I got a new band saw last year. I'm having a bit of a problem with blade tracking. I'm wanting the blade to ride in the center of the wheel but each time I get the blade just about to the crown it jumps to the other side. I wonder what causes this. Do the tires need dressing ? What is the purpose of dressing the tires, anyway ?
Most likely your upper and lower wheels are not coplanar. Rather than me recite an article simply Google band saw wheel coplanar. A nice little article pops up.
>>>I got a new band saw last year. I'm having a bit of a problem with blade tracking. I'm wanting the blade to ride in the center of the wheel but each time I get the blade just about to the crown it jumps to the other side. I wonder what causes this. Do the tires need dressing ? What is the purpose of dressing the tires, anyway ?
Yonak,
I am definitely not a bandsaw expert. I did read and follow the advice in the bandsaw books by Lonnie Bird and Mark Duginske and in the Iturra Design book/catalog. Some people swear by the Snodgrass videos but I'm personally not impressed.
I've never had to dress any tires. Assuming the tires are in good shape, properly crowned, and not gunked up, I wonder if something else is wrong.
I assume you are adjusting the tilt of the top blade to move the blade while both the upper and lower guides are moved completely out of the way.
Perhaps you could indicate
- the type and size of bandsaw
- the type and size of blade
- if it did this from the start or if this is something new
- how you are setting the tension
If something new, did it start with a new blade? If so, did you try a different blade? Was this a new saw or could the tires be old and need replacement? I recently had to replace the tires on my larger saw after a decade of use. I installed new urethane tires which are much better than the originals.
Tension too low is a common cause of bandsaw problems. I understand that setting the tension too high for either the blade or the saw can also be a problem. (I had to replace parts in my smaller bandsaw because I was trying to tension blades too wide and thick for that saw.) Guessing at the tension or believing the indicator built into most saws can be unreliable. I use a tension gauge which is a little pricey but there is a cheap/free way to do the same thing.
BTW, much of my bandsaw use is for processing green wood for turning, often 12" thick and sopping wet, some very hard and dry woods. My favorite blade of some years now is a 1/2" 3 TPI made locally from Lennox stock.
The blade on the bandsaw I use the most (an 18" Rikon) has always stayed where I put it on the tires. My other shop bandsaw, a 14" Delta with riser block, needed some tuneup to make the wheels co-planar before it suited me. (This took a bit of effort.)
If not co-planar, the blade may try to ride centered on the crown on one wheel and off-center on the other. Just a guess here, but I'm wondering if in your case the two crowns are working against each other. Both just before and after it "jumps to the other side" is the blade running in the same spot on both the top and bottom tires?
I know many people say it is fine for the blade to run towards the front or the back of the wheels but I prefer it right in the center of both tires for the most even support and what I think gives a better cut.
It sounds like you have your guides completely out of the way. Why not let the guides keep it from going over to the back. I'd take it back to where the blade was just before wanting to run to the back. I think the problem is that the set of the teeth want to be on on the downhill slope of the front of the crown, and once you get right on top, you loose the support of the flat behind it, So I would take it back a little, then bring the guides up and give it a try.
>>>Why not let the guides keep it from going over to the back.
I understood the rear guide should always be a hair's width away from the blade when not cutting - I have always set mine so the rear bearing didn't spin except when there was pressure during a cut. But as mentioned, I'm certainly no expert. Perhaps it's different if the saw is designed so thrust bearing is oriented so the blade bears against the face rather than the circumference?
Thanks for your response, John. In answer to your questions :
- the type and size of bandsaw = Rikon model 10-325 (14")
- the type and size of blade = 3/16" 4s & 1/4" 6h
- if it did this from the start or if this is something new = I think it's been like this ever since I got the saw but it may be getting worse, or maybe not. I can't remember how vexing the problem was when I first installed a blade. It has definitely happened, recently, with different blades and different kinds of blades (even though they are both pretty narrow).
- how you are setting the tension = By the seat of my pants. I'm kind of going by the guide to be sure I'm in the ballpark but I'm tending to fine tune the adjustment from time to time. This could, indeed, be the cause. I'll make it a point to experiment with different tensions to see if I get different tracking results. I just got it in my head that tire dressing was the cause because I don't know what dressing does or how to do it but I've heard that people do it.
This is a new saw as of last year. Are the tires normally dressed at the factory for a new saw or is that something the user must do ?
Keith, yes, the guides are out of the way. Ever since I had a bad spate of blades breaking at the weld (with my previous saw and with this one) I tried all sorts of remedies, one of which was to be sure I was not putting any extra front-back pressure on the blade thinking that that, in addition to the flexing done by the wheels could be doing the blades in.
Incidentally, I repaired all my broken blades by soldering and I haven't had a blade break since. I'm convinced that all the blades were poorly welded, even by different suppliers.
For reference and as a last resort, Rikon has a written procedure for lower wheel adjustment to correct tracking problems on the 10-325. I recommend that you don't attempt the adjustment until have tried the above suggestions and you have talked with Rikon. Let Rikon recommend the lower wheel procedure to you.
I am one of those people that is impressed with The Snodgrass video, based solely on the fact that it worked for me, after chasing my own tail following Duginskie advice.
Another thing to keep in mind is that the Rikon 325 blade tension gage is blade length dependent, blades must be the same length to be of any value as a reference. In my opinion, the gage is a waste of time. There is quite a bit of flex in the frame and tensioning mechanism. I use only a 1/2" blade and find that if I change the tension 1/2 a turn, I have to re-adjust tracking.
My comment above on Snodgrass may have been easily misinterpreted. His methods have worked for me, and I have no complaints about them. But when the Carter exhibit is positioned near one's own location at a show, and the same presentation overwhelms your hearing and interferes with your speech recognition and your voice over three days, it can become very stressful, even if the advise is valuable. Of course, he is not the only source of hearing damage at a woodworking show: There are several vendors running power tools, several other hawkers and presenters with PA systems, and there is no acoustic damping in the whole hall. If your hearing has been abused over the years, I would highly recommend attending Lie-Nielsen events or Handworks instead.
At the wood working show at Denver a couple of years ago, the Carter demonstrator said to adjust the tracking so the teeth ride the center of the wheel. Then the side guides won't require adjustments when changing blade sizes. (Their system uses no rear guide, as I recall).
The factory tires just a year old should not need changing, dressing or reshaping.
Did you check on the position of the blade on the upper and lower tires to see if they are the same? If not, the saw might need to be adjusted. My 18" Rikon has some adjustment bolts on the lower wheel to help with this, with instructions in the manual (the bolts are on the outside of the cabinet). Perhaps yours has a similar adjustment. I had to adjust mine once and it has stayed in alignment, at least for the blades I use.
I might also try increasing the tension. If you are using the gauge on the saw, most agree these indicators are not very useful, often undertensioning. One book recommends using the markers for the next larger blade. From my tests with the Starrett tension gauge that may not even be enough. Something to try though.
Without a tension gauge you can use one of several methods to get close.
Here is a deflection tensioning method that sounds reasonable, from Sam Blasco on another forum. I don't think he would mind if I copied this part. Sam's method of tensioning without a gauge:
Come 6" down from the upper wheel, where the blade is about to enter the tire. Tension enough so that there is less than 1/4" deflection with moderate pressure (no body weight behind your finger). Track the blade where you want it. Close the doors and turn on the machine with no guides set and no zero clearance dust block. Check the blade to make sure it is not fluttering side to side. If it is, add a little more or less tension while the saw is running until the blade stops fluttering. Make a test cut on a 6" resaw. Does it cut easy? straight? no wander? If so, you have found a good starting point for tension. Draw a pencil line on your saw's gauge and you can return to that setting reliably for that blade again and again. A 1" blade will require the same tension as a 1/4" blade, but will use much less spring to get there. I have three pencil lines on my saws... 1", 1/2" and 1/4". Typically, for a 1" Carbide Tipped blade, the pointer will be about 1/4" above the last line on the saw’s gauge, or 5/8s of the way up from the bottom of the window. The picture below of my on board gauge is just to give you an example of about where the pointer goes, your own results may vary. The 21,000 psi is between those two upper lines and if I add enough tension to get the pointer just above the top line I'm at 26,000 psi, according to those gauges I mentioned above. The saw cuts very well at both of those points, so I like to err on the side of less tension (this goes for drive belts too). The results confirm my theory that a blade will cut well at many different tensions, and go in and out of "flutter" at many different tensions, too, so beware of the "flutter" test as a sole means of tensioning a saw. Harmonics is an interesting subject. I like to run my blades at the lowest tension they cut well at, since I believe there is no point in over-stressing a system. Would you run your car at the RPM red line all the time because the engine is capable of that? Why over stress a system if you don’t have to. If you feel you ever need more tension for a particularly hard task you know you have some in reserve, right? As for the pointer, itself, you can actually adjust it to point wherever you want it to when you reach a tension you like. Unscrew it from the frame and access the spring and its set screw from the backside. Personally I find it easier to make a pencil line.
There is also a way to accurately measure the tension using a digital caliper and small c-clamps instead of a tension gauge to measure the stretch of the blade, exactly what the expensive gauge does. This info is from From John TenEyck:
(Measuring tension with digital calipers)
...the blade guides are removed or at least backed away from the blade. Clamp the vernier with about a 5" gage length so that each jaw is on the flat of the blade, between two teeth. On really narrow blades it's best to face the vernier towards the back of the saw in order to avoid the teeth altogether.
The basic calculation is Young's Modulus = Stress/Strain, where:
1) The Young's Modulus of steel is about 30 x 10^6 psi.
2) Stress, the value you are after - the tension in the blade in psi.
3) Strain = Deflection / gage length. The vernier measures deflection, and the gage length is the starting distance between the jaws under zero load.
So, you rewrite the equation as Stress = Young's Modulus x Strain = 30 X 10^6 x deflection/gage length
The gage length I started with was 4.768", so when I measured a deflection of 0.003" that was equal to a blade tension of 30 X 10^ x 0.003/4.768 = 18,876 psi.
My little Delta was more than maxed out with the 1/2" blade I was using. The Iturra spring was nearly fully compressed, the frame was distorted by nearly 0.010" and that pulled the upper guide completely out of alignment. The data showed that I can't really run more than about 12K psi on a 1/2" blade. But with a 1/4" blade I can run at nearly 25K psi w/o over stressing the saw. The 1/2" blade will still cut OK at 12K psi, but I have to run more slowly than I would if I could apply higher tension to avoid blade deflection.
I tried Snodgrass's method and was very pleased with the result. I took the table off and everything. I ordered new bearings and installed them. Mine were in bad shape. It cuts great. I wouldn't mess with coplanar stuff.
Just put the deepest part of the gullet in the center. The guides go as close as possible with out touching.
John, thank you for your comprehensive answer, for the tensile test with a Vernier and the Sam Blasco method. I have a lot of information to work with and lots of testing and adjustments to tend to.
Something seems fishy about that equation.... I don't understand the need to divide by the gauge length - this should be a question of deflection under applied load alone.
I may be missing something, but I have to get to work so I'm not really concentrating on it.