I have a Delta 14 inch band saw with the 6" riser. I have a project coming up where I plan on re-sawing some 2" thick Mahogany. My stock is 9" and 12" wide- I will probably rip the stock to widths ranging from 2.25" to 6" for the various parts I need. Once I have those widths ripped The re-sawing will mostly be in half yielding thickness just under 1" off the bandsaw- I will then plane them to 7/8 thickness. The lengths I'll be ripping will be 48" and under. My question is what is the best blade for the re-sawing on the Band Saw- Mahogany is not a very "hard" hardwood But I assume there are some optimum TPI recommendations...Thanks.
I have had good luck with the Highland Hardware Wood Slicer blade. I have a Jet 14" with riser. I have used it on mahogany, maple, walnut, etc. No real issues and it seems to cut well and leave a decent surface. I'd like to try a carbide blade someday, but these are so reasonable, they are hard to beat.
I don't have my Delta anymore but I just used a cheap 1/2" 3TPI for my resawing. What I had to do did not need a very thin kerf. As long as I kept the blade tensioned properly and fed the wood at the proper rate I got a good straight cut. It did have a lot of gullet marks that had to be planed out but then the blade only costs me $9. My new saw is much higher quality and with the same brand of blade I get a pretty good cut. Still someday hope to get a top of the line blade, just because I want to see.
What I mean is what attributes of the resawing are most important for you to achieve with this purchase? Cost- what ever blade you have on the saw will suffice for this job but perhaps with a sacrifice of speed or smoothness of cut. Speed- get a 3/4" blade with as few a teeth that you can find. Smoothness of cut- buy a carbide blade. Is the blade to solve a longer term need?
I'm cheap so I buy a blade welded up from roll stock at a saw shop. Less than $10 for your saw. 3 tpi in a 3/4" blade is fairly fast and leaves a cut that can be smoothed with a 1/32 planer pass.
What I mean is what attributes of the resawing are most important for you to achieve with this purchase? Cost- what ever blade you have on the saw will suffice for this job but perhaps with a sacrifice of speed or smoothness of cut. Speed- get a 3/4" blade with as few a teeth that you can find. Smoothness of cut- buy a carbide blade. Is the blade to solve a longer term need?
I'm cheap so I buy a blade welded up from roll stock at a saw shop. Less than $10 for your saw. 3 tpi in a 3/4" blade is fairly fast and leaves a cut that can be smoothed with a 1/32 planer pass.
humm-things I hadn't considered!
Cost- well I want it to cut efficiently for as long as possible-I am not close to the saw at this point so I don't remember the TPI for the blade currently on the saw. I know it is a 1/4" blade and I know I want a wider one for the re-saw purpose so 3/4 is probably the dimension I'll use.
smoothness?
Not as important as long as I can get my saw to cut without a lot of drift or wander-This is a used saw and I have only done free hand cutting so far on mostly thin plywood. I may have to do some tuning for the re-saw tasks- 3tpi seems the best for re-sawing according to response so far.
Long Term Need-
Maybe so- much of my veneer work the past 15 years has been with relatively thin veneer purchased from suppliers. If this saw/blade can re saw thicker widths ie 1/8" or more - I 'll be slicing my own veneer in future projects.
Mahogany cuts like a dream, no need for an expensive blade. Best tip for resawing, SLOW FEED! If you see sawdust in the kerf after you made a cut, you fed too fast. Fast feeding also contributes to a barrel cut since the gullets are full of sawdust and if you keep pushing, the blade bows. 1/2" wide blade is plenty for that saw.
I use a 1/2 3tpi Timberwolf on my JET 18. Tried a 3/4" for resawing but harder to tension properly. Went back to the 1/2"
TIP: Make yourself a full height fence (I have several) for what you'll be cutting and make very sure that your two riding surfaces are dead-nuts square with each other.
The Wood Slicer will probably handle it well. Actually, given the stock thickness and widths and the desired finished thickness you could just about get away with a thin-kerf rip blade on a table saw. I used to do that sort of stock reduction all the time when I had no bandsaw. Resawing wide stock on a TS can be a bit scary at first so if you aren't comfortable with the idea, forget I mentioned it.
I have a 14" Delta without riser but I use my larger MiniMax 16 equipped with a dedicated 1-inch carbide blade for resawing and such.
While I am not an expert on bandsaws, my experience with the Delta saw makes me question whether or not it has the ability to properly tension a 3/4" blades versus a 1/2" for an operation like resawing veneer. I don't believe the stock spring and frame are able to handle this easily, even with the addition of aftermarket parts. I'm sure there are Delta users with 3/4" blades that will say they work. All I'm saying is I think the saw was made to work better with a blade width of 1/2".
I think you would be better served going with a 1/2" because the saw will be able to handle it better. Also, like you mentioned, you will probably want to check the tuning of your saw for the best results.
Your 14" Delta won't be able to properly tension anything over 1/2". The 1/2" - 3tpi hook tooth that I recommend is one I've used for 40 years for resawing, including production resawing, although on a larger saw. Point is, it is fine for the type of sawing you described. Make sure you crank up the tension just about as high as you can get it.
Deflection and bowing in a cut are the result of inadequate beam strength in the blade. In other words, if the blade is able to bow away from you as you cut, it will have to deflect sideways to accommodate this bowing. Think of that old puzzler about how much will a railroad rail deflect if you make it 1" longer. The answer was something enormous like 50 feet. (Someone refresh me on this, eh?) So tension is very important, particularly with a narrower band.
When tension is lower than ideal, a slow feed rate will allow the blade to cut at a leisurely pace. With proper tension, you actually get a better result by keeping a constant and somewhat aggressive feed pressure on the workpiece.
Another factor to consider is the set of the teeth. I always used Timberwolf blades from Suffolk Machinery because their grinding and setting is very uniform compared to cheaper, stamped blades, which usually have an unbalanced set. Highland's Woodslicer gets high marks for this and for quality of cut. I don't prefer them because they don't last as long for me for some reason.
There's also a lot of debate about fences. I'm an advocate of a point fence, which only contacts the workpiece at a point directly next to the tips of the teeth. Other people swear by a straight fence that is adjusted in advance to parallel the natural cutting drift of the blade. If your blade is sharp and the setting is uniform on both sides, it should cut dead straight, so this may not be an issue. Cutting with a point fence requires a bit more attention, but you can compensate for any slight drift by pivoting the workpiece slightly against the point fence as you cut. I like to sight down the kerf as it exits the back of the blade and try to keep the blade centered in that kerf. This requires a sort of cross-eyed attention, but it works great for me.
I know there are a lot of opinions out there on every aspect of bandsaw setup, blades and techniques, and these are mine, but I think you'll find that a lot of pros agree.
I recall once when we had a big cover story on bandsaws, my old pal Mark Duginske came over to set up our Delta 14" (with riser block, like yours). He spent a couple hours getting the wheels dead-nuts co-planar, the guides properly aligned and set and the blade properly tensioned, the fence set up and everything square, parallel and perpendicular. I brought out a 12" wide piece of 8/4 walnut crotch for the photo shoot, and that saw peeled near-perfect 1/8" slices off that board. So, it can be done. But, the blade alone won't do it. You need to be sure your saw is set up as good as you can get it.
If you anticipate long term veneer preparation spring for a carbide blade. It cuts so smooth that you can glue right off the saw.
Drift is a result of teeth getting clogged up with sawdust. Once the gullet fills you loose effective set in the blade and it wanders. Run the biggest gullets (few tpi) your saw will accommodate if smoothness of cut is not a factor.
Remember my veneer sawing tip. Once you get an acceptable blade the biggest loss of wood will be straightening the remaining surface after each pass. Especially figured wood will spring as tension is released by resawing. Solution- glue the billet to a stiff backer board.
Sawing your own veneer is great fun. (see my dovetail post of an example, PIC 1)
I use 1/2" 3-tpi blades for almost everything, including resawing and processing green wood into turning blanks. (Don't do much resawing but do a lot of green wood processing.)
I've tried various brands of blades over the years and never saw a huge difference. The blades I use now are made from Lennox stock by a local welding and industrial supply company.
I use that 1/2" blade on an 18" Rikon that cuts 12" thick. I also have a 14" Delta with riser (that I tuned up with help from Duginski's book) and used the same blade for resawing to 12". No problems. The biggest thing I resawed was a 12' 2x12 from Douglas Fir, cut into 4 pieces. It came out fine and planed smooth with very little loss. Probably pure beginner's luck. It was out of ignorance I agreed to try this for a friend - I'd be terrified today to even try.
BTW, I've tried the single point resaw fences and a tall fence for resawing. I preferred the tall fence. The single point fence would probably be better if the blade tended to wander a bit for some reason or if the particular wood had grain or properties that caused problems.
Note that I always check and adjust the fence for drift before resawing.
I sometimes switch to a 4-tpi blade for smaller work, but not often. For thick wood too many teeth in the wood at once just get clogged up with sawdust.
I think proper tensioning is probably the biggest issue - if the tension is not proper resawing is far more difficult but still can be done by slowing down. The little scale on the back of most 14" saws are horrible. Even the very precise pointer on the bigger Rikon tensions way below what my tension gauge reports. The tension gauges are not cheap but if you know someone with one maybe you can borrow it. (I have 5 wood and metal bandsaws here including the sawmill so the cost was worth it for me.) I used to try to use 3/4" and even 1" blades on my 14" saw and while I could saw with them, there was no way I could set the tension properly without overstressing the saw. I bent the tensioning bracket that way and had to buy a replacement.
Another thing I would pay close attention to is the guides. When resawing I like to tighten up the guides a tiny bit, make sure that they are not pressing unevenly on one side of the blade, and make sure they are positioned properly behind the gullets and not too far back. If they are loose and/or too far back, the blade is far more likely to twist and follow the grain if it gets off just a little bit. The guides can force it to stay a little straighter.
Also, I like to have the blade running on the center of the crowns on the wheels. I know some say it doesn't matter, but I think it provides more support for the blade, especially for wider blades.
If I needed to resaw an expensive or special board I would set up and make a test run on another board first.
After trying other sizes, I have used the above for the last 10 years. I don't do a lot of re-sawing, but have been happy with the Highland Hardware Woodslicer. I also concur that good setup is essential. My 2 cents.
This morning I resawed a few pieces of 8/Q mahogany that was six inches wide and 50'' long. Used a new Timberwolf 1/2 3 TPI blade.
The mahogany cut like warm butter. A couple of light passes on the jointer cleaned up the blade marks leaving me with two very fat 7/8 thick pieces on each board.
So I feel very comfortable recommending this.
BTW, I suspect almost any fresh new blade would do the job nicely. Do a test cut in scrap first to find any possible issues (cutting in wrong place, fence not square to table, drift, etc) and fix the issues before you touch the good wood.
A dull blade can wander no matter what you adjust.
There is a difference between sawing green logs and veneer. Usually you are sawing veneer to stretch a piece of dry wood to cover more surface with its attractive features. How smooth and level the cut is will affect how much material needs to be removed to smooth the veneer and true the billet after each pass. With a blade that cuts rough and wanders one can effectively loose a slice or more of veneer for every slice you recover. With a carbide bade you ideally will loose nothing but the saw kerf. Other blades can approach the smoothness of the carbide. I have had instances were I could easily sand the teeth marks out using a typical steel blade.
I have read some of the replies, but not all, so I apologise if I am repeating something that others have stated.
My current machine is different from yours, but I had one nearly identical years ago.
The ideal resaw creates a straight and smooth cut. Sawing straight means that there is less waste to remove when planing the saw marks. Not many straight cuts end up being saw-mark free.
A wide blade is more likely to saw straight. A smoother cut is a function of even and/or reduced teeth set.
The way the blade ejects sawdust is important in its impact on tracking: too many teeth and too fast a cut create too much sawdust to eject, and the teeth load and the blade wanders. A dull blade does the same thing.
So the rule is "as wide as you can make the blade and with as few teeth as possible". For example, on my Hammer 4400 (17 1/2"), I use a (Lenox Woodmaster) 1" wide blade with 1 1/2 tpi. This saw has 4 hp and will chomp through anything, but I still feed as slowly as possible.
The question is what can you use? I recall fitting a 3/4" wide blade to my old 14". Can you get one with 1 1/2 tpi?
The Leonx is a good blade, but does not leave a smooth finish like a tablesaw. It is very decent, nonetheless. The teeth are bi-metal (HSS), which I can sharpen. I needed to remove some set to smoothen the cut. I doubt that your 14" saw + riser will cope with the tension required of a carbide blade, and even the bimetal ones may be doubtful (but worth trying). Personally, I found the Woodslicer to be crappy in regard to edge holding. They last a few minutes on my wood.
Lastly, my saw tracks very well, so I prefer a high, low fence over a single point fence. A single point is best when your blade will wander, but this leads to a less straight/flat surface, with more to flatten. Getting a straight cut is best, but does require that the points above are followed.
The best blade hands down is the RESAW blade sold at Highland Hardware in Atlanta. I was skepical but ordered one to try and I haven't looked back. It is the best I've seen and everything they say about it on the Highland site is spot on.
It leaves an almost perfect finish on the wood, but of course there is still some sanding needed to smooth it but about 10 or less percent of what i was getting with other blades.
It comes in 1/2 and 3/4" and I got both, like the 1/2" best.
The first bandsaw blade I tried for resawing was the Highland Hardware one. It left a very smooth cut, but seemed to get dull quicker than I expected. Since then I have stuck with Suffolk Machinery blades.