Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Posts

Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#1

Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Barry Irby

A friend sells and installs stair lifts for a living. They sit on three brackets that sit on the floor or steps and have four screws each into the floor. The base plates are 1/4 steel with predrilled holes for the screws. The screws appear to be No. 10 1 1/2" Pan head with phillips drive. The drive may be whatever passes for phillips/universal. They may accept square drive. Not slotted. They come with the stair lift.

He's getting call backs about the heads of the screws snapping off. He is driving the screws directly into oak without predrilling. He is coating the screws with wax or soap.

I suggested he go to Fastenal or McMaster Carr and get better screws and to predrill the holes to the shank diameter. He looks at me like I may have lost my mind. What say you?

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#2

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

del schisler

here is what i use for stuff like that , i pre-drill with a number 5 tapper drill bit and you can use a 3/8 counter sink but the head is going against the steel , than that can't be used but the tapper drill bit will work , also i see he is using soap which i would do also , i bet he wont have any more problems i use fuller made items which i find is best my 2 cents

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#3

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

John in NM

Sounds like he needs to pre-drill.

If this is a new problem for him, I would bet the manufacturer is using cheaper screws.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#4

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions? *LINK*

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

He is exceeding the tensile strength of the screws. There are two things I would suggest. First, switch to a #12 screw if he is going to stay with sheet metal type screws. For a more secure and permanent fix switch to Timberlok Headlok structural screws. They come in a power drive flat head. They are at least 3 times stronger than what he is using.

Lee


Headlok

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#5

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Ralph Lipeles

I would use wax or bee's wax, not soap. Soap will draw in moisture over the years and end up causing rust.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#6

Vote for pilot hole

Clifton C

Barry, if this is something new, he might be able to blame the screws. It sounds like he thinks drilling a pilot hole is a waste of time. I'm for drilling a pilot hole. I can go a lot faster with a drill and a driver and no wax (soap attracts moisture and can cause other problems) then having to reposition something, like a bracket, after I've popped the head off a screw. Having to stop and fix something slows the flow, and usually burns up more time then realized. As for time savings, what does a callback cost? Well, now I'm working for free, I'm not on a paying job, and, "I got a callback!!!"....

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#7

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Ed Wozniak - Buffalo, NY

Perhaps he is over driving the screws. I recently bought a 12 Volt impact driver. It drives screws easier than my 18 Volt drill but it does not have a clutch. When driving a screw head against a wood surface there is a certain amount of forgiveness if the screw is over driven. When over driven the screw head will sink into the wood. But when driving a screw head against a steel plate that forgiveness is lost. One possibility is that he is over driving the screws. I would vote for stronger screws or a review of his installation technique.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#8

JL

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

JL

Predrill of course.

Another vote for wax. My stepfather's trick was to carry a can of inexpensive paste wax and drag the point of a screw through the wax before sinking. For me - my wife has a a LARGE hunk of wax - she cast me a bunch of votive size candles w/o wicks and I keep one of those in a small screw top can.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#9

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Marvin Horn

Ditto on pilot holes, wax ect.

I've been usining screws from McFeelys for at least 15 years and still have not had one snap off. No connection, just a very satified customer.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#10

Re: Spax

Hank Knight

Spax brand screws are available lots of places and can be ordered online from Amazon, McFeeley's and others. They are high quality steel screws with a universal drive head (Phillips + square drive), and they make #10 pan head screws. Hard to break a spax screw, but it's possible. Spax advertises that pre drilling is unnecessary with their proprietary thread design, but I pre drill anyway, and I would certainly pre drill in oak. Use wax, not soap for reasons already explained. I use paraffin, but most any wax will do.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#11

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

John K Jordan

>>>For me - my wife has a a LARGE hunk of wax - she cast me a bunch of votive size candles w/o wicks and I keep one of those in a small screw top can.

I still have half of that chunk you gave me! Excellent wax.

Did I ever offer you some beeswax? I melted and filtered some from my hives and from another guy.

JKJ

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#12

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

AZ in Colorado Springs

+1 for McFeelys. Their screws are hardened, and if you need to cut the end off to make it shorter, no dikes or pliers are going to do it. They are very strong screws.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like cheap steel to me. I'd tell him to try Spax screws. They're known for their resistance to the head snapping off. They do make a pan-head SMS.

Ellis

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#14

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

james runchey

I use a new wax toilet ring, as I have for many years. I filled a small plastic box with it, works great. Way back when...I drilled a hole in my hammer handle and filled it with wax, used to come in handy. I'd completely forgotten that aspect. Many years since I was a nail pounder. I retired 25 years ago.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#15

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

TomD

He deserves what he gets because his whole process is based on his needs, not those of the customer. much of the advice given, which may be entirely sufficient, is still based on what will do the fastest job. I have a slightly different take on this because I work in the area where cheapness kills, ie boats, and aircraft.

If I get it he is installing body weight lifts for people of possibly compromised health, and the geniuses who are selling the kit are specking the wrong screws, in the wrong grade. There probably is an installation protocol, that can't be what he is doing.

When securing plate, normally flat head machine screws in properly sized countersunk holes are the ticket. Bolts if accessible would be great, but wood screws are probably what the job requires.

It does make one wonder what else in the kit is a dud.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#16

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

walta

From a product liability point of view, it would be mistake to use any hardware not provided or approved by the products manufacture.

If you modify any product its manufacture can’t be held responsible for your decisions.

My wild guess is that that, if he does not have the time to drill a pilot hole he is also in too big a hurry to install all the screws specified. The failing screws were likely weaken by the excessive torque used to drive them without a pilot hole and failed from overloading because many of the required screws are missing or failed on installation and are not present to share the load.

If the product is being installed in accordance with the manufactures instructions and the screws are still failing the manufacture should investigate the failure and correct the faults.

Walta

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#17

Ellis Walentine

Excellent response. Thanks.


Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#18

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

TomD

That is sensible from a liability perspective, though it is hard to imagine a high quality screw that fails in installation in this way without the manufacturer cutting corners. Woods vary significantly in characteristics, very minor misalignment can bind hardware. Pilot hole variations can affect the difficulty of installing the screws. There should be more redundancy built into the system.

I also wonder a tiny bit about the current fad for installing everything with hammer drills, that sounds like the kind of abuse I would avoid were it possible. As far as I know those tools aren't popular specifically because of the extensive work done in optimizing the strength of fasteners installed that way, though in the case of mega long fasteners, it could be part of the picture.

Re: Screw Heads snapping off Questions?

#19

Impact drivers, not hammer drills...

John in NM

Big difference, one hits along the drill axis, the other on a tangent to it.

They are popular because they prevent a lot of damage to the screw head through not camming out the driver bit as often or as badly, and drive screws much more quickly and easily than a drill/driver. Unfortunately it also lets you do silly things like drive regular sheet metal screws into oak without pre-drilling. Not all screws are designed to stand that kind of abuse - and I'll bet you dollars to donuts that the manufacturer of the lift says to pre-drill a hole.