Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

Posts

On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

#1

On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

Grant Smith

I recently had a good conversation with a pro woodworker about sanders, sandpaper, and how manufacturers are fond of obsoleting things for their own benefit. We reached a few conclusions, and had a few more global questions I will share here in an effort to extend the conversation and enlighten all of us (including me).

1. John and I noticed that Mirka recently ended production on a few of their sandpaper offerings. One example is their 6" 8 hole Hook and Loop(H&L) paper. I have come to find out that only Fein sanders used this paper, so it makes sense from a business perspective I suppose.

I happen to have a Fein MSF 636-1 with a 6" pad on it. It is a hoss of a sander, and my main finishing sander. Being a fan of the Mirka paper, My "fix" was to get online and to buy up a five year supply. Surely I'd figure out something by then, or wear out the sander, an idea which I hate, because I want/ expect everything to last forever(who doesn't?). For the record, I did also note that other companies still make 6" 8 hole H&L paper, of which I was leery since I am getting old and am becoming set in my ways.

2. John owns a Festool 6" sander, and two Mirka Deros sanders, and he noted that the interface pads on them are entirely covered by a hood for dust collection. He therefore figured out that he could carefully drill with a forstner bit any hole pattern he wanted. Since he is fond of the performance of the Festool paper, he adapted his Mirka sanders to use it for a total cost of nothing by spending 20 minutes at the drill press(yeah, I know, time is money, but the satisfaction of getting one over on a company is worth every second, and can be savored forever).

3. We examined a Fein sander, Festool sander, and the Mirka sander and it appears that some interface pads and dust collection hoods are such that they can be modified to accept the paper of your choice. My Fein wasn't a good candidate, however, because of the internal paths within the interface pad only allowing an 8 hole pattern.

4. We concluded, based on several other observations that the makers of sanders these days prefer you to buy their sandpaper. They therefore make their sanders have incompatible hole patterns to thwart those who try other brands. They have miscalculated, however, the resourcefulness of the average woodworker. Workarounds are our mantra, equipped with the tools, we will not comply. And we are internet empowered, so we share these workarounds, along with general disdain for companies who try to monopolize our tool spend, or obsolete our favorite tool.

5. We noticed that sander makers are creating interface plate designs which have ever increasingly complex hole patterns. "For improved dust pickup" they say. Yeah, well it also helps the sandpaper division sell their product, too, doesn't it?

What is the big deal, you ask? Well, at some point, your favorite sander will die, and you will need to replace it. At that moment, the "big deal" will strike you full in the face when you glance up to the $120 worth of leftover sandpaper on the shelf. You choices at that point will be to buy the same brand that just failed, or to get creative and find a sander with an interface place that can be drilled to your own needs.

I will close with my favorite gripe in life:

"Why can't these people sit down and have lunch?" Nooooo, they would rather fight with one another than make things better for the user. Witness Walmart and Target, or CVS and Walgreens, each building a huge store as close as possible to the other. Locked in a death match of a sort only robber baron railroad companies of the 18th century would appreciate.

But I digress.. The main point is: I know my next fancy main sander will have a drillable interface pad.

Extra credit rant: I firmly believe lower end tool companies have systematically bought up the better companies just so they could own the patents, copy the products, then sell under the name of the reliable tool badge an inferior product at a premium price. We see your tactics, and will unite against such oppression!

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

#2

Edit:

Grant Smith

I said: "Locked in a death match of a sort only robber baron railroad companies of the 18th century would appreciate."

I should have said: "Locked in a death match of a sort only robber baron railroad companies of the 19th century would appreciate."

Grant

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

#3

Re: Edit:

Marc in Mass

What a difference a century makes. :D

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

#4

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If you used the Abranet mesh, you would not need to worry about hole positions at all. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

#5

Re: On sanders, sandpaper, and future proofing

William Duffield

It is not a newly discovered marketing strategy to put up a store front near your competitors. This has been common practice for millennia. It decreases your raw materials supply costs. It attracts customers, who want a choice. It decreases your customers' costs when they need to "shop around". It increases your good will with your customers when you can send them a couple houses down the street if you can't meet their needs. It makes it easier to find good help, since they will know that if it doesn't work out, they can more easily find employment elsewhere without the expense of moving their household.

In order to make improvements to your products, so they work better and cost the user less, changes (innovations) must be made. Whether I'm sanding in someone's home or in my shop where I'm the only one breathing or waiting for finish to cure, effective dust control is very important. That's why I use Festool sanders. They couldn't have made the significant improvements they did if they had stayed with one of the traditional zero, five or eight hole patterns. First, they moved the collection holes closer to the perimeter of the pad, to collect the dust that traditional sanders slung out into the room due to centrifugal force. To try to collect this dust, the traditional strategy was to just increase the suction. This also increased the pressure of the abrasive on the product, decreasing the mobility of the sander and increasing friction and heat, which led to premature failure of the abrasive and the sander.

I'm sure you've noticed that when you've worn out a sanding pad that there's still plenty of sharp abrasive right in the middle. Another Festool innovation was to punch another hole in this unused area and make good use of it, by blowing air from the motor through it and out between the abrasive pad and the surface being sanded. This carries the dust out to the outer holes where it is effectively collected by the vacuum before it can escape into the room and into your lungs. Additionally, this air flow cools the motor for longer motor life. It cools the pad for longer abrasive life, less loading, and longer pad life. And it lifts the sander on a cushion of air, making it easier to maneuver.

Later, Festool further improved the sanding process by adding a lot more dust collection holes in their Rotex sanders and paper. The new paper works just as well with the older sanders as the older paper, so you don’t need to worry about the old paper being discontinued. The new sanders work just as well with the old paper as the older sanders, so you don’t need to worry about obsolete paper sitting around on your shop shelf, collecting dust. This doesn’t look like planned obsolescence to me.

Although Klingspor, Mirka, etc. aren’t making paper to fit Festool sanders yet, eventually they will. Maybe it’s a patent issue. When they do, I will still be very reluctant to switch, because the Festool papers are still economical when their performance and longevity are factored in.