Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?
TomD
"My understanding is that most woodworking glues create joints stronger than the wood, if the joint is properly prepared and the glue properly applied and clamped. That would apply to both rigid- and flexible-when-dry glues."
Well... There are several problems with what is probably a correct statement on your part, as far as it goes, and certainly what is widely believed.
1) failure modes, you can put almost any glue sold as a wood glue and apply it to two edges and then break it apart in your hands, and the joint should break in the wood. But that is not the failure mode of most serious failure. I have to assume at least some people are making actual stressed structural products on this board. These include products, like airplanes, boats, bows, guitars, all of which have populous woodworking sub cultures. Another is shop furniture, jigs and home built machines. Others are chairs, cross-grain veneers, edge joints, dovetails. For any of these a longer term non-destructive failure mode is creep, the glue simply morphs under pressure and eventually fails, there are tests for at least epoxies, that you can perform that allow you to rate glues for creep.
The destructive test woodworking mags seem to like to cover are pretty silly, while maybe there are vaudeville routines of the fat person sitting on the weak chair and blowing it to bits, we normally design well within the structural capacities of our materials. Joints fail over time, and that is what we need to concern ourselves with at least to some extent. Not simple breaks along grain lines, because we presumably sized materials to deal with that.
2) Stronger than the surrounding wood test are normally splitting tests. But most of our more difficult structural challenges involve loads that attempt to create long grain continuity. These are the test you want to avoid volunteering for at the local karate club, because wood is strong stuff. So a rung on a chair, a wing spar in an airplane. Most of our fancy, scarph, dovetail, M&T joints are of that type , and the glue will be stressed.
3) While this is increasingly esoteric, we bond other stuff than wood to wood. Or we transition significant loads through heavier materials and species to lighter materials, as with soundboards.