Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Undersize Dog Holes

Posts

Undersize Dog Holes

#1

Undersize Dog Holes

William Duffield

An almost unpronounceable woodworking organization I belong to owns a Sjobergs Nordic workbench. While it leaves a lot to be desired, it was a generous donation and is convenient for carrying to shows, meetings and outreach events. This weekend, even though it does not break down, I carried it to and from a Lie-Nielsen event on the top of my Scion xB (handy rolling microwave oven :) ) and even unloaded it last night singlehanded.

I would like to make it a little more useful by enlarging the slightly undersized dog holes in the top and vise jaws to 3/4"ø ($#%^@ metric system!) so they can be used with popular holdfasts, bench dogs and other accessories. The top is not easily separable from the base, and would not conveniently set on a drill press table. I don't keep it at my shop, so it's not practical to use my machinery.

How would you enlarge the dog holes without wallowing them out or messing up their perpendicularity to the surfaces?

If you can't plane with the big dogs, stay under the bench! :D

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#2

Easy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Step 1 On a drill press drill a 3/4" hole in something hard about 2-3" thick.

Step 2 Place and clamp this hole over the undersized hole.

Step 3 Drill away. Caution it may be grabby depending on drill to hole size. You might have to hold UP on the drilling device, not push.

I have done, freehand, holes on my benches this way with total success.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#3

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

Keith Newton

A plunge router ought to do it easily.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#4

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

John McGaw

Caution! I haven't done this but...

I'd think that if you had template with a very accurate 3/4" (or whatever size you want) hole in it you could clamp it over the existing hole and then use a router equipped with a long flush-cut pattern bit to enlarge the existing hole.

Does this sound doable or am I overlooking something?

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#5

Re: Undersize Dog Holes *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

So from your question I see that the bench did not fall off the roof rack on the way home yesterday, which would have eliminated the need to enlarge the dog holes :b

I haven't tried this....

How about a 3/4" bit with a pilot?

Run it in a plunge router, the pilot will locate it and the plunge router will keep it straight.

Bob in NJ


Changeable-pilot counterbore

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#6

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

Hank Knight

I think Bill's method would work; but if it were me, I'd plug the original holes first to eliminate potential problems keeping the bit centered. My experience with trying to enlarge exusting holes without first plugging them has been poor at best.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#7

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

Ralph Lipeles

Can you drill a 3/4" hole in a 2 x 4 that can then be clamped to the top and used as a drill guide?

Another approach would be to use a drill press accessory that is made for portable drills. I have one that I got in the 50's that was made for my Black and Decker 1/2" slow speed drill. I still use it on occasions when doing deck work.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#8

i need to do the sake thing

Joseph Piotrowski

i need to do this and soon myself.

while back, researching a solution on the web this i ran across at tip that said to use a fostner bit.

i have not tried it, but the fostner bit seam to tract real well in overlapping hole. maybe this would work. i think it need careful alignment and a dead 90 drill path to work.

i also thought about just plugging the old holes and just drill new one. i not very particular on the appearance as mine is a cheap harbor freight bench. that will eventually get replaced.

good luck,

Joe P.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#9

maybe yes, maybe no

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My luck with forstner bits and overlapping holes is so-so. It depends a lot on how much the holes overlap. If you are cutting into less than half of the original hole, it would have a better chance of success. Especially using a hand-held drill.

Personally, I'd get the longest plunge router bit I could find and at least start the hole with that.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#10

Re: i need to do the sake thing

William Duffield

I have a better than Forstner bit (Famag Bor-Max) that would be my first choice, except for two problems: First, it is too short to go all the way through the vise jaws, and might not penetrate all the way through the top, either. If doing it with an alignment guide, it is too short for sure, and the aligning surface of the bit is only 3/8" deep, and allows the bit to wander. I haven't measured the bench top thickness yet.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#11

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

William Duffield

I didn't see any metric pilots at your link.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#12

Seems to me . . .

Bob Lang

. . . that this shouldn't be as difficult and complicated as we all want to make it. If the hole is close to 3/4, I would get a 3/4" twist bit in a manly drill motor and have at it. My thinking is the bit would take the path of least resistance and follow the existing hole without much collateral damage.

Bob Lang

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#13

Re: Seems to me . . .

AZ in Colorado Springs

I'd do as Bill described. The only tweak to his advice:. If it's a row of holes parallel to the edge, locate the starter hole in your guide so the the end of the guide is flush with the edge of the top. Use a forstner bit.

Clamp the guide securely -- maybe a 2x4 that spans the top and you can clamp both ends.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#14

Re: Seems to me . . .

William Duffield

That's what I'm going to try first, if I can support the bench top on my drill press, but my 3/4" twist drill bit has a #2 Morse taper, and none of my hand drills, powered or cranked, will grip it.

I do have a 3/4" Irwin bit with a tapered square tang that I've used to drill new dog holes in a new bench top. But there's no purchase for the screw tip to get it started.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#15

Re: Seems to me . . .

Rum

Turn a short dowel the size of the current hole with a small centering hole drilled into it (I would basically chuck a piece and turn and drill it in one chucking on the lathe).

Screw your auger bit into the centering hole.

Insert down into old hole and crank away.

voila "perfectly" (for some value of perfectly) centred hole enlargement.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#16

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

james runchey

I agree with Bill, a predrilled block to guide a bit works very well....done it many times.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#17

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

Phil Smith

Depending on how much undersized the hole is you might have luck with a metal reamer. The imports are cheap and they work well in metal. Should work in hardwood top.

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#18

I tried it, and it seems to work well *LINK*

Henry Higginbotham

I've looked at my cheapo set of adjustable hand reamers before and wondered if they wouldn't work for wood. I chucked one into a cordless drill and tried it on a hole in a treated 4x4. It's not as smooth as you'd get with a plunge router, but it's pretty good and would probably be better in harder wood. Less potential for excitement than a plunge router, too, unless you've got a handy way of fixing the router base to the workbench top.

But I have that same Sjobergs bench and the holes are already 3/4". William, did you take "European delivery" on your bench? :D


Cheapo hand reamer set

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#19

As Bill said, almost...

Clifton C

I enlarged mine almost like Bill said. Used a 4x4x1.5 block for the jig cause that’s what I had. Diagonal lines to find the center and drilled with a brad point bit. I have a forstner, but decided the brad point would be more stable in the jig. Drew lines down the bench centered through the holes, then with a square, drew lines across. Using the corners of the jig on the lines centered the jig, double stick tape held it in place. I crawled up on the bench so I could kneel over each hole and drill straight down, Probably not necessary, it just felt like the thing to do at the time. Easy, quick and inexpensive…(24 bench holes, 4 vice holes and 12 leg holes)

cc

Re: Undersize Dog Holes

#20

Re: I tried it, and it seems to work well

William Duffield

Thanks, guys, for introducing me to a new tool, previously unknown to me!

The dog holes are just a smidgen undersized. I won't know until Monday, when I get it back in my shop, just how much. Gramercy holdfasts, which are intentionally undersized, drop into the dog holes but don't hold. The wooden dowel on the post of my work light, which is loose in all the dog holes in all my benches, is a force fit in these. A compounding problem is that I also need to drill some new dog holes in the shoulder vise jaw and across the top opposite the jaw.

A problem with the plunge router "solution?" is that the bench top and vise jaws are too thick to get my longest 3/4" ø plunge router bit all the way through.

I usually put a small chamfer on the top edge of dog holes, with a trim router, so if I do that before drilling or reaming, it should help to get a slightly larger twist drill started.

Thanks for all the suggestions. The discussion has, I'm sure, been enlightening to all of us.