of thing wont happen.

Having said that probably bottom mount runners is probably the easiest fix

Re: To make or mend?

#12

Plus 1 on what Mark said.


Re: To make or mend?

#13

Re: To make or mend?

CJ in MPLS

So the mend is complete. Here is what I did:

- marked the finished width of the drawer;

- marked out the shoulder and the end of the tongue on the front and back of each of the two overlarge drawers;

- cut the shoulder of the tongue to the correct depth;

- cut the drawer end free of the box at the marked end of the tongue (the drawer bottom was cut at this same position as the tongues and the bottom have the same projection); and finally,

- made new drawer sides for the open box ends from some left over 1/2" plywood.

I've mounted the newly finished drawers and they work well. I will note that the inexpensive Ecuadorian plywood that I got from the Home Depot is not all that great. It looks OK, but different from the typical birch plywood that I am used to seeing. It has a fair few voids. The biggest problem is that it is very soft and screws will easily strip out if you aren't careful.

Thanks for the support folks.

CJ