Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

Posts

Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#1

Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

Barry Irby

I have a Dewalt lunch box planer, Model 733. It's the older version that has two resharpenable knives. The newer versions have disposable knives. I knew there was a Byrd/Shelix head available for the newer ones, but thought I was out of luck with the older unit. Today in discussing my jointer with Byrd they tell me they make heads for The 733 , 734, and 735 models. Now comes the quandary about whether to replace my head or buy a new machine. The head for mine is $470.

Just thought I would throw out the fact that the heads are available for the older versions.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#2

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

John McGaw

Wish mine would be so cheap! For my Robland X31 it would be $971.50 excluding new bearings ($55) and some unknown amount for shipping. I think I'll be sticking with my old instant change blades which I replaced the original wide heavy steel knives with.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#3

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

William Duffield

I no longer have a 733, but i have some observations: It has disposable blades, which are easy to change, reducing your maintenance labor costs, but increasing recurring equipment costs vs. other non-helical heads.

It also has a tendency to destroy drive chains and sprockets, leading to high maintenance costs and considerable down time, if you are not very careful about how you feed it. I suspect a helical head would put less load on these components, thereby decreasing costs, but it is not clear to me that this would be significant.

That planer is very loud, but I don't know how much of the noise comes from the universal motor and the drive train vs. the head. Helical heads are quieter than heads with blades, but without listening to one, I don't know if it would make a significant difference. I would never operate the DW 733 without hearing protection, but I often run a board or two through the PM 15HH that replaced it without putting on the ear muffs.

I also have lots of rough cut hardwood lumber between 12" and 15" in width. If nothing else, that made my decision to replace mine a no-brainer.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#4

I understood these heads took more HP *LINK*

Dick Coers

"And one disadvantage

There is one surprising difference with helical cutter heads over straight-knife machines: Helical cutter heads take more effort to feed. If you were to install a helical cutter in your jointer, you will notice that it takes more effort to push the board through the machine. The reason is simple. Previously, the wood only met with resistance from the spinning knives three or four times per rotation (depending on how many knives your machine has). With a helical cutter head, there is always at least one knife in contact with the wood, thus constant resistance to your push. As a result of this, planers and jointers typically use more horsepower when a helical cutter head is installed."


This won't help those driveline issues!


https://www.canadianwoodworking.com/tools/introduction-helical-cutter-heads

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#5

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

Jim Dillon

Barry, good to know although the $470 gives me pause. My 733 is still going strong after 20 years although I did have to replace a sprocket several years ago. And replacing the blades went smoothly a few years ago as well. For now, I am content. When I do encounter tearout, I can usually minimize the problem by lightly dampening the surface of the wood and taking very light cuts. And I've tried to improve my ability to read the grain to anticipate problems. Noise wise, yes the 733 is noisy but I always use ear muffs so that is a nonissue for me. In the future however... . Thanks for letting us know about the availability of the Byrd/Shelix head for the model 733. Jim

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#6

Interesting.....

Barry Irby

I wonder if they measured this or if its just an assumption? On the edge of a board there would be one 3/4" cutter engaged at a time, very nearly like straight knives. The skew angle might increase the "apparent " thickness of the board but not by a lot. On a wider board the spiral shape would mean that only part of the spiral is engaged at any given time, but part of each spiral might come into play simultaneously. It seems this would make feeding smoother. The two or three knife head would "bite" and release thousands of times a minute. Probably so frequently the vibration would be dampened. Hmmm?

I will get my new jointer head in a week or so. Obviously I will try it. I will try to judge if there is a noticeable difference in feeding the board. Something to look forward to.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#7

Re: I understood these heads took more HP

William Duffield

Thanks for the correction. It is surprising, and almost counterintuitive.

Since the cutters are hitting the wood more or less continuously, instead of impulsively, it seems to me that the vibrational forces on the drive train should be reduced, or at least smoothed out, depending on how you want to look at it, except at the individual cutters.

There are lots of forces and effects that could cause a difference in the feed force required, including differences in depth of cut, cutting angle of the heads, sharpness of the edges (high carbon steel blades can usually be sharpened more finely than carbide), lubrication of the tables, different bearings, etc. New bearings could also run stiffer initially. Psychological differences include responses to the noise level and pitch and vibrational feedback. A lot of people would be tempted to set an intrinsically quieter machine for a more aggressive cut.

In any case, it's going to be a difficult decision, and only partly due to the physical parameters we can control.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#8

Re: I understood these heads took more HP

john lucas

I don't have a helix head on my Steel City jointer but it has the same carbide teeth spaced out so at least 2 or more teeth are cutting all the time. The lack of resistance when I feed a board through vs my older steel knife jointer is amazing. The noise is also tremendously reduced. I only paid $230 for my 735 Dewalt and since I don't do a lot of flat wood work anymore it's really hard to justify the helix head. But based on how easy my jointer works I now really wish I could justify it.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#9

I don't get that ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

"And one disadvantage

There is one surprising difference with helical cutter heads over straight-knife machines: Helical cutter heads take more effort to feed. If you were to install a helical cutter in your jointer, you will notice that it takes more effort to push the board through the machine. The reason is simple. Previously, the wood only met with resistance from the spinning knives three or four times per rotation (depending on how many knives your machine has). With a helical cutter head, there is always at least one knife in contact with the wood, thus constant resistance to your push. As a result of this, planers and jointers typically use more horsepower when a helical cutter head is installed."

This won't help those driveline issues!

https://www.canadianwoodworking.com/tools/introduction-helical-cutter-heads

That is contrary to all I have read, and in my experience.

I have a Hammer A3-31 with spiral heads. The machine is recommended to use 20 amps. That may be the case, but I believe the recommendation was made when the straight blades were the only option. My machine is plugged into a 15 amp plug, and is very happy. In fact, under load, an electrician friend of mine measured the load needs at below 10 amps.

As I understand it, the impact of a single, straight blade striking the wood is far greater than several small blades that are both angled for a slicing cut, as well as spaced (on a spiral) for individual strikes.

This must reduce impact force. As an analogy, it is the same for a shooting board using a plane with a skewed blade, or a ramped shooting board with a straight blade. Both of these offer a progressive cut and create less impact than a flat shooting board with straight blade.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#11

Not in my experience

John in NM

All else being equal, I could see the shearing cut requiring slightly more power as the blade length is effectively longer.

In reality the vastly easier cutting action of the carbide inserts offsets this and then some. I planed a whole mess of ipe when mine was new and a year later (light use since) it still cuts much easier than the straight steel blades did even when new.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#12

Re: I understood these heads took more HP

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

In my experience, helical cutters on my 8" jointer require much more effort. While I would never switch back to straight knives, I was surprised at the difference.

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#13

Re: I understood these heads took more HP

John K Jordan

I've read experiences and impressions both way. I haven't yet seen any hard data. I don't know much about helical heads but I wonder if these varied impressions are from equivalent heads. There may be several variables: the actual cutters, depth of cut, the specific board, perhaps the speed and HP of the motor. (I read somewhere that the helical cutters may work better at slower speeds.) Any more variables? The phase of the moon?

I have a new 8" PM jointer with straight blades that I bought long ago but have not yet uncrated. However I've already decided to upgrade it to a helical head as soon as I set it up. There seem to be many advantages!

I'm thinking this would be a good time to try a couple of tests to try to put some numbers on any differences. My thoughts: use the same board of hard maple or something to joint a face with the straight knives. Push with a block with a compression gauge built in to measure the force used. Monitor the amperage pulled by the motor during the cut. Repeat several times. Then swap out the head and try the same test on the same board.

Any ideas on this?

JKJ

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#14

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

Tony-Memphis

I replaced the cutter head on my 735 a few years ago with the Byrd cutter (Shelix?). Santa brought it to me! I have been pretty pleased with it. I broke a few cutters initially. I think I may have over torqued them? Now, one thing to note is that the finish is not as smooth as I got with the knives. There are some "sandpaper height" ridges left. That doesn't bother me. Especially when I run a piece of highly figured crazy grained wood through it and it comes out smooth with no tear out. Doesn't seem to matter which way you feed it either. I'd like to have a jointer with the shelix type, but I am going to wait for when I upgrade from my 6" to an 8". As for the power issue, I have no idea. Don't think it matters.

Tony

Re: Shelix Cutter head for Dewalt Planer????

#15

Re: I understood these heads took more HP

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I prefer to take light cuts with the jointer, but it's possible that I may be taking a deeper cut with the Shelix head installed. One thing I would be sure to measure correctly is the depth of cut, and I'd do that by using a set of dial calipers to measure the difference in thickness of the board before and after the cuts on each head, then adjust the cut depth accordingly. Please let us know the results of your tests.