Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Posts

Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#1

Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Virgil Johnson

I want to replace my 30 year old Craftsman 7 1/4" saw.

Looking at the Bosch CS10 , Makita 5007MG and Skilsaw SPT67WM-22. The Skilsaw seemed like a decent deal for 99 bucks. Anyone bought a circular saw lately that would care to comment?

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#2

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

John K Jordan

You might want to say what you plan to use it for.

I use mine mostly for construction and maintenance around the farm, often up a ladder and far from power, so I want light weight and portability. For my use a Dewalt 18v cordless is perfect.

JKJ

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#3

Shouldn't be hard to find a "used" one

Henry Higginbotham

I suspect there are a LOT of very lightly used corded circular saws lying around that could be bought for cheap. Every year or so I debate whether to keep my Makita 5007. I doubt it's got 30 minutes total cutting time on it. Dedicated track saws and cordless circular saws have sent quite a few 5007s and the like to live out their days on a shelf.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#4

No, my 30 year old Craftsman is going strong


Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#5

JL

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

JL

Depends on what you will be cutting.

If you are ripping plywood - any good circular saw should work. The Bosch is a good choice.

If you are ripping wood onsite (2 x X) - you need something with a bit more power or torque - such as a worm drive.

But otherwise any good 12-15 amp saw would work.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#6

Mine has 1/16" armature end play.

Virgil Johnson

Always had a bit of slop. Its time for it to be replaced.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#7

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Chuck Bjorgen

I bought the Makita 5007MG from Amazon back in 2015 to replace my 40 year old Skilsaw for $150. I chose Makita because I'd never owned one of that brand and it seemed highly recommended by construction folks. We used it mainly for breaking down garden lumber for disposal so it was probably overkill but the magnesium build probably made it lighter for my use. Compared to my old saw it is wonderful.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#8

Seek

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

a Porter Cable Saw Boss 345 6". If you can find one in good shape (discontinued when Dewalt bought out P-C) you'll love it. It cuts 2x stock and glides through 1" hard maple.

I still have my big honker Skill 7-1/4 worm drive that comes out for ripping wet PT and 4x on site, but the Boss is go-to for most jobs, especially breaking down sheet goods.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm a retired carpenter. I used a circular saw constantly. Dewalt has a decent saw. You can't kill a makita but they aren't the most user friendly. My everyday saw was a ridgid . Light and strong,east to handle,minor adjustment issues. I had a bosch and disliked it. If this is only for lightweight homeowner type use any saw should be fine.---Jack

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#10

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If you are like many of us, a portable circular saw is rarely used. I had a Thor that I purchased around 1960 that I threw out about 40 years later due to the switch failing. I picked up an 8" OLD Black and Decker at a yard sale for $4 or $5 with a cut off cord about 15 years ago. It has enough power to plow your garden! I have used it maybe 3 times while I owned it. If you don't use one often I sure wouldn't invest a hundred bucks. I think any of the 7 1/4" saws on the market would serve me for the rest of my life.

You may be different, if your doing a lot of remolding, farm maintenance or the like then others may advise a good lightweight saw.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#11

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Keith Newton

Those are all pretty good, but if I were to choose one, I'd go with the Makita. A friend I often work with got one, and I really like it. Often it's after dark when we're out on a job site, and the LEDs sure beat following the line by brail.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#12

Milwaukee, DeWalt, and Porter Cable in order

Grant Smith

Hi Virgil,

To some degree it depends on what you want to use it for. Give us more information about its planned use, and we can better tailor an answer.

I own two Milwaukee Tilt-lok saws that are flawless in how they have performed for me. I keep one for shop use, and one for outdoor stuff to include cutting concrete, etc. I love the Tilt lok handle concept, and I also like the Aluminum plate. Depending on your planned use, get the ripping guide accessory. No issues in 6 and ten years of use.

A good friend has a DeWalt circular saw that I have used on projects at his house, and it too is a good saw with great power and handling.

I own two Porter Cable circular saws. One is a 743, which I use for finer cuts in plywood. It has a dust collection port which captures about 90 percent of the dust.. PC used to make a 347 too, which is left handed. MY second is a 314, which is a worm drive small saw for panel cutting. LOVE IT, but I dont think they are made any more. I am not so sure about the current porter cable offerings, as it looks like the designs have changed dramatically... Maybe choose another brand unless you see great reviews.

Overall, I prefer the brands that contractors use for circular saws. They are build tough. I would include Makita and Hitachi in that category too.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#13

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Joseph Mulherin

Virgil, for just cutting very little you might check out the Harbor Freight saws.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#14

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Try to use the saw you think you want to use before your purchase. At my height, 6'6" a Porter Cable throws sawdust directly in my eyes. They are good saws but don't fit my body! My first saw, a Craftsman 7" saw with all aluminum body, worked well for 15 yrs until another worker dropped it off a 6' ladder onto concrete and broke the housing!

A Craftsman salesman told me a 7" saw did not exist...until he could not get a 7.25" blade to fit.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#15

Oh, and get some Freud blades

Grant Smith

I like the thin kerf and full kerf Freud blades for utility use. They make a model called The Demon that can cut through nails and such without damaging the teeth (usually). Also a 40 tooth ATB blade for under $20 that can provide nice cuts, if you have the need. Even a 60Tooth blade is available if you plan to use a straightedge and want flawless.

The thin kerf blades can cut faster if finish isn't important (such as framing).

I buy Freuds D0724A framing blades several at a time, and reach for one for when I need a blade for cutting up framing lumber or similar.

Note that each of these blades will also fit on the table saw and can be used as necessary for keep from damaging the full size fancy blades when you are doing utility projects.

With the Demon blade, I have ripped a 4' high pallet of 2x6" lumber down in to stakes for snowmobile trail marking without needing to change blades. Went right through the staples found in such lumber. Great for removing a deck or other large wooden structure.

I like DeWalts new circular saw blades, too.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#16

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

John McGaw

What will the saw be used for? How extensively?

I have three different circular saws ranging from a circa-1982 Craftsman (in pretty rough shape after being used extensively to cut masonry) a heavy-duty worm-drive saw (which is unpleasant to use except for serious construction work) and a nice lightweight DeWalt battery-powered saw (which is excellent for shop use such as trimming stock and breaking down sheetgoods). I find the latter the most useful right now since it is easy and produces a cut which is pretty much glue-up ready with the right blade.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#17

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

Roy Girolami

I have thought when using my Milwaukee that the blade should be on the other side of the motor. I am right-handed, so to use the saw and follow a line, I am forced to contort my body. If the motor was on the right side of the blade, I could see the blade and the line more easily. PC used to make left and right hand models and I would have bought one but my Milwaukee still keeps chugging along. Over 20 years now.

Roy

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#18

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

John McGaw

I've never really thought about the left vs. right divide. Right now I couldn't tell you which side the blade is on on any of the three saws I own. Maybe if I used them more often I'd have feelings one way or the other.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#19

There is one drawback...

Grant Smith

I am a rightly and have a PC saw with the blade on the left. While it is nice to be able to see the cut, it does mean that you have the saw resting on the off cut most times. This can mean some flaws in the cut are inevitable as you near the end of cut.

I suppose one could adopt the "cut on styrofoam" method many use.

I recently bought a DeWalt track saw to help me with rip cutting of long boards and straight lining rough sawn boards. While not cheap, I think this tool can be a "low cost table saw" for beginners and those without a permanent shop. Certainly glue line cuts are possible.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#20

Mine too!

Tony-Memphis

But for $59 or something like that, it has always done what I asked it to do. To qualify, I only use it to break down larger pieces. I probably use it once or twice a year. Thought about one of the new track saws, but I try to avoid sheet goods as much as possible. I usually buy smaller pieces and cut them up with a jig saw.

Tony

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#21

Ditto on the Milwaukee Tilt Loc

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I have two, one at home and one at my river place. Used primarily to break down sheet goods with fine tooth blades. Great saw.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#22

Re: There is one drawback...

Joseph Mulherin

Have read all of the post on this topic and I have to ask why is it that most of you feel that Harbor Freight tools are junk???

The prices are low and the saws are good enough to last a few years. Mine did until I had the robbery last July 2016. And they offer different blades for the saws too....dado and diamond, and a blade sharpener tool too.

I am retired and am not a manufacturer of furniture or into construction anymore, so I choose to buy the HF tools for my own use in my shop.....and the store is just a few blocks from where i live here in Indio, CA.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#23

Re: There is one drawback...

TomD

I don't think Virgil ever said what he wanted the saw for, so HF might be his best bet. HF has some stuff that is great, and other stuff that is junk. We don't have them up here so I have gone to one the odd time and bought everything that caught my eye, and sorted it out later. I would buy their offerings for tools I only use occasionally, or for tools that are really highly rated. My feeling is that prices seem always to be converging. While in theory, inflation has been next to non-existant, many of the cheapo tools, now cost, number for number what the tools they replaced that were made in America cost. The days of the deals may be limited.

I recently bought several of their routers for various fixtures. I can't return stuff to them, it turned out to have a badly misshapen base, so I will just fix it.

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#24

Re: There is one drawback...

Grant Smith

Hi Joe,

I have shopped at Harbor Freight. I can likely name nearly everything I have purchased there:

-An pneumatic flooring stapler for installing hardwood flooring. Worked, I now just basically loan it out to friends, as my work with it is done. The other option was $400 stanley bostitch. I rate it a 6 out of ten, because of constant air leaking and fit and finish

-little disposable brushes. Fine for their purpose. 7 out of ten because the hairs fall out of the brushes as you use them.

-A 20 ton wood splitter that is used for splitting wood for the extended family, none of us burn wood for heat, just for campfires and ambience burning in the house. Total of maybe 4 cords per year of use. It has a Great Robin engine, Haldex pump and valve. The rest has been redesigned by us because fit and finish was lacking, making setup and tear down frustrating, use frustrating. Poor design and weak bolts caused early failure and redesign of the sliding wedge assembly. All of the hoses have been replaced with higher quality hoses for safety. The oil return hose was not rated for hot hydraulic oil, which caused it to fail catastrophically, nearly scalding a bystander. Harbor Freight and the manufacturer would have had a lawsuit on their hands if the hose had swung a few more feet in the wrong direction. This is why we swapped out all of the hoses with industrial excavator grade lines. 5 out of ten, all five of which go to the engine and pump/valve reliability. That it is still operating is a testament to our welding and fab capabilities.

-Assorted casters for both work and shop use. Most of them are OK, but you need to inspect them closely for manufacturing defects. I give a hand full of bad ones to a clerk and they end up back in the bin. 6 out of ten.

-A pneumatic upholstery stapler. Works OK so far. 8 our of 10.

SO, would I buy a tool I plan to use as often as a circular saw there? Nope. Not. A. Chance. I will emphatically refer readers to my prior recommendations.

To be fair, it seems many companies make crap for the masses in much the same way these days. Even Lowe's "lifetime guaranteed" tools break when used as intended. Sure, they'll give you another free, but my time is more valuable than that.

I pretty much don't buy store branded anything these days. I go for what the contractors and professionals buy. Cry once about the price, and be happy ever after.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Circular saw recomendations anyone?

#25

Re: There is one drawback...

Joseph Mulherin

I hear you, Tom and Grant.......each to his own opinion. My purchases have been good for me since I do not do a lot of saw cuttings with the HF saws.