Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

Posts

Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#1

Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

ronster

I've been using Translucent Titebond on my last few projects.

Perhaps, based merely on my observations of dried glue on the tip of the spout, it's more brittle than other formulations.

Anybody have any knowledge about the properties of this product that may impinge on performance?

ron

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#2

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

TomD

Don't know that product, but brittleness, other than having a pejorative tone, is normally a good thing for wood glue. A major failure mode is creep, hard glues are typically less prone to creep. Most assume that soft glues will stretch, but hard glues are generally more likely to weather the storm. Titebond I has a great reputation among the lutherie community where it's hardness is counted on, over any other major brand. Other similar glue champs that are hard are WEST system 105 glues, and hide glue. The emulsion evolved by LMII to deliver higher performance in lutherie that Titebond I is a white glue that is harder still than titebond.

Of course brittle materials are materials we perceive to fail due to their hardness, like glass or peanut brittle. But then glass is actually a major tensile reinforcement when processed correctly. If it stretched like rubber it would not make good fishing rods, arrows, or bows.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#3

What is Translucent Titebond?


Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#4

Properties can.....

Brian Roberts

be researched here:

http://www.titebond.com/product.aspx?id=e06720fc-44f9-42b2-8c5c-77e7d85cf624

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#5

& I had thought flex was good in glue!


Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#6

I was wondering the same

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In any case glue should be tough, not brittle.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#7

Re: & I had thought flex was good in glue!

TomD

Presumably everything has it's uses. But no, generally the issue for getting high performance out of wood and glues is you get creep and the joints fail. They may break, or they may simply print through. Now for a lot of stuff you don't need high performance. For instance the plywood thickness in my 24 foot racing trimaran, and my sock drawer bottom is approximately the same; 1/4". The loads one is dealing with are not the same. In regular woodwork you can get some serious loads though. One example would be gluing together two boards for a table top. I have had the edges in the joint print through after a year. Clearly they had dissimilar expansion ratios, and the glue crept. The joint never separated, one could just feel it running one's hand over it. I don't know of any situations with wood where a hard glue is a problem. Wood is not a namby material. Before they invented materials like fiberglass and carbon fiber it had the highest modulus of elasticity of common materials. And by the time we get it, it is all second hand material. It needs an equally stubborn glue

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#8

One of the best is....

Brian Roberts

hot hide glue....which is brittle when cured and dry.

As relates to glue....dry, hard, and brittle translates to no creep.....which is one of the disadvantages of white or yellow glues.

As with anything it depends on what properties you seek.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#9

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

don stephan

Darryl Keil in his veneering videos always talks in terms of dried glues being rigid or flexible. The test is to lay out a thin sheet of glue on a piece of glass or plastic film, and see if it bends at all when dry. The relevance would be a glue joint that stands proud slightly after six months, or a bent lamination that has springback when released from clamps. Not sure if one should equate the terms brittle and rigid for dried glue.

My understanding is that most woodworking glues create joints stronger than the wood, if the joint is properly prepared and the glue properly applied and clamped. That would apply to both rigid- and flexible-when-dry glues.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#10

I still don't get it?

Dick Coers

Glue needs to be translucent inside the joint? I'm certainly not going to leave a bead exposed on my work, but Franklin thinks the new woodworker leaves the squeeze out on their work and they need a new product? Sad.....

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#11

Re: & I had thought flex was good in glue!

TomD

For instance, in making wood composite bows, we use heat to cure the glue to raise the hardness and to raise the glass transition temperature below which is it hard like glass, so to speak. This is important because bows are used in conditions where it can be quite hot, and so you need that hardness over a range well above comfortable room temperature cures. The thing is that the epoxy left in the joint is normally very thin, so it will be flexible like a piece of stainless steel foil wrap. It won't snap, but it won't creep either.

A classic failure with a bow is that it overheats in the trunk of a car and when taken out and strung it delaminates or critically deforms. Soft glue at room temperature is the same kind of problem, but as stated what degree of strength one needs varies.

Another example of rock hard glues are the phenolics used in plywood. They are harder than epoxies in my experience.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#12

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

TomD

"My understanding is that most woodworking glues create joints stronger than the wood, if the joint is properly prepared and the glue properly applied and clamped. That would apply to both rigid- and flexible-when-dry glues."

Well... There are several problems with what is probably a correct statement on your part, as far as it goes, and certainly what is widely believed.

1) failure modes, you can put almost any glue sold as a wood glue and apply it to two edges and then break it apart in your hands, and the joint should break in the wood. But that is not the failure mode of most serious failure. I have to assume at least some people are making actual stressed structural products on this board. These include products, like airplanes, boats, bows, guitars, all of which have populous woodworking sub cultures. Another is shop furniture, jigs and home built machines. Others are chairs, cross-grain veneers, edge joints, dovetails. For any of these a longer term non-destructive failure mode is creep, the glue simply morphs under pressure and eventually fails, there are tests for at least epoxies, that you can perform that allow you to rate glues for creep.

The destructive test woodworking mags seem to like to cover are pretty silly, while maybe there are vaudeville routines of the fat person sitting on the weak chair and blowing it to bits, we normally design well within the structural capacities of our materials. Joints fail over time, and that is what we need to concern ourselves with at least to some extent. Not simple breaks along grain lines, because we presumably sized materials to deal with that.

2) Stronger than the surrounding wood test are normally splitting tests. But most of our more difficult structural challenges involve loads that attempt to create long grain continuity. These are the test you want to avoid volunteering for at the local karate club, because wood is strong stuff. So a rung on a chair, a wing spar in an airplane. Most of our fancy, scarph, dovetail, M&T joints are of that type , and the glue will be stressed.

3) While this is increasingly esoteric, we bond other stuff than wood to wood. Or we transition significant loads through heavier materials and species to lighter materials, as with soundboards.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#13

Re: I still don't get it?

David Bair

If you're working with a white wood, like maple, Titebond III will leave a noticeable dark line when edge-joining or setting flush-cut plugs.

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#14

Re: I still don't get it?

Dick Coers

Do TB III and Translucent have the water resistant rating?

Re: Is Translucent Titebond more brittle?

#15

Re: I still don't get it?

David Bair

Translucent Titebond is "Not recommend for exterior use or where moisture is likely."