I ordered a Byrd/shelix cutter head for my jointer before Christmas. They indicated it would go out......soon.....they were fairly busy with year end orders. I left the country for a few days and had a friend watching for it, but have not seen it.
I sent them an E-mail this morning, but obviously have not heard back.
Am I in too much of a hurry? I assumed they would send it in a week or so. Would you be concerned?
Bill, I bought this jointer when I got out of college in 1971. Over the years the pot metal pulley has worked loose and ruined the shaft on the cutter head. Could have had it rebuilt or bought a new standard head (maybe), but the head did not include jack screws for setting the knives. It was a PITA to set the knives and I had a tendency to let them go too long between sharpening. So I decided to "upgrade" to the carbide cutters as much for easy of resetting the knives as anything else. Hopefully, I have done something nice for me.
I knew the jointer was "grumbling" and thought that after 45 years the bearings had gone bad. When I took it apart, I was stunned at how chewed up the shaft was. The pulley was a little wallowed out but the shaft was practically triangular. Would have thought the pot metal would have failed completely without chewing up the shaft.
I ordered one the end of January. I got this message from them:
"Unfortunately, the SHELIX head you ordered is currently out of stock. This may cause a delay of about four to five weeks before your order can ship, due to very high order volumes."
Turn and face the strange Bill. Times, materials and methods change. When I see a WoodCentral see a post about Forrest blades or Shelix cutter heads I start listening for the scruffing of your soapbox being dragged out...:-)
People here are often saying that they can achieve whatever with tried/true methods. That may be true, but unless you enjoy the tried/true for their place in history, why dismiss a newer approach without an open mind?
The virtual elimination of tearout on figured stuff is something to behold on my meager 8" jointer with its byrd spiral. My only problem: I now drool over 15" planers with byrds.
1. No more screwing around endlessly trying to get all three blades in the same exact arc. This translates into more time for actual wood working and less blood loss working with three razor-sharp blades.
2. No more trying to find new blades that fit my machine in an environment that is evolving towards less diversity. The last blades I bought were close-outs. I used to let the blades get too dull before changing them.
3. An unexpected bonus was the significant reduction in noise from my jointer, which used to challenge my planer in the banshee scream department.
4. Less scolloping on the edges to be joined-a consequence of blade-height errors and feed speed.
5. The spiral arrangement tends to pull boards into the fence.
6. Jointing is more comfortable; less vibration is transferred to the work piece.
7. There is less tearout because the carbide chips create more shear.
8. I can set the out feed table to the height of the cutters. With blades, I had to add .004" to account for the lift the blades give to the workpiece.
9. I can make lighter cuts because the down-pressure on the board is reduced.
Planers and jointers both put flat surfaces on boards. I decide which surfaces will be the show surfaces after I've jointed and planed them. The surfaces produced by my helical head planer are significantly superior to the surfaces produced by my previous planer and my current jointer, and require much less post-processing.
The amount of time/money I waste sharpening, replacing, and resetting cutters is significantly reduced. The edges of the carbide cutters, unlike the high carbon steel cutters, do not rust.
If you compare the size and shape of the chips that come off the helical cutters, it should be obvious that shavings from long knives hang up much more easily in the ducts of dust collection systems. Most of us have cobbled together ducting with ducts that are less than 6" diameter, too many hairpin turns, and insufficient CFM of air movement, and don't like to take the ducting apart when it clogs.
Helical heads are significantly quieter than traditional jointer and planer knife heads. If you have a cheap planer or jointer with a universal motor, you probably won't notice, but with heavier machines with induction motors, they might make the difference between the annoyance of using ear protection, or more effective ear protection.
John, I can tell you my experience with changing over my 8" Delta jointer was pretty simple. I purchased a Byrd head and just followed the directions. About the only thing I had to do during installation that wasn't a straight remove and replace thing, as hoped for, was one end needed to be shimmed very slightly. Otherwise, it was very easy.
The Byrd head cuts very clean no matter grain or feed direction. It cuts knots in pine and cedar very smooth, unlike the original straight-blade head.
I got another message from them last night. The head shipped yesterday, and UPS tracking shows it should arrive by end of business day tomorrow. Now, all I need to do is work the installation into my schedule, and figure out what to do with the old head and knives.
Re: What Does This Have To Do With The OP's Questi
William Duffield
I can't replay to a deleted posting, so I guess this will have to do:
I think Bill posed a good question, and an open discussion of the pros and cons of a helical head for a jointer offers valuable insight to many of us here. It is pertinent to the original question, because lead time and installation time for replacing a head are factors that should be considered when deciding whether to upgrade a jointer or even replace an old one with a new helical head machine. I know I debated with myself for a considerable time before deciding a Byrd head for my DJ-20 made sense to me, from a cost, performance and trouble perspective.
I don't understand the concept of hijacking a thread, unless it is totally irrelevant spam, and this is not. Both issues are about helical heads for jointers, the only tangentiality issue is when vs. why.