Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Planer feed roller marks on boards

Posts

Planer feed roller marks on boards

#1

Planer feed roller marks on boards

Yonak

I have a planer that has a grooved, segmented feed roller. Sometimes my boards come out with serrated roller marks on the edges that extend in from the edge about 1/8" ~ 3/16". Does anyone know what causes this and how to fix it ?

I have a Powermatic 180 planer. I wonder if anyone who's familiar with such segmented rollers knows if the segments are individually adjustable or if, perhaps, the springs are worn out (I have got to believe, however, if the springs are worn out the tension would be less rather than greater) or, perhaps, if the segmented sections can sometimes get stuck out of position.. It doesn't happen on all boards, just on the edges of some, sometimes.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#2

That is why segmented rollers are to be avoided

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In theory segmented rollers enable one to plane more than one board at once because there will be equal pressure on whatever is under the rollers even if the two boards are not exactly the same thickness. In practice this concern is unimportant. My industrial sized machine has a single infeed roller. I routinely shoved two and three boards at a time through it and never saw a need for segmented rollers.

I did once use a segmented roller machine and saw what you see. Here is a possibility based on what I experienced. If the roller at the edge of the board is only partially on the edge, the roller force being exerted is concentrated on less board (same pounds of force on , for example, half the roller length instead of all of it. The result is dents at the board edge. The more easily dented the wood, and the lighter the cut, the more likely you will see this result.

It is common to have too much infeed roller pressure. I set the infeed roller just slightly lower than the cutterhead cutting circle.

Or you may be taking too light a cut. If I take too light a cut (say 1/64) I see roller marks across the lumber if the wood is soft.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#3

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

Grant Smith

Hi Yonak,

At least on my Delta DC 380 planer, I find these marks occasionally too. In general terms, I find that they are due to taking too light of a pass. Especially an issue when planing soft woods such as Cherry or Walnut, this is due to the light pass not erasing the marks which occur on most lumber as it is fed in to the planer.

Since I upgraded from a rubber infeed DeWalt lunchbox planer to the Delta, I had a hard time getting used to the issue. Indeed, it was such an issue for me that I invested in a Wixey planer thickness gauge accessory to allow me to hit the desired thickness every time right on the button. This way, I could ensure I was taking off a 16th of an inch or more on the final pass. Doing so completely eliminated the issue.

When I had the lunchbox planer, I was in the habit of test fitting a given board in a dado, or measuring it for desired thickness, then sneaking up with light passes on the desired thickness. Not good work method with the serrated infeed. Instead, measure carefully what you need and use a thickness gauge, or measure accurately what you want and plan to take off 1/16th or more on the final pass.

You may indeed have an issue such as Bill describes, but I suggest that you try making a heavier pass and see if it goes away before doing major overhaul work.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#4

Good analysis

John in NM

This makes sense - the reason its only at the edges.

My PM100 has a solid roller and I've never had the problem.

The other thing to consider is that the infeed roller may be too tight relative to the outfeed roller. I've seen that when the machine was adjusted by someone who didn't have the written procedure or just didn't understand how it was supposed to function.

Powermatic used to send you a booklet with full adjustment instructions, free for the asking. I doubt they do it any more, but it might be worth asking them.

Probably one could find the booklet on ebay if they wanted. It has setup instructions for the big machines like the 180. I don't think the instructions would work for the new imports they sell (which is why I doubt they still hand out the booklet).

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#5

set up is universal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Everything is set relative to the circle defined by the cutterhead, no matter the machine The only critical adjustment is the pressure bar. I find it best set empirically. Lower it in increments until the lumber jams, then raise it a bit until the lumber just feeds. This procedure should eliminate any snipe.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#6

Infeed roller is too tight

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you need to take a 1/16" cut to remove infeed roller marks your infeed roller is set hugely too low. An optimally set up machine will not telegraph the infeed roller on a 1/32" cut under any circumstances(nonsegmented roller) and on any hard wood the cut can be a bit less than this amount.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#7

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

Joseph Mulherin

Yonak, I typed in the "Powermatic 180.com/manual" and up came the spot at "Fineproductmanuals.com".

You should find a complete manual to fix the situation.....but I would say to buy a solid roller and get rid of the segmented one because you will not be able to get smooth boards with it if you are using soft lumber or are finding marks on just the edges.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#8

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

Yonak

Grant, thanks for your insight. I'm familiar with the marks you are talking about and I don't think it is due to taking too light of a pass. I take off 1/16". These marks are quite heavy just on the edge of the boards. I think Bill is probably right that my feed roller is likely adjusted too low. I'll try adjusting that.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#9

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

Yonak

Thanks, Joseph, I watched a video on making adjustments to the rollers and bed on my machine and there was no mention of this issue. I will get the manual and check it out. Thanks for the info.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#10

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

Grant Smith

Yonak,

Thanks for posting on the subject. Bill's comments will prompt me to have a look at the setting. Thanks, Bill!

PS, I still recommend the thickness gauge. Wouldn't be without it.

Regards,

Grant

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#11

Only if you understand it....

John in NM

If one doesn't have that picture in their head already, the step by step that is specific to a given family of machines will get them results without the understanding.

If you don't understand how all the parts work together, then setting up a PM180 is very different than setting up that top motor design that all the importers were selling for a while (and perhaps still are).

Its also handy for the novice to have instructions spelling out how many thousandths to set the rollers at vs. the arc of the head. I never remember exactly so always go to that little booklet to look it up.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#12

Powermatic 180 infeed roller adjustment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have the manual in front of me.

With a block of wood as a gage block lower the table until the knives just "kiss" the gauge block as you spin them by hand. For a solid infeed roller set its height "1/32 lower" than the arc of the cutterhead. This setting is accomplished by lowering the table 1/32 and then adjusting the infeed roller until it just kisses the block. However, for a segmented infeed roll, adjust it 1/16" lower.

In my experience this setting puts more pressure on the wood than necessary. Keep in mind that if you are removing 1/16" the board will already be 1/16" higher than the cutterhead arc on the infeed side. An infeed roll setting 1/16" below the cutterhead arc would be mashing the rollers up 1/8" from the rest position. A roller overhanging the edge would be mashing into the edge with considerable force in this situation.

A clutzy fix for your situation is to feed a sacrificial piece next to the good board.

Powermatic pushed segmented rollers. I don't know why.

I wax the planer table and set the infeed roller less than what Powermatic suggests. But in the end these adjustments are best done empirically. Put as little pressure on the infeed roller as what it takes to reliably feed. I endure some hangups in trade for the lighter setting. I am always standing by to give lumber a push as needed.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#13

Re: Good analysis

William Duffield

The adjustment procedures are included in the user's manual on the newer PM machines. hey are available on the web in .pdf format. There are most probably a lot of similarities in adjustment procedures between the old machines and newer ones, since it would have been difficult to come up with a design that works better. Other bells and whistles would be more likely to have been changed (and cheapened) over they years.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#14

There's an article right there...

Grant Smith

Thanks, Bill.

My Delta DC-380 planer was rescued from a failed small sawmill that thought they'd plane the lumber right as it came off of the mill. As you well know, there are so many things wrong about that approach that one's mind is boggled. I recall asking the seller if he meant to say "when the lumber comes out of the kiln", he said.. "Nope, we save steps by planing before it goes in the stack for air drying". Sheesh. I let it go at that, but I did use the condition of the planer to get a great price, $300. He had a WoodMizer that was also for sale. Both machines had been kept inside, looked nearly new, except for the rusted table on the planer. They had only milled around 6,000 BFt, according to him. The market dropped to where it wasn't profitable was his reason for quitting.

Anyway, my planer was had for a song, but it needed lots of rust removal from the green lumber. To be honest, once i got it cleaned and the rusty beds polished, I started using it without a thought of the infeed/ outfeed settings. Now I wonder if they had cranked the infeed roller down to get it to feed through the rust and (probably) uneven green boards.

By the way, I don't really recall exactly at what thickness my planer will show infeed roller marks, just going from memory. My process now uses the Wixey gauge, first finding the depth before sliding in the stock, then raising the cutter head in increments of 1/2 turn of the height adjustment until the board is admitted. So I have developed a workaround that has been fine for my needs. That said, now that I know more, I will dig in and see if the machine can be adjusted for the better.

Thanks again,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#15

Re: Powermatic 180 infeed roller adjustment

Yonak

Bill, you're right about the feed roller being 1/8" below the surface of the inbound board. I never really thought of it that way. I've never had a hint of slippage .. I guess I know why now. I wonder why they recommend 1/16" below the blade height. It makes sense that I can raise the roller. I'm going to try that. It's a pretty easy fix if it does the trick.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#16

What a story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Green oak will rust the planer in the time it takes to feed through the first 4 feet! I am amazed it was able to be rescued at all. But all's well that ends. I encourage people to buy these old machines. The heavier they are the better they plane. My machine will leave a snipe-free surface ready for 120 grit paper when it is set up right and not abused knives. Your's too I presume.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#17

Re: Powermatic 180 infeed roller adjustment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The segmented rolls were designed for rough lumber sizing. Powermatic was paranoid about loose lumber kicking back at the operator. Hence the robust infeed roll pressure guaranteed to be mashing against any assortment of rough lumber in the machine at one time. Personally I have never in tens of thousand bdft of lumber ever had a loose board offer to kick back.

Now I have had some events with thin lumber. The cutterhead in these big machines pound the lumber. Thin lumber can get to resonating and just explode.

Re: Planer feed roller marks on boards

#18

Re: Powermatic 180 infeed roller adjustment

John McGaw

Waxing the planer table or anything else you can do to minimize friction is an absolute necessity on every planer I've used. My Robland has a solid serrated infeed roller rather than a segmented one and it has considerable power behind it but even that can be stymied by board-to-table friction.