Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

Posts

Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#1

Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Background- the frame sides will be held together by dovetailing a veneered top and bottom into them. To deal with this potential cross grain situation the top and bottom are veneered plywood. Dovetails will be cut into the plywood and the pins will be cut into grain running 90 degrees from normal.


To my surprise and delight the tails cut nicely in the 13 ply, plus two I added, birch plywood. It think it essential here that I used a birch core plywood. They even pared nicely during minor adjustment and they appear strong. I would not hesitate to cut dovetails in this kind of plywood in the future with either a cross cut or rip dovetail saw.


The pins started equally delightfully. I fretted, needlessly over starting the saw in the cross grain rails. As someone here suggested some time ago, I nicked the scribe line, set the cross cut saw in the nick and breezed through the cuts. (the nicks are highlighted with pencil) I recommend this nickers approach if you are having saw starting problems.


I wasted out much of the pin waste with the router and solid 1/4" carbide bit(recommended for this kind of work for longevity). The Lee Valley light proved its worth here. I could direct a focused beam of light on the kerf and scribe line and route to them easily. I do love this light and recommend it for this kind of work.

Next my good spirits were dashed. Paring out the tiny bit of remaining waste is trivial in a conventional, vertical grain pin. In this case end grain is being pared. In the earlier ash posts some spoke of how ash is softer than oak. NOT MY ASH. It is in another universe from the walnut and cherry I usually pare. Chisels had to be in perfect order to pare this end grain.....slowly!

Every experience one has leaned in paring conventional half-blinds is wrong in this situation. The grain orientations are exactly backwards from prior experience. It took hours to do one set of pins. I got slightly better by the 4th, but in all it took 2 days of tedious shop time to fit the tails to pins.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#2

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Don Orr

Very interesting. You sure to do seem to like a challenge. Keep your progress posts coming-I enjoy them a lot.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#3

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Brian Holcombe

Interesting, I would expect that to go quickly. I take it you had to pare the sides of the dovetails?

I am still a little baffled on the engineering behind this case, I understand how the parts are going to assemble, but based on your original drawing the top overhangs the sides.

My first thought when looking at it was that the sides could terminate into a frame and panel top, you shot that idea down but I wasn't convinced that it wouldn't work. I know you replied to that idea, but I didn't see the reply until some weeks later.

So, how do you plan to build the overhanging top? Will you work moldings around the exterior?

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#4

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have made lots of half blind dovetails for drawers. I waste out most of the sockets in the pin board with a router then pare the long grain wedge shaped pieces that remain in the corners. It goes quickly.



I proceeded the same in this case except the grain in the pin board is going horizontal instead of vertical as seen in the picture. That left me paring recalcitrant hard end grain to remove the corner waste, which went amazingly slowly. I remain astonished how long it took to excavate such a small sliver of material. Ash is tough stuff.

The other issue is the horizontal grain in the pin board leaves the pins prone to splitting. The fit of the dovetails had to be optimum so as to not split out a pin when assembling. These joints could not be forced together like a typical drawer can be. Once assembled I am not concerned by the horizontal pin grain. I made enough of them that acting together they will handle considerable stress. As in Krenov cases the back will be a critical structural element.

The top that overhangs is applied to the "false top" that is dovetailed into the sides. It's standard period construction for case goods. The rest is standard Krenov display case construction.

Indeed I could have made a frame and panel top. I would still have been left with attaching it to the sides by some means. I'd rather dovetail the plywood, if dovetailing was the attachment.

In any case I glued it together last night and to my great relief the front, where the doors must attach, is all in one plane with no perceptible twist. The rest of the construction is straightforward.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#5

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Brian Holcombe

Ah, to save yourself future headaches such as this one I would suggest making a structural bonnet top and attaching it to the base with tenons at the sides and support with light stretchers.

So, rather than moldings pne would apply molded framing members.

Dovetails are not especially strong against racking, I would expect a tall cabinet like this to have supporting members along the top front and bottom front in order offer suppprt against racking and maintain easily closing doors in the future.

It can be forgone in shorter cabinets but tall cabinets do put a huge strain on the corner joints anytime people lean against them or simply press against the sides for any number of reasons.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#6

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"in order offer suppprt against racking " ......which is why the back will be, must be, structural. It is a technique I learned from the Krenov school of engineering( via Finck, the plane guy). Additionally, Krenov employed a rub support opposite the hinge on the bottom of the door. This sticky up thingy takes the load off the door in its closed position.

The proof will be in the pudding. Will report if it doesn't work.

Indeed Krenov would have doweled a top on the cabinet. I considered it.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#7

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

William Duffield

I have a real bad feeling about this. Your pins have no strength. We discussed this with respect to the joining of legs to meta-benches. The strongest joint of this type has one tail and two half pins. The more pins you add, the more strength you lose, and the more it acts like a zipper.

A stronger joint would be glued, face grain to face grain with a shallow rabbet in the plywood top, removing the outer longitudinal ply and exposing the first layer of ply running across the board (from the front of the cabinet to the back). But that would rely totally on the strength of the glue. Like Krenov did, it might be structurally strengthened with a few dowels.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#8

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

TomD

That is how I used to do my dovetails in the 80s, before I knew how to chop well enough, which obviously is not your problem. I just eyeballed the routering as long as one feeds correctly there isn't any risk.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#9

What are you imagining.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....that is going to stress these joints once assembled into the final piece? It's a display case not a steamer trunk. By definition display cases are light and airy and hence more frail than steamer trunks. It will sit in one place until someone someday decides to move it. It is not going to weigh much so there is not going to be much stress in picking it up. People moving something that is almost entirely glass will likely use some care. Again, what do you imagine that will break the joint you are concerned with that will not destroy the glass! Keep in mind that this thing will have a tightly fitted, glued in place, back that will counter any imaginable racking force.

Once every few years the doors will get opened....if my current experience with a 1910 display case is any indication. If you thinks this piece is unduly frail check out some early 20th century curved glass cases. I have one that has survived, including moves from NY to FL, back to NY and then to TN. I have no doubt that this ash piece will be at least as durable.

Bottom line of it all- the design suited the need. The engineering suited the design as well as any alternative I have considered or has been recommended. I'll let you all know if the cut glass bowls and china collapse it.

On a philosophical note, those that design and build always face compromise. The most fundamental compromise is can I engineer a design good enough for the piece's purpose. Then one faces do I have the skill and tools to build it, how long will it take to build, what will it cost, is good enough good enough to satisfy the maker, etc.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#10

Re: What are you imagining.....

William Duffield

The only thing I have a problem with is the engineering. The faux dovetails weaken the structural integrity of the case, and therefore should not be used. This is not the first instance of someone publishing this "joint" on the web or in print, and I consider it my duty to the woodworking community to warn them whenever I see it promulgated.

In another thread, Brian already pointed our only one of many potential failure modes.

I agree with your assessment that properly fitted and glazed glass, a glued-in plywood back, and care in moving will probably keep the case intact for a long time. However, you cannot predict who will move it in the future. I have seen many instances of furniture damaged or destroyed in moving, even by "professionals." You cannot predict to what future use it may be put, maybe to display and store a large collection of rare books (or anvils :D ).

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#11

Theoretical woodworking.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is easy to criticize some element of the engineering for its lack of ultimate durability if appearance and function are ignored. A valid criticism is one that better solves the engineering while preserving the essential design elements.

So far you have stated a rule you have established that says never use horizontal grain for a dovetail pin board. Apparently this rule does not consider either the potential strength of the wood used nor the size of the pins, something I gave a lot of thought to in the situation at hand.

I provided earlier a sketch of what the case needs to look like. How would you fasten it together? The bystanders can then judge the alternatives if they ever build a display case with glass sides. I might ever start over is an elegant solution is offered. I once built a domed trunk just to experience the elegant solution to domed structures Will Neptune provided.

Some people live by rules. It makes life simple. Don't ever do this or that. I believe woodworking is best governed by guidelines. Guideline- Don't employ a horizontal grain pin board if you can avoid it. It is potentially weaker and a pain in the hands to waste out the dovetail sockets.

However, I have found by actual experience that in some situations one can skirt this guideline. I have a 30 year old stool where the dovetails lock into horizontal grain, in relatively weak poplar. I built it that way because of the way I wanted it to look. The small "Latta style" bench you were critical of admittedly is not as strong as it could be. If the bench was made from 3/4" pine instead of its 1 1/2" oak I too would doubt its dovetail longevity. But it will last forever holding up a small vice unless it gets relegated to a car ramp for changing oil. Unlikely, since few change their oil at home now days.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#12

Re: Theoretical woodworking.....

William Duffield

You said yourself, in the post above,

"The other issue is the horizontal grain in the pin board leaves the pins prone to splitting."

"Once assembled I am not concerned by the horizontal pin grain." Well, you should be.

I totally reject the concept of a design that does not address the strength of the materials before the aesthetics. Some people who arrogantly title themselves designers, but who ignore the materials, the structure, the functionality or the environment are at best charlatans.

I found a picture of one that I built a long time ago. This is a lot different from yours, especially in that it doesn't have openable doors and the transparent parts are plexiglas, but it is a display case, and I also found a diagram I drew of its joinery.



The bottom and the top are separate construction, and the box that is the case sides sets inside the bottom moldings wherein it is constrained. The top moldings also surround the top of the box. This construction is typical of portable knock-down armoires, which I also have experience repairing and restoring after being delivered and destroyed by "professional" movers. If you need to make the top and bottom stronger, especially to avoid the problem of cross grain end moldings, then make the top and bottom as frame and panel, or even just open frame and attach a secondary top with screws. Even stronger would be to construct the top and bottom as open boxes, with the front and back joined to the sides with dovetails.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#13

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thou

Sgian Dubh

Bill, you're getting a fair amount of grief about your unconventional dovetailing. To an extent I can understand the negative commentary because the chosen construction is relatively weak. Personally I can't see what aesthetic advantage there is in visible dovetails at either the top or bottom of the case you're making - how often are they going to be seen, and who's going to look for them? And if the observer does notice them their reaction will depend upon their knowledge of construction. In my case, being a designer maker, I'd be at least somewhat critical about your choice of construction. The technically unsophisticated observer probably wouldn't know what they're looking at, nor comprehend the oddness of the construction.

For my money, based firstly on not seeing the aesthetic advantage of your construction (you may have a compellingly beneficial aesthetic argument I've missed), and secondly looking for an effective and structurally sound solution for a cabinet not likely to experience much in the way of stress, I'd simply execute a tongue and housing joint with a router - there's going to be insignificant cross grain movement to consider with man made board tongued into a long grain rail. Regarding strength, I've got a tool box on wheels that has been slung about in workshops, the back of vans/cars, shipped back and forth across the Atlantic for over thirty years that's tongue and grooved together: it's still as sound as the day it was built. Slainte.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#14

design reminder & focusing on the wrong weak link

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


It has an applied top. Dovetails will be covered.

The only thing that is going to simultaneously split several 1 1/2" long grain ash pins would be a racking force that would no doubt shatter the doors and probably the bridle joints as well.

That said, I'll bet the dovetails in the plywood will fail first. My critics seem to have overlooked the fact that half the plywood tail is the "wrong" grain orientation. I might just do a test joint to prove the point. I gave considerable though to optimizing long grain pin to half long grain tail. That is why this top has more tails than I would normally use.

Does anyone believe that my construction is weaker than an English drawer with its dainty mahogany pins? The drawer might move daily. This case may not move for years.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#15

Re: Imagine This

William Duffield

I know it's too late at this point to change horses in midstream, so you must go with what you've got and hope the Furies will leave it be.

A more appropriate construction might be to imagine a table, with legs mortised and tenoned to aprons (hinted to in my previous diagram) and a top attached in a traditional manner, with pocket screws in slots. Then imagine turning it over and attaching aprons and another top using the same methods in the new orientation.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#16

Re: Imagine This

Brian Holcombe

William's logical thought process and description of two table tops is excellent, that is an illuminating way to describe what to do with the corner joinery.

If you will take a look here;

http://www.christies.com/lotfinderimages/D59017/a_ming-style_huanghuali_round-corner_tapered_cabinet_yuanjiaogui_qing_d5901771g.jpg

The ming cabinet is an excellent example in this case, the tapered sides are frame and panel, which in the abstract can capture glass rather than wood. The top, also frame and panel is terminated at the corners with what reveals itself as a mitered joint. The mitered corner is constructed using interlocking joinery, in this case a through tenon to lock the miter and another at the top of the post.

The construction further resists racking forces through the use of a panel, lower stretcher, and apron-head spandrel.

I can't imagine it is out of bounds to discuss these sort of construction details, we certainly all have a different approach in mind when we set out to build something but sharing our respective thought processes furthers the forum in my mind. One of the reasons why I enjoy participating in wood central is that there is a certain element to the discussion in which it is not considered inappropriate to discuss detailed aspects of a build outside of a congratulatory manner.

I also participate in Chris Hall's forum where one of my design decisions prompted a 6 page discussion on stretcher to post joinery. My approach was to use a wedged half dovetail, piercing through the post. Chris pointed out to me that the connection was further improved by using a cogged joint, also held tight with a wedge but detailed the possible stretcher to post joints in great detail. The deep dive into the topic was illuminating and improved my previously surface level understanding of the logic involved in choosing between two joints of nearly the same purpose. Ultimately one chooses a dovetail when they cannot gain access to both sides of a post, and one chooses a cogged joint when they can.

I've been the person made example of (drawer slips! :) ) and been the person making example, there is no offense taken on my part and hope that there is no offense taking on the part of any other participant here who might be made example of, in this case Bill.

I find one of the best ways to improve ones own quality is through detailed discussion of the decision making process and further weighing the merit of ultimate choices.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#17

Re: Imagine This

William Duffield

More information about the three way mitered joint


used between the posts and the top of Chinese furniture can be found in Gustav Ecke's book, "Chinese Domestic Furniture." Joel at Tools for Working Wood carries it, and you can find it online on Google Books, with links to other sellers.

Studies of Chris Hall's blog, "The Carpentry Way" will also elucidate applicable oriental joinery methods.

An additional advantage of the Christie's Ming cabinet design and joinery is that the tenons near the bottoms of the posts are offset from each other, so less wood is removed from the same place in the posts.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#18

Re: design reminder & focusing on the wrong weak l

Marc in Mass

I break just about every 'woodworking rule' I have encountered so far and the pieces I build are all over the place, suffering the indignity that most daily used furniture experiences. In the beginning I followed all the common sense ones and still do because they are obvious. Some tricks and hacks escape even the most experienced woodworker at times. I mix woods (a no no I guess), I leave open defects where a fix would look worse but still want to use that piece of wood. I dream up unconventional fasteners and working parts (pulls, hinges, etc.). Methinks that unless you are doing this for a living, throw the rules out the window and do it like you want to. Just be safe doing it. Your mistakes will become clear over time, you will fix them, and you will always be your own critic. All the pieces I have let go to others are still in play and have not needed a recall. For the customer, build it strong and beautiful. For yourself, build it any way you want.

Re: Display case- abnormal dovetails and some thoughts

#19

Re: design reminder & focusing on the wrong weak l

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I suspect your somewhat unconventional dovetailing will hold up more than well enough: time will tell. As to comparative strength with daintily dovetailed drawer fronts to sides, that's a tricky one because of the different type of stress the two constructions are likely to experience in service. Daintily dovetailed drawers generally hold up pretty well from what I've seen of the many antiques and old furniture I've repaired and restored over the years. The most common repairs in such drawers tends to revolve around the runners, slips, the top edge of drawer sides, split drawer bottoms, bottoms bowed or bent because they've shrunk out of the drawer front groove, and bottoms damaged because the sides and/or slips have worn down enough to expose the side groove causing the bottom to abrade against runners and the like.

In truth, I'm not sure of the purpose of the discussion and suggestions of things like three way joints and upside down table rail to leg structures, and so on. They're interesting discussions when pertinent to some types of showcase, but from what I can see they're not especially relevant to your needs because of the rail/stile proportions in your end frames.

As before, I suspect a simple tongue and groove/ housing between the ply top panel and the end frames would have been more than adequate. True, if you wanted to take this joint close to the front/ back edge of your end frame it would have a weakening effect on the bridle joint in the corner, but your dovetails are already taking a significant chunk out of that joint anyway, and any tongue or housing at the same point needn't be deep enough to have such a structurally weakening impact. Slainte.