I am beginning to do some marquetry. My first little projects were glued up using cauls and clamps. Now I have a Thin Air Press - a simple vacuum press that uses a manual pump to extract the air. I have created a panel for a cabinet door - about 12 X 17 inches.
The information on the company web site showed using the vacuum press by simply wrapping the marquetry panel with open mesh. Other techniques I have seen use sheets of wax paper and mdf cauls on either side of the panel.
You need the mesh to help push out the air and trap the bag. I'm not so sure it'd leave marks on a marquetry panel with sensitive work on it.
When I've veneered tabletops with that bag, I'd place a piece of MDF that's a little larger than the panel and then the mesh to pull everything down and keep it square.
I am not sure I understand the question. I do what I learned in the Mack Headley shop. The layers from bottom to top: bag, a flat surface( in my case 3/4" coated MDF), item to be veneered, plastic mesh, bag.
Air pressing on the top through the mesh is guaranteed to apply uniform pressure, 15 pounds per square inch.......2000 pounds per square foot!
Johanna I'm not familiar with your thin air system, but did a quick search. It looks like the tube or hose connects right in the middle of the top side of the panel. The only place you need mesh is on that top side of the caul, otherwise using a caul of something like melamine would be like putting a stopper in the line where it enters the bag. Using screen-back Masonite for a caul would be a good choice since it already has the air paths pressed in.
All I've ever used were bags that I've made myself, using sheet vinyl from 54" wide rolls bought from an automotive upholstery supply near my shop. I make the bags by folding the sheet back over onto itself then gluing the sides. In the corner of the fold, I bring a short section of hose in, with a heavy wad of caulk around it to seal the corner.. On the inside end of the hose, I have an old shirtsleeve taped around the hose, that I always make sure is in contact with the edge of the stack of parts / cauls. I used to try to have a sheet of something like your screen on top, but have found, that there is enough of an air path around the edges to evacuate the air from the stack without anything else.
Now, I use epoxy for almost all my bagging, due to the fact that I'm working alone and this gives me plenty of open time to get all the glue spread, taped into bundles, then fed into the bags, then sealed before the vacuum gets drawn.
I tape the thin .5 mil plastic drop cloth to my cauls ahead of time to keep them from sticking to the work. For marquetry you will probably want to have that laying face up on top of the bottom caul, then place your door panel on top of it, rather than trying to pick up the veneer after it's glued.
I don't know what glue you are using, but if it is slow setting, and used without a caul, you might have a problem with glue flowing under toward that hose connection right out in the middle of the work. it could pull up a little bump that gets sanded through before the area around it gets smoothed out.
As for using a hand pump, I don't know how that is going to work out. I wouldn't want to try that. Your going to be as busy as a one armed paper hanger, if there is a leak in the bag, which there always are. If you don't have a gauge, you can tell by feeling of the wrinkles how good the vacuum is, or where a leak is if they are tighter in one area, then soft near the leak.
Good luck with the project, and let us know how it turns out.
Discalimer: I have vacuum veneered a few doors and drawers but do not consider myself highly experienced.
I would think option 1 superior and use it It ensures equal pressure on the veneer. If the surface underneath the veneered object is flat option 1 ensures the result is flat. I do not see any benefit to a top caul. In fact, if it is less than perfectly flat all around there may not be uniform pressure on the veneer.
I did a fair amount of veneering in a vacuum bag a few years ago. Unfortunately it has been long enough that I don't remember the details well, but I do recall having trouble around the edges of the panels unless I used a top caul that was slightly larger than the work. Preferably, the caul should be about the thickness of the caul or less bigger than the piece. If the caul is too large, it will bow at the edges and "fold" down, creating a bulge around the edge of the panel. If I tried to get away without a caul, I got poorly done edges. If the veneer over hangs the edges you get a little bulge. If it over hangs too far, it breaks. I think sometimes the glue flows toward the edges but then gets trapped as a bulge because the pressure "seals" the veneer down at the very edge.
I have had good luck with melamine faced cauls and with polyethylene over the product. I have used nylon window screen to let it breath. I have done panels without a caul, but with poly and screen and used a roller to be sure the glue was full squeezed out. Have not experienced the little bump at the vacuum inlet valve, but did go hmmmm?
I agree. However (to be picky, or to be perfectly clear, depending on your point of view), your description has left out a couple of important details. Between the "item to be veneered" and the "plastic mesh" you should list "veneer glue" and "veneer". It might also be useful to those who would follow the instructions to point out that any veneer tape used to piece the veneer together should go ON TOP OF the veneer, not between the veneer and the glue. DAMHIKT!
I also know some folk who use mesh on the outside of cauls to protect the bag from sharp edges. Its a little quicker than putting a roundover on the outside edge of the caul which I usually do.
And just a nit for the sake of any newbies to veneering - you should place veneer on both sides of the substrate when gluing up. The glue introduces a huge amount of moisture onto the substrate and having one side dry and one wet is a good way to get a cup in the piece.
Unless the caul is stiff to hundreds if not thousands of pounds of force it must not overhand the part being veneered. If either the caul, if you use one, or the veneer overhangs much there is risk of buckling at the edge and resulting poor contact of veneer at the edge.
Ideally the veneer should be the same size as the substrate and the caul, if you use one, also the same size. The part veneered is then trimmed to finish size after the veneer is done.
When veneering, the adhesive seldom is laid down in a perfectly uniform and flat layer. The purpose of the caul is to force the adhesive into a perfectly uniform and flat layer under the veneer. I've pressed hundreds of panels of all sizes, but not with your system - I'm using a commercial vacuum bag and electric vacuum pump.
Well, things did not go all that well. The veneer wrinkled.
There was evidently a leak that, in spite of my checking the sealing strip, resulted in a gradual loss of vacuum.
I think I used too much glue. I also should have used some MDF cauls in the "sandwich".
I sanded out most of the wrinkles, but in two small places I sanded through the veneer.
Now my options are: 1) try to repair the two places where I sanded through, or 2) start over. I think I will start over because I also would like to change some of the shaded areas.
I would like to post a picture, but the option to browse for it is not showing up. It's easy to include a picture in an original post, but I never seem to be able to do it in a reply.
>>>...I would like to post a picture, but the option to browse for it is not showing up. It's easy to include a picture in an original post, but I never seem to be able to do it in a reply.
Johanna,
Have you read the vacuum veneering info on the Joe Woodworker site?
He has plans for a vacuum press/clamp/chucking system that has a vacuum reservoir and controls to maintain a strong and consistent vacuum for extended times. I don't do a lot veneering myself but I got all the components and intend to use his plans for a multi-use vacuum system.
Also, Joe is an incredibly nice and helpful person! He seems always happy to help over the phone.
As for the photo, do you not get the "Upload embedded file: Browse" button just above the text reply box?
The rule I have used with urea formaldehyde glue is to roll it out, then drag a finger through it. If a slight ridge of glue is formed on each side of the drag, the amount of glue is okay. Don't know if that test works for other types of glue.
"He has plans for a vacuum press/clamp/chucking system that has a vacuum reservoir and controls to maintain a strong and consistent vacuum for extended times"
Any vacuum pump worth buying can be turned on, and left on for the duration of the process. An engineer friend who didn't understand vacuum pumps bought a used lab pump and then proceed to build this complex arrangement of reservoir and pressure switches to turn the pump on and off as needed during the glue cure.
Upon seeing it all I blurted out, "what the hell is all that for". He proceeded to explain its elegant function. I pointed out that the kind of pump he had was designed to be turned on and run for hours or days to maintain vacuum in lab experiments. Overnight operation is typical for vacuum drying. Turning it on and off was the worst thing he could do to it.
In lab situations I have run the small diaphragm pumps, often bought for vacuum veneering, for hours on end. They are expected to run this way. That said, perhaps someone is making delicate vacuum pumps solely for vacuum veneering. If so, avoid them. If the pump can not run for 2 hours, more than enough time to set glue that sets by loosing water, avoid it.
Nothing beats a 6" foam paint roller for glue application. The only requirement for optimum glue bond is that each surface be wet with glue. One can achieve this situation by slathering enough on one surface to ensure the other wets, or better I think, is to put on a thin layer on each surface before joining. Wetting both surfaces with a thin layer of glue is something I practice for any glue application- panels, dovetails, mortise and tenon, etc.
I spread it like I was painting with a paint roller. When it looks uniformly wet, that is enough. I do not agree that slathering on glue until you can't see a pencil line is optimum. That is more glue than necessary and more than necessary results in a weak joint and excessive cure time.
In the end it only takes a glue layer 3 molecules thick for where the mating surfaces touch for the best joint strength.
Glue is less than 50% glue and the rest water. Where ever there is a puddle of glue there will be glue "foam" when the water leaves. And it may take hours for the water to leave rather than minutes for an optimum glue thickness. Glue foam is much weaker than a solid glue line. More in NOT better when gluing.
One should be veneering panels somewhat bigger than the final size and then trimming. This approach avoids the overhang issues in vacuum veneering.
The cut-offs provide test pieces to see how well the veneer stuck. Examining these test pieces will give the person learning to veneer feedback on their technique.
You are absolutely correct. During my working life as an Engineer, my factory had many workstations where we applied a Vacuum in the "nest" so the part was held securely while the operator stacked up additional parts. These stations had small (1/4 hp) Gast vane type vacuum pumps that ran constantly 8 to 16 hrs./day. We did wear out the vanes occasionally after years of use. I am quite sure all of the pumps we used would have outlasted the life of any woodworker that did a LOT of vacuum veneer work.
I suspect that's true. The design is attractive to me in part since I don't want the dang thing running constantly and unnecessarily when I'm in the shop.
My response was directed only at the application of the original poster, marquetry, and not mortise and tenon and other hardwood joinery. For this application of adhering a layer of veneer onto a substrate I would not mention in a reply applying glue to both surfaces, only the substrate for the marquetry.
It is always advantageous to have the veneer or marquetry sheet slightly larger than the needed final dimensions, so there is allowance for trimming to final size. It is also advantageous to have the caul slightly longer and wider than the veneer or marquetry sheet.
But if the substrate is longer and/or wider than the veneer or marquetry sheet, the applied glue is exposed around the edges and a smear can get wiped onto the bag, the caul, et cetera.
I like a veneer or marquetry sheet and caul both slightly longer and wider than the substrate, 1/8" for a half inch thick caul and 3/8" for a 3/4" thick caul. The caul overhang prevents the veneer overhang from getting damaged, all is not lost if there is slight shifting as the sandwich of substrate/veneer/caul is slid into the bag, and reduced chance of a glue smear.
Your official WoodCentral profile has username "johannaj". When you post, you need to use that exact username and your johannaj@comcast.net email address or else the system won't recognize you and you won't have the photo uploading and text formatting options of membership.
You have a couple options here. One is for me to delete your current profile and let you re-register with your full name, if that's what you'd prefer to be using. Or, you can go to the Set Preferences link (in the gray navigation bar on each forum) and enter your registered profile username. This will reset your cookie so that our software will recognize you on that board. Either solution will reinstate your photo posting privileges.
I could tell this was a profile issue because if "Johanna Johanson" was a registered username, it would have shown up as a hyperlink (blue text, underlined). Instead it showed up as black text.
Let me know if you'd like me to delete your current profile.