Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Glue line visibility with Titebond III

Posts

Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#1

Glue line visibility with Titebond III

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In an earlier post it was stated that,

"If you're working with a white wood, like maple, Titebond III will leave a noticeable dark line when edge-joining "

I questioned this statement so I did an experiment. Shown is the glue line I got with Titebond III. My conclusion is if one is getting a visible glue line the joint is not prepared accurately.


That said, there are few woodworking applications where it makes sense to use the specialty Titebond glues. The cost, shelf life and irreversibility of these specialty glues makes them an undesirable choice for most furniture assembly.

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#2

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

David Bair

In my experience, your conclusion is incorrect. The photo is too low-res to support either of our observations. Finally, my maple is a lot whiter than your sample.

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#3

I agree

ronster

Sharp knives, good calibration, and good technique can make a thin but not infinitesimal glue line. I'm not always in tune with those requirements. Even when the stars are aligned, I don't mind choosing a glue that somewhat matches the material. What do I have to lose? I'm doing enough projects to justify having more than one glue bottle on the shelf. And if I only wanted one glue on hand, maybe a translucent one would be best, unless its other properties were deficient, which brings me around to why I asked the earlier question.

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#4

more resolution and a glue color discussion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


White things photograph yellowish under my bench lights. The joint is actually poplar to maple, but no matter I can not see a glue line "in person". Compared to "white glue" Titebond regular is not much difference in shade from Titebond III, which indeed is a bit more brown. But as you say, the bottom line is what you see. My purpose was to suggest that everyone may not experience a problem with glue colors in panel construction. It is a different story when a glue line is cut at an oblique angle.

These glues are white as made then tinted yellow for historical reasons. If color was a problem in panel construction Franklin would not be adding color to the glue widely used in furniture manufacture. My friend that ran a factory making panels ordered it in 55 gallon barrels. Then he dyed it pink so that workers could more easily detect when panels were not cleaned up in planing.

But if color is a problem in your work use Titebond White or Elmers white or any other. They are not greatly different from Titebond, being a bit more flexible. Titebond yellow has reversible crosslinking that makes it more ridged at room temperatures.

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#5

Re: more resolution and a glue color discussion

TomD

"They are not greatly different from Titebond, being a bit more flexible. Titebond yellow has reversible crosslinking that makes it more ridged at room temperatures."

What is "reversible" cross linking? That doesn't sound that good...

Rigid sounds good. Luthiers always used Titebond I, but I confess, other than some interest in hide glue, I am not sure what they use today. I was going to ask why anyone making furniture uses any Titebond other than I. I like white glue, but over time almost all the makers who are locally sold stopped selling the stuff, it became difficult to find (there are glues that are white, but not white glues), and as I keep fresh bottle of I around for lutherie, I rather gave up on white glue. It is funny that the original yellow glues became associated with pro grade, when it was slapdash grade, really. Is the color inherent, or is it a dye?

Re: Glue line visibility with Titebond III

#6

Another example

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If this helps ...

I can add another kitchen door in bookmatched Hard Marple and glued with Titebond III (for water- resistance). The joints were glued with Titebond Hide Glue.


Zooming in ...


No dark lines.

Regards from Perth

Derek